Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 67 votes)
5 stars
24(36%)
4 stars
24(36%)
3 stars
19(28%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
67 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I heard the radio version of it from the Egyptian cultural program and the truth is there is no need for this beauty.

This statement might seem a bit bold at first glance. However, when we really think about it, beauty is often in the eye of the beholder. What one person may consider beautiful, another might not. In this case, perhaps the person making the statement felt that the particular thing being described didn't possess the kind of beauty that they were looking for or that they believed was truly significant.

The link provided, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H34Wm..., might lead to something that could potentially change one's perception of beauty or might further support the idea that there is no need for this particular type of beauty. It could be a video that展示s different perspectives or offers a new way of looking at things.

In conclusion, while the initial statement may seem dismissive of beauty, it actually opens up a discussion about the subjectivity of beauty and how our perceptions can vary.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I thoroughly enjoyed these short stories.

Each one is filled with surprises and has an open-ended nature that compels the reader to continue thinking about them even long after the stories have come to an end.

The story "Mrs Frola and Mr. Ponza, Her son-in-law" is a prime example of a Pirandello story. It delves into the concept of the relativity of truth and the inherent impossibility of truly understanding and penetrating other people's minds. This particular story had a profound impact on me, making me question my own assumptions and perspectives.

It made me realize how often we take our own version of the truth for granted and fail to consider the possibility that there may be multiple valid interpretations.

The way Pirandello presents these ideas in such a thought-provoking and engaging manner is truly remarkable.

These short stories have not only entertained me but also challenged me to think more deeply about the human condition and the nature of truth.
July 15,2025
... Show More
What an odd little story indeed! It is a tale that intertwines the complex themes of human greed, revenge, and justice, all presented in a most unexpected way - with lighthearted humour.

Greed, that insatiable desire for more, often leads people down a path of no return. In this story, we see how it drives the actions of the characters, setting off a chain of events that culminates in a rather comical yet thought-provoking outcome.

Revenge, too, plays a significant role. As one character seeks to right a wrong done to them, they embark on a journey that is filled with both hilarity and heartache.

And then there is justice, that elusive concept that we all strive for. In this story, justice is served in a way that is both unexpected and satisfying, leaving us with a sense of wonder and amusement.

Overall, this odd little story is a charming and entertaining read that manages to explore some of the deepest aspects of human nature while still making us laugh. It is a testament to the power of storytelling and the ability of a good story to touch our hearts and minds.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A nice collection of stories has been presented here.

These stories are truly remarkable, with many of them being as absurd as his plays.

The author has a unique talent for creating worlds and characters that are both strange and captivating.

Each story takes the reader on a journey through a different set of circumstances, filled with unexpected twists and turns.

The absurdity of the stories adds an element of humor and entertainment, making them a joy to read.

Whether you are a fan of his plays or simply looking for something different to read, this collection of stories is sure to satisfy.

It offers a fresh perspective on life and the human experience, presented in a way that is both engaging and thought-provoking.

So, sit back, relax, and enjoy the ride as you explore the wonderful world of these absurd stories.

You never know what you might discover along the way.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Pirandello is indeed one of the most renowned Sicilian authors and playwrights. However, these stories, despite being set in Sicily, do not possess as distinctively Sicilian a character as those of Giovanni Verga, for instance.
They center around people and their relationships, with a particular focus on how an individual views the world subjectively and can never truly fathom what is happening in another person's mind.
For example, "With other eyes" delves into a young wife's response upon discovering a photo of her husband's first wife and how this alters her perception of him. "A Voice" is about a lover's fear when she suspects that her blind love will regain his sight and see her for the very first time.
"A Character's tragedy" is more fanciful but is interesting as it anticipates some of the themes present in Pirandello's most famous play, "Six characters in search of an author".

July 15,2025
... Show More
I haven't delved into any other works of Pirandello before, and thus, I was filled with excitement when I got the opportunity to read short stories penned by this Italian author.

The stories themselves were rather simple in their structure and narrative. However, they were accompanied by profound lessons and morals that left a lasting impression on me.

Among all the stories, my absolute favorite was 'The Oil Jar', which is also the title story of the book. I was truly impressed by the well-developed characters in this story. Each character had their own unique traits and personalities, which made them come alive on the pages.

Moreover, the ending of 'The Oil Jar' was extremely witty and clever. It took me by surprise and made me think about the story long after I had finished reading it.

Since I had the Dover edition, which only cost $1, I am a bit uncertain about the accuracy of the translation compared to that of a higher quality publisher.

I would really like to reread some of these stories translated by another translator to get a different perspective and a more accurate understanding of Pirandello's works.

Furthermore, I have developed a great interest in Pirandello's writing and definitely want to explore more of his works in the future.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Perhaps before reading "One, No One and One Hundred Thousand", I should have read this collection of short stories (or novelettes). It would have been a gentle introduction to reading Pirandello's works because I had to spend some time getting used to the author's style. Not being a native speaker and not having read enough to feel comfortable with any text in Italian, I found Pirandello's literary language rather challenging as the reader must possess the talent to understand what has not been clearly stated, but only hinted at and implied. In other words, Pirandello's literary output is a rather high step for an inexperienced reader.


The novelettes are extremely entertaining and it is a pleasure to read them both for pleasure and for delving deeper into the study of Pirandello's literature. Since I don't want to write a long and capricious account, I will only dwell on a particular aspect of this collection that I have noticed. Trying to discern the presence of something common among the various novelettes, I have come to the conclusion that it would be the conflict between two kinds of laws: the state laws and the moral laws. In the novelettes of "La giara", the obvious difference between the two lies in the fact that they are based on different principles, that is, the essential for both kinds is rather different.


While reading, I have identified three consequences that result from that conflict:


a) There are situations and problems that transgress the limits of state laws.


b) The solutions, that is, the attempt to accommodate both kinds of laws, make the protagonists end up in bizarre situations (such as having two wives, or being buried next to the deceased wife of one's husband in order not to allow him to take that place, and so on).


c) The fact that these solutions are considered bizarre shows the moral rigidity and stubbornness (even obtuseness) of Pirandello's society.


An excellent collection that invites one to explore other works of Pirandello.

July 15,2025
... Show More
From the beautiful comedic works of Pirandello, the jar was not an obstacle, but who owns the jar.

Pirandello's comedies are known for their unique charm and profound exploration of human nature. In this particular story, the jar plays an interesting role. It may seem like a simple object, but in the context of the comedy, it becomes a focal point that引发s various emotions and actions among the characters.

Who owns the jar? This question sets the stage for a series of humorous and perhaps even thought-provoking events. As the story unfolds, we see how different characters interact with the jar and how their relationships are affected by it.

Whether it's a case of mistaken identity, a battle of wits, or a display of greed, the jar serves as a catalyst for the comedic elements in the story. Pirandello's skillful writing brings these characters and their situations to life, making us laugh while also making us reflect on the absurdities of human behavior.

In conclusion, the jar in Pirandello's comedy is not just a prop, but a symbol that represents the complexity and hilarity of human existence.
July 15,2025
... Show More

كقصص حكايات عالمية is a wonderful collection that takes readers on a journey through the rich tapestry of global literature.

Specifically, when it comes to من الأدب الإيطالي, Italian literature has a long and illustrious history.

It is filled with captivating stories, unique characters, and profound themes.

Italian authors have contributed greatly to the world of literature with their masterpieces.

From the works of Dante Alighieri to those of Italo Calvino, each writer has added their own distinct flavor to the literary landscape.

The stories in this collection offer a glimpse into the Italian way of life, its culture, and its values.

Readers can expect to be entertained, enlightened, and inspired by these tales.

Whether it's a love story, a mystery, or a historical epic, كقصص حكايات عالمية من الأدب الإيطالي has something for everyone.

So, pick up this collection and embark on a literary adventure through the beautiful world of Italian literature.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly love the short stories in this book.

Each story is like a precious gem, shining with unique charm and wisdom.

The authors have skillfully crafted these tales, taking the readers on captivating journeys through different worlds and emotions.

Some stories make you laugh out loud, while others touch your heart deeply.

The characters are vividly described, making them come alive in your imagination.

The plots are engaging and full of surprises, keeping you on the edge of your seat until the very end.

Whether you are looking for entertainment or inspiration, these short stories have something for everyone.

They are a great way to relax and unwind after a long day, or to explore new ideas and perspectives.

I highly recommend this book to anyone who loves good literature and enjoys reading short stories.

You will not be disappointed!
July 15,2025
... Show More

A Thrilling Novel about Endurance and Stubbornness



This is a truly exciting novel that delves deep into the themes of endurance and stubbornness. The story follows a protagonist who faces numerous challenges and obstacles along the way.

Despite the difficulties, the character refuses to give up and persists with unwavering determination. Their endurance is put to the test time and time again, but they manage to find the strength within themselves to keep going.

Their stubbornness, which might seem like a flaw at times, actually becomes their greatest asset. It allows them to stay focused on their goals and not be deterred by the opinions or actions of others.

As the story progresses, we witness the protagonist's growth and transformation. They learn valuable lessons about themselves and about life, and their journey is both inspiring and captivating.

This novel is a must-read for anyone who enjoys stories of perseverance and the human spirit.

July 15,2025
... Show More

It is very much a mixed bag. The title story is amusing yet rather slight. It could have potentially made a good Puccini one-acter. However, the later stories aren't necessarily better. Quite arguably, the best in the collection is the early “Citrons from Sicily”. It is not only a moving study in class differences but also powerfully builds tension in the form of the main character's growing realization of his position. “A Voice” explores both character and conscience. And although “With Other Eyes” uses the shopworn trope of appearance (in a photograph) as a representation of personality and fate, the main character's struggle toward empathy with the despised former wife is well calculated. Perhaps most remarkable is “It's Not to Be Taken Seriously”, a study in repressed homosexuality and the main character's panicked reaction when threatened by awareness of it. “A Character's Tragedy”, no doubt an early study for what would be Pirandello's most famous work, is tedious as it lacks cumulative effect.


And what is one to say about “Mrs. Frola and Mr. Ponza, Her Son-in-Law”? If it's really “about the relativity of truth and the impossibility of penetrating other people's minds”, then perhaps Pirandello shouldn't have been so arbitrary in presenting information to his characters – and to his readers. Does the current (second? or only?) Mrs. Ponza actually exist? We're supposed to believe that nobody sees her. On the other hand, it would've been impossible for her to exchange daily notes with Mrs. Frola (by means of a basket lowered into the courtyard of an apartment complex) without eventually being seen by someone. Wasn't she seen when moving into the apartment? Either Pirandello or his translator is hiding behind some deliberate ambiguity, and this is annoying. Of course, it could be that both characters are lying, neither is insane, and in fact they're carrying on with each other...

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.