Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
32(32%)
4 stars
37(37%)
3 stars
30(30%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More
The movie is truly one of my all-time favorite movies.

It has a special charm that keeps pulling me back to watch it over and over again.

The story is engaging, the characters are well-developed, and the overall production is top-notch.

Even though the book on which the movie is based is a little bit different, I found that I loved it too.

The book offers a more in-depth exploration of the characters' thoughts and feelings, and it allows for a more detailed understanding of the story's background and context.

Reading the book after watching the movie was like uncovering a hidden treasure, and it added a new layer of appreciation for the story.

Both the movie and the book have their own unique strengths, and I feel fortunate to have experienced both.
July 14,2025
... Show More

I've always been touched by the words, "I believe that you should always leave loved ones with loving words. It may be the last time you see them." But it wasn't until an incident 8 years ago that I truly understood their significance.


That day, I was on the phone with my Dad. It was a typical conversation until the end. Usually, I'd say "Love you, Dad," but that time, for some reason, I hesitated and just said, "Okay take care, Pi." Little did I know, it would be our last phone call. Two hours later, my mom called to say Dad had a bad headache and was on the way to the hospital. It was a stroke, and he never woke up. To this day, I regret not saying those three words.


The second incident happened in January 2009. I had been with my significant other since elementary school. We were childhood sweethearts, and our relationship had evolved over the years. We were a cool couple, rarely arguing out of jealousy. But one night, everything changed.


He was late picking up our friend Widya, and I, being extremely punctual, kept calling him. When he finally arrived at Widya's, he called me back, and we had a heated exchange. He ended the call with "Love you," but I was too angry to say it back. Not an hour later, I got a call from Widya saying there had been an accident. By the time I got to the hospital, he was unconscious and never woke up. His "love you" was the last thing I heard from him, and my response was far from loving.


It's been almost 4 years since then, and I've learned a lot. I've learned that being too punctual can be a burden. I've accepted the loss of my loved ones, but I still struggle with the regret of my last words to them. I envy Holly from the book because she had time to say goodbye properly and received letters from her husband even after he was gone. I wish I had something like that.


Despite all this, I know that life goes on. I'm a woman with a million happy memories, and I'm ready to make new ones. I'll open my heart and follow where it leads, just like Holly. And I'll always remember the importance of leaving loved ones with loving words.


\\n  
"I believe that you should always leave loved ones with loving words. It may be the last time you see them."
\\n

July 14,2025
... Show More
I seem to be one of the very few who didn't like this book.

First of all, I must point out that I have a great affection for girlie books and I'm the kind of person who would cry at anything even remotely sad. However, despite these facts, I didn't enjoy this book at all and was constantly looking forward to its end.

I truly WANTED to like it. I had high hopes that something would occur to make me change my opinion, but unfortunately, that never happened.

The entire book gave the impression of a rambling and dull conversation, with a story-line that was both repetitive and inconsistent.

Ordinarily, I would have had complete sympathy for Holly's situation, but to be honest, she just irritated me. Her friends also annoyed me, as did her family (except for her mum, whom I liked).

And those notes from Gerry... What a sweet and romantic concept it seemed to be, but for me, they lacked any sense of realism or genuine emotion.

I'm relieved that it's finally over. For me, it's a BIG thumbs down.
July 14,2025
... Show More
This book is truly a remarkable one that will make you both laugh and cry along with the characters.

It vividly describes the profound feelings of a woman who has lost her beloved, her soul mate.

The main story is that before her husband passed away, he wrote 12 notes for her. These 12 notes, one for each month, were intended to support her and assist her in starting a new life without him.

As you read, you will witness what she does and how she lives her life without him, as she tries her best to continue.

I thoroughly enjoyed every single moment of reading this book. I highly recommend it to you. Enjoy it!

P.s. Sorry for my poor English.

The story is about a woman who lost her dear husband, who was her life and soul.

The story is that her husband, before he died, wrote her 12 short messages to help her overcome her grief and continue her life. In the story, you will experience her grief and joy with her, and see how she copes with her daily life without him and without his guidance.

It is a really wonderful story.

July 14,2025
... Show More
Toimi as an audiobook, read by Pirjo Heikkilä, is truly amazingly good! I still really liked it a lot and didn't see the need to reduce the stars from this one <3.

This audiobook offers a unique listening experience. The way Pirjo Heikkilä reads brings the story to life in a wonderful way. Her voice is engaging and she has a great ability to convey the emotions and nuances of the text.

The content of Toimi itself is also very interesting. It takes the listener on a journey through different situations and characters. The story is well-written and keeps you hooked from start to finish.

Overall, I highly recommend this audiobook. Whether you are a fan of the written word or just looking for a great way to pass the time, Toimi read by Pirjo Heikkilä is definitely worth checking out.

I can't wait to see what other audiobooks Pirjo Heikkilä will read in the future. She has truly made this listening experience a memorable one.

July 14,2025
... Show More
I had a strong desire to read this book ever since I watched the movie, which was a long time ago. However, I only ended up reading it now. Somehow, I felt that the movie and the book were completely different from each other, except for the title and some characters. Anyway, I believed the book was better for my own reasons. For example, in a book, you can learn more about all the characters, and the story would be presented in much more detail compared to a two-hour movie.

Regarding the book, I would say that the author has done an excellent job. The characters she created seemed extremely real, well-differentiated, and relatable. Some of the situations were very touching, especially the scenes concerning Holly's loneliness, her beautiful moments with Gerry, and their unfulfilled dreams. Holly was sometimes a bit too cranky and moody, but the way she acted was quite natural. I never felt that her feelings were exaggerated, even when she was jealous of her best friends as they moved on with their lives while she was still fixated on her old memories.

Now, what I didn't like about the book was that it was a bit too sluggish. Also, the letters from Gerry to Holly were too short. They could have been a bit longer. Apart from that, the other major letdown was the ending, which really didn't fit well with the whole story. I mean, after reading 400 pages, it ended where it had originally started. That was something that didn't sit well with me. But overall, it was a good read, and the time spent with this book was worthwhile.
July 14,2025
... Show More

The story is simple yet unique. It's about how a husband (Gerry), feeling that his life won't last long due to the cancer he's suffering from, prepares his wife (Holly), who is very dependent on him and deeply loved by him, to live after his departure. He leaves letters for Holly to open every month for a year after his death. The letters contain various requests based on what usually happened in their lives.


The story is touching although there are some funny parts that are a bit disturbing, like the 'amazing' incident at Holly's birthday celebration. But overall, this story can give the reader a lot of things: about how a wife must remain independent even though she has a reliable husband... because we never know when we will part from him, about friendship, about the meaning of a family, about love, about a meeting and also about a separation.


Holly, who is fragile and shy... over time, finds many lessons and meanings from the departure of her husband... friend... lover and soulmate: Gerry, and also from the lives of the people around her.


Holly, who feels that everything in her life is in chaos, yet has beautiful and happy memories. Who knows what it's like to have true love, but is ready to step into the future.


A touching, romantic, meaningful yet still 'down to earth' novel... beautiful :)

July 14,2025
... Show More

Warning: This is my first review so it may be awful :D


Before I started the book, I thought it was a typical romance book about two people who fell in love, bla bla bla. However, when I began reading it, I was in shock. The first chapter was about the death of the main male character. I initially thought the story would be reversed, but I was wrong. It was completely different, and I LOVE IT!


It's a new story about a woman whose husband recently died. She is now depressed and miserable, not knowing what to do with her life anymore without him by her side. After a while, she discovers that he left her envelopes containing ten letters, one for each month, telling her what to do and encouraging her to move on with her life. It's really a good book. I like that every chapter has its own emotions. I cried, laughed, felt sorry for her, and sometimes even wished I could punish her. All these feelings in the same book are rare. I liked the characters; they all seemed real to me. I also loved her family, all of them, even Richard. Although I don't usually like people with this kind of personality in real life, I like it in the book because I know when a chapter includes Richard, it's going to be a funny one :D


I didn't like the last chapter. I hate when they repeat events that happened before. It makes you feel like you're in a movie because you know things like this don't happen in reality.


P.S. This review is for my friend. I don't usually write reviews, but she was disappointed in me, so I did it for her.

July 14,2025
... Show More
3.5 stars

This rating indicates that the product or service being evaluated has a decent level of quality. It is not quite excellent, but it also doesn't fall short.

There are likely some aspects that are quite good, perhaps the functionality is solid, or the features offered are useful. However, there may also be a few areas that could use improvement.

Maybe the design could be more aesthetically pleasing, or the user experience could be enhanced in certain ways.

Overall, a 3.5-star rating suggests that the item is a viable option, but it may not be the top choice for those seeking perfection. It has its strengths and weaknesses, and potential buyers or users should carefully consider their own priorities before making a decision.

July 14,2025
... Show More
This book!!

Oh my goodness, this book was truly an addictive read. I found myself completely engrossed in its pages, unable to put it down. It was so emotional that I went through boxes and boxes of tissues. The story was just that powerful and moving.

Not only was the book amazing, but the film adaptation was also a pretty good one. It managed to capture the essence of the story and bring it to life on the big screen.

Now, I'm really looking forward to reading the second book. I can't wait to see what adventures and emotions it has in store for me.

Overall, I would give this book five stars without hesitation. It's a must-read for anyone who loves a good story that will tug at their heartstrings.
July 14,2025
... Show More


Rating: 5/5 || Recenzia pe Secretele Simonei ||
  Cumpără P.S. Te iubesc








Când viața îți oferă lămâi...
... faci limonadă. Parcă așa era vorba aceea. :)



P.S. Te iubesc is a book that had been on my reading list for a very long time. Recently, thanks to those from Editura Allfa, I had the opportunity to delight in this book that helped the author Cecelia Ahern make her debut.



Most likely you have heard/seen the movie P.S. I love you, starring Hilary Swank and Gerard Butler, an emotional, amusing, and relaxing movie that I really liked. It was made after the book of the same name and was a great success, which made me curious to read the book as well.



I read P.S. Te iubesc in the wonderful new edition that Editura Allfa created. Our protagonist, Holly, is a young woman who goes through an unimaginable suffering along with her friends. She loses her other half, the precious person in her life, her beloved Gerry, a wonderful husband who is taken away by a tumor.



Holly is devastated and loses herself, forgetting how to truly live until the moment she starts to receive some mysterious letters from... Gerry! It seems that her guardian angel didn't leave her alone and prepared a set of letters for her to help her get back on her feet.



carte ps te iubesc cecelia ahern editura allfa



The magical letters
Although Holly becomes extremely enthusiastic about the letters she receives through her friends, she will have to face a series of challenges that Gerry prepared for her. Not all of them are pleasant things as they awaken memories that sadden her or put her in difficulty, forcing her to face her fears.



The protagonist suffers a great deal and cannot easily overcome the stage she is in. She becomes jealous of her friends who continue their life rhythm as if nothing had happened, but it's all just in her mind. The pain of losing Gerry is present in everyone's heart, but Holly cannot accept what happened.



The title of the book is full of significance, emphasizing the feeling of love between Holly and Gerry, something that could be felt from each letter written by Gerry, the ending always being the same: "P.S. Te iubesc".



A book full of emotion and suffering that makes you think about the hardships of life, P.S. Te iubesc is that reading that steals your tears from time to time and makes you live along with the characters. The process of rediscovery of the protagonist teaches us that we must rebuild our lives after any tragedy, the obstacles existing only in our minds. With willpower and the support of those around us, we can rediscover how beautiful life is!



carte ps te iubesc cecelia ahern editura allfa
carte ps te iubesc cecelia ahern editura allfa



Citate:


  
    "Holly se îmbrăcă cu hainele pe care Gerry o pusese să le cumpere luna trecută și înjură. Avea multe alte lucruri mai importante de care să-și facă griji, decât de detaliile nesemnificative despre cum arată. Își lăsă părul liber astfel încât să-i acopere cât mai mult fața și își dădu cu mult rimel rezistent la apă, de parcă asta ar fi împiedicat-o să plângă. Simțea că noaptea se va termina în lacrimi. Ar fi vrut să aibă puteri magice, când avea de înfruntat zilele cele mai grele din viața ei." (p.125)
   


    "Lacrimi amare i se rostogoleau pe față și Holly își strânse mâinile în jurul corpului pentru a se alina. Plângea pentru Gerry, plângea pentru ea însăși cu suspine amare, care făceau s-o doară coastele, ori de câte ori voia să-și recapete suflarea. Nu mai voia să fie singură și nu mai voia ca familia să-i vadă singurătatea pe care ea încercase din răsputeri să o ascundă față de ei. Voia doar ca Gerry să se întoarcă, și nu-i mai păsa de nimic. Nu i-ar fi păsat dacă ei s-ar fi certat în fiecare zi, dacă ar fi fost faliți, n-ar fi avut casă sau bani. Îl voia doar pe el. Auzi cum se deschide ușa în spatele ei și simți niște brațe puternice care îi cuprinseră trupul fragil. Plângea ca și cum lunile de suferință acumulată se rostogoleau dintr-o dată afară." (p.190)
  


July 14,2025
... Show More
I appreciate the story and the sentiment but I'm just not the ideal audience for it. 2.5 stars

This statement reflects a common experience among readers. Sometimes, we come across a story that has its merits, yet it fails to resonate with us on a personal level. The story might have been crafted with great care and attention, and the sentiment it conveys might be profound. However, for some reason, it just doesn't click with us.


This is very popular but I don't think I can be a fan of the read. It's too emotional but I think people who are into that would definitely enjoy it.

The popularity of a particular read can often be a double-edged sword. On one hand, it indicates that there is something about the story that has captured the hearts and minds of many. On the other hand, it also means that not everyone will be able to connect with it in the same way. In this case, the reviewer feels that the story is too emotional for their taste. While they can recognize that others might enjoy this aspect, it simply doesn't appeal to them.


It's important to remember that everyone has their own unique reading preferences. What one person loves, another might find unappealing. And that's okay. The beauty of literature is that it offers something for everyone. Whether you prefer a heart-wrenching emotional rollercoaster or a light and breezy read, there is sure to be a story out there that will speak to you.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.