I embarked on reading this book with a certain degree of trepidation. "Consider Phlebas" holds a special place as one of my all-time favorite Sci-Fi novels. I firmly believed it was a perfect piece in its own right, and thus, I saw no need to explore further into that particular world. However, under the pressure from my friends, I reluctantly began delving into a few other books, and this one happened to be the first after "Consider Phlebas".
It has to be said that the book was very well-written. The prose was engaging, and the story had the potential to be truly captivating. However, as I reached the end, I was left with a sense of disappointment. Frankly speaking, the ending was rather stupid. I simply couldn't fathom why this book had been recommended to me as being better than "Consider Phlebas".
One of the major drawbacks of this book was the excessive amount of exposition and explanation. It was evident that the author had written it with an Earth-bound modern-day audience in mind. This was in stark contrast to "Consider Phlebas", which seemed to be written for someone who was a part of that fictional world. In "Consider Phlebas", the notes and afterword served a purpose, only explaining the more obscure historical aspects that people within that world might not have been familiar with. Otherwise, the book treated the reader as if everything that happened should be more or less familiar in concept, even when it was completely insane by Earth standards. In this book, however, the situation was even worse. There was direct insight into the Mind's communications, which made them seem like petulant children. I felt that I should never have been able to understand the communication between Minds, much less be privy to it. There was one truly awful line in the book that went something like: "lol there once was a planet that killed people with electric chairs BUT GET THIS they also banned 'cruel and unusual punishment' loloolololololol". This line almost made me put the book down right then and there.
I am almost sorry that I read this book at all. However, now that I've somewhat tarnished my knowledge of the Culture, I might as well continue reading. I guess I have no other choice but to see where this journey takes me.