Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 55 votes)
5 stars
24(44%)
4 stars
12(22%)
3 stars
19(35%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
55 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Esquerdalladas 101

is a rather interesting and perhaps somewhat mysterious topic. It seems to suggest a certain set of ideas or actions that are related to the left or leftist ideology. While the phrase "pa eso no está mal" implies that there is something not bad about it.

It could potentially refer to a variety of things. Maybe it's about a particular approach to social or political issues that those on the left believe in. It might involve ideas such as equality, social justice, and a more inclusive society.

Or perhaps it's related to a specific group or movement that identifies with the left. This could include political parties, activist organizations, or simply a community of like-minded individuals who share similar values and goals.

In any case, Esquerdalladas 101

seems to be a topic that is worth exploring further to understand its full meaning and implications.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Although I have liked it, I have missed more depth in the educational policies and programs.

How are they formulated, who makes them and under what criteria, etc. It focuses more on the messages and the mindset that comes through the media and politics, almost exclusively in the United States.

It would be beneficial to have a more comprehensive exploration of educational policies and programs worldwide. This could include analyzing the different approaches taken by various countries, the impact of cultural and social factors on education, and the effectiveness of different educational models.

By delving deeper into these aspects, we can gain a better understanding of how to improve education and ensure that all students have access to high-quality learning opportunities.

Moreover, it is important to consider the role of educators, parents, and students themselves in the development and implementation of educational policies and programs. Their perspectives and experiences can provide valuable insights and help to shape more effective and inclusive educational systems.

Overall, while the current focus on messages and the mindset is interesting, a more in-depth examination of educational policies and programs is needed to truly understand and address the complex issues facing education today.
July 15,2025
... Show More

I do think that reading Chomsky is always a pleasure. However, this book didn't offer me much. Firstly, I was looking to read something more closely related to education itself. The title is misleading as the book actually deals with other topics. Although something can be salvaged in relation to the theme I was seeking, it is not specifically a book where the author discusses education in and of itself or its derivatives.

Perhaps if the title had been more accurately reflective of the content, my expectations would not have been so high. Nevertheless, Chomsky's work is always thought-provoking, and even in this instance, there are still some interesting ideas to be found. It just didn't quite meet my needs in terms of a focused exploration of education.

Overall, while I may not have been entirely satisfied with this particular book, I will continue to read Chomsky's other works in the hope of finding more in-depth discussions on the topics that interest me.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I have become even more interested when he was talking about the American educational system (the first 50 pages).

The American educational system is indeed a topic that holds great significance and fascination. It has its own unique characteristics and structures that have evolved over time.

The first 50 pages likely delved into various aspects such as the history, curriculum, teaching methods, and assessment systems.

Learning about the American educational system can provide valuable insights into different educational approaches and how they impact students' development and future prospects.

It may also offer opportunities for comparison and reflection, allowing us to consider how certain elements could be adapted or improved in our own educational contexts.

Overall, this exploration of the American educational system has piqued my curiosity and has left me eager to learn more about its intricacies and implications.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Incredible retelling as to what media distortion can do to sway public disinformation on public policy.

Media distortion has the power to have a profound impact on public perception and understanding of public policy. It can lead to the spread of misinformation and false narratives that can influence public opinion and decision-making.

For example, a media outlet may selectively report on certain aspects of a policy while ignoring others, or may present a one-sided view that is not representative of the full picture. This can cause the public to form inaccurate opinions and make decisions based on false information.

In addition, media distortion can also lead to the amplification of certain voices and perspectives while silencing others. This can create an unbalanced and unfair public discourse that does not reflect the diversity of views and interests within society.

It is essential that the media plays a responsible role in reporting on public policy and presenting accurate and objective information. This requires journalists to be vigilant in fact-checking and verifying their sources, and to present a balanced and comprehensive view of the issues at hand.

By doing so, the media can help to ensure that the public is well-informed and able to make informed decisions about public policy.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Love the guy, and I truly agree with everything he says. However, this is far from being his best work.

These Chomsky interview books typically have him repeating the same things over and over again in each and every book. Sadly, this one is no exception.

I initially thought it might be different because it is labeled as a book on education. But, to my disappointment, it only briefly touches upon these topics before quickly reverting back to the familiar and timeworn topics he always discusses. These include Nicaragua, Central America, South America, Vietnam, Israel, and US atrocities, among others.

The attempt to connect all this stuff to education was, at best, half-hearted. It is definitely not one of his better books.

In conclusion, while I still have a great deal of respect for Chomsky, this particular book fails to live up to the expectations I had.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Everyone interested in understanding what has happened (and is happening) in Central America should read this book.

This book offers a comprehensive and in-depth exploration of the rich and complex history, culture, politics, and social issues of Central America. It delves into the region's past, from its ancient civilizations to the present day, uncovering the events, people, and ideas that have shaped its development.

By reading this book, readers will gain a deeper appreciation and understanding of the unique challenges and opportunities that Central America faces. They will also learn about the region's diverse cultures, languages, and traditions, and how they have interacted and influenced one another over time.

Whether you are a student, a scholar, a traveler, or simply someone with an interest in Central America, this book is a must-read. It provides a wealth of information and insights that will help you to better understand this fascinating and dynamic region.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This book is certainly stimulating.

However, the only con for me is that it makes many sociological digressions.

If one is not familiar with the theme, they may be difficult or heavy to deal with.

In any case, it conveys very transparent and authentic messages about the school system as a unique entity with society.

It explores various aspects of how the school system functions within the larger social context.

The author delves into the relationships, interactions, and the impact of social factors on education.

Despite the challenges posed by the digressions, the book offers valuable insights and perspectives.

It encourages readers to think critically about the role of the school system and its connection to society.

Overall, it is a thought-provoking read that can enhance our understanding of this important topic.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I had read this a few years ago and completely forgotten every single detail of it.

If that doesn't serve as a sufficient review, let me elaborate further.

Sometimes, a die-hard Chomsky fan will go to extremes and pick up anything that has the C-man's name attached to it, without much rational thought.

This book is precisely one such example.

Not only that, but this book also reveals that some of these Chomsky fans will even take it a step further and edit and introduce a Chomsky book based on some truly terrible Chomsky interviews.

The beginning of the book is okay, although it is based on ideas that anyone who has read works like Manufacturing Consent or Understanding Power will quickly recognize.

It seems that in the process of idolizing Chomsky, some fans have lost their objectivity and critical thinking skills, leading to the production of works like this that may not accurately represent Chomsky's true ideas or the quality of his work.

Perhaps it's time for Chomsky fans to take a step back and reevaluate their approach to his work, ensuring that they are not blindly following and promoting something that may not be worthy of such adulation.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I am quite angry with this book because after reading it, you feel cheated.

The topic dealt with in the book is very interesting if what you are looking to read is the history of American imperialism and its constant system of manipulation over society and the world (although the very well-documented data are a bit outdated today, but the political position of the US is still valid).

However, the title and the synopsis are in bad taste for those who were really looking for the techniques for a more free and less alienating education. Yes, it mentions in passing the relationship between education and democracy through a brief introduction after which it begins a dissertation on American imperialism that becomes boring when you see that it never gets to talk about education.

And frankly, I prefer how the great Eduardo Galeano draws the global political scenario and documents the atrocities of the corrupt and imperialists; Chomsky gets tangled up like a baroque blind.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The book is composed of several distinct parts that are unified under a common theme.

Specifically, the piece 'Democracy and Education' which is excerpted from Chomsky's 1994 speech at Loyola, where he endorses and defends John Dewey, is truly worthy of 4 or 5 stars. It offers profound insights into the relationship between democracy and education.

The piece 'Market Democracy in a Neoliberal Order' also earns a solid 4 stars. It delves into the complex nature of market democracy within a neoliberal framework.

As for the rest of the parts, they receive a rating of 3 or 4 stars as they are a bit uneven. Each part, on its own, is good enough. However, they all share a common thread: exploring the role of the media and complicit journalists in constructing the controlling narratives that uphold and justify the established power of the U.S. government.

It should be noted that several chapters are also available in other books. If you are encountering this content for the first time, it can be excellent and eye-opening. But if you have already read Chomsky's other works, it may seem more of the same.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Noam Chomsky's works are always interesting to read, and this one is no exception.

However, the problem lies in the editing itself, which leads to deception. "La (des) educación" has little to nothing to do with education itself (despite the title and the bust with a cap that appears on the cover).

The first chapter includes very light references to the topic, and from there on what we find is a compilation of conferences and interviews that mainly revolve around the continued denunciation that Chomsky has exercised towards the foreign policy of the United States in Central America (with Nicaragua as the center of gravity).

In that sense, one comes out much more informed and much more critical after reading the volume, but not about the subject that has been announced.

Overall, while the content within the book is valuable in its own right, the misrepresentation in the title and initial impression can be a bit disappointing for those who were specifically looking for in-depth exploration of the education theme.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.