She Comes First bills itself as a guide for thinking men when it comes to sex, particularly those eager to please women. However, I'm skeptical that it truly caters to the thinking crowd. The author attempts to showcase intelligence and humor by frequently referring to Strunk & White's The Elements of Style, but it comes across more as a show-off flaunting their high IQ, similar to this.
The book begins with a cursory overview of women's sexual anatomy and a brief discussion on foreplay, with a passing mention that each woman's needs vary. Sounds good?
Not really. The remainder of the book seems to primarily focus on pleasuring a woman orally, following a specific formula that fails to consider that what works for one may not work for another. What if your partner doesn't enjoy oral sex? Well, if this book is your go-to for sexy times, both you and your partner are likely to be disappointed.
Here are my list of problems with this book:
First, as I've already noted, this book assumes that women can only orgasm through oral sex. While some women do enjoy it, basic logic tells us that just because some people like something, not everyone does. Teaching only oral techniques as a means to orgasm is as dangerous as Freud's claim that a clitoral orgasm is inferior to a vaginal orgasm. It's essentially a man imposing his desires on women.
Second, this book neglects communication and consent. Maybe communication isn't an issue if you're too busy following a script? Or if you have preconceived notions of what to do? I'm not sure. Suffice it to say, instead of encouraging couples to talk about their wants and desires and learn what each partner likes, this book emphasizes that oral sex is the only way.
Third, men who buy this book take it as gospel and end up disappointing both their significant others and themselves. Meanwhile, Ian Kerner can cash in on your purchase. Bad for you, great for him. I firmly believe that this book is targeted at bros who pretend to be interested in their partner's pleasure but are really only looking out for their own.
Finally, my biggest issue is the popularity of this book. There are far better books out there that explain women's sexual anatomy without presuming a particular way that the person in front of you wants to be pleasured.
For other options, try The Clitoral Truth: The Secret World at Your Fingertips or Women's Anatomy Of Arousal: Secret Maps To Buried Pleasure. Both offer in-depth looks at women's anatomy. They also touch on political or spiritual themes that I feel detract from their main point, but otherwise, they are solid. Books that focus on communication or the psychology of sex and arousal, such as Come as You Are: The Surprising New Science that Will Transform Your Sex Life, would also be better choices.
I gave up about halfway through. Maybe there are redeeming parts later in the book, but if so, Mr Kerner presents the information too late and in too little quantity.