Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
41(41%)
4 stars
29(29%)
3 stars
29(29%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
April 26,2025
... Show More
In the country of Amestris, the highest form of science known is alchemy, the ability to transmute substances into another form. It seems limited only by the Law of Equivalent Exchange “to obtain an object, something of equal value must be lost.” Transmutation of humans is therefore forbidden. But grief-stricken child prodigies Edward and Alphonse Elric decide to break this taboo when their mother dies prematurely.

They do not get their mother back; Ed loses an arm and leg in the process, and Al’s entire body is consumed. Ed is able to preserve Al’s consciousness by binding it to an empty set of armour. They both gain the ability to perform transmutation without the cumbersome necessity of an alchemical circle, and Ed has his missing limbs replaced by automail, a form of cybernetic prostheses.

Edward Elric is determined to find a way to restore Alphonse’s body, but to do this he’ll need information on the Philosopher’s Stone, an item that allegedly allows transmutation to be performed without equivalent exchange. To do this, Ed joins the State Alchemist corps, becoming “a dog of the military” and code named “the Fullmetal Alchemist.” He soon finds himself and Al enmeshed in a government conspiracy, and about to learn even more hard truths about the nature of alchemy.

Fullmetal Alchemist was originally published as a monthly shounen (boys’) serial in Monthly Shounen Gangan. It did very well, spawning two anime series (one with a different ending than the manga, which was still being written at the time), video games and light novels. Arakawa went on to write Silver Spoon, the anime of which I’ve previously reviewed.

In the volume I have at hand, Alphonse, the military team led by Roy Mustang (“the Flame Alchemist”) and Ling, prince of Xing (essentially China) have temporarily teamed up with Barry the Chopper (serial killer who’s also been bonded to a suit of armour) in an attempt to make the government conspiracy break cover. They engage in battle with the homunculi Envy, Gluttony and Lust. The battle between Roy Mustang and Lust is particularly heated.

Meanwhile, Edward and Major Armstrong head across the border into the wasteland that was once Cselkcess before the unknown disaster that destroyed it overnight. In the ruins of the capital city, they meet with an old friend who gives them information on the conspiracy. Edward also meets a group of Ishbalan refugees, and learns the fate of the parents of his friend Winry Rockbell.

In addition, the Elric boys’ father Van Hohenheim resurfaces after many years. He had abandoned the family some time before his wife’s death, and hadn’t been heard from until now. Ed is…less than pleased to see him. The readers know, but Ed does not, that Hohenheim looks almost identical to the person code named “Father”, creator of the homunculi. That’s pretty suspicious.

This is a pretty nifty series. The monthly format allows more plot and character development per chapter, and Arakawa doesn’t let that opportunity pass. There are some heart wrenching moments, as well as exciting battles. (Even in this volume, Roy finally manages to defeat Lust, but at a terrible cost.)

Alchemy, which is basically magic, works by a set of rules which is easily understood, and seeming exceptions are carefully explained over the course of the series.

Less good is that some of the comedic bits get overused, particularly Edward Elric’s oversensitivity about his height. And while yes, the particular usage of the Seven Deadly Sins for the homunculi is nifty, that particular structure for a villain group is nearly a dead horse by now. (And Lust is the only female in the group. So shocking.)
April 26,2025
... Show More
July 17th, 2021 : Read in Chinese. The action is always most exciting when the Homunculi are around, so the first half of this volume is as thrilling as I could wish. Pride's debut, too cool... plus Envy, Gluttony... and Wrath! "我一个人去就够了。"

The second half has plenty of good, slow-paced resolution. There's a wonderfully clever transition between Xerxes and Resembool, with a significance that I think could only be caught on re-read.
April 26,2025
... Show More
Volume 10 of the Fullmetal Alchemist series was more of an action packed volume but also revealed lots of new information and developed characters as well. Making volume 10 a really good read and gave readers a real mouthful of action, plot and character development etc. I think that volume 10 was one of my favorites so far.

Volume 10 takes many things from previous books, like Ross's death, and explains them or puts a twist onto them. In Ross's case, her death was faked and this was revealed at the end of volume 10. Volume 10 took the build ups of the previous books and delivered the climax's of them. The battle in Lab 3 was something I had been looking forward to because the homunculi vs alchemists battle had been hyped since the beginning of the series. The battle wasn't even a full battle however, and it still delivered excitement and emotion. There will surely be more battles in the next coming volumes as this was only a teaser of what the reader will see in the future. Another thing I loved about volume 10 was that the tone and moods were all over the place. If done poorly, a rapidly changing tone or mood can make the story feel poorly written but in volume 10 of Fullmetal Alchemist the way the tone shifts as events in the battle take place is beautiful. The way there are 2 fights taking place, one in the underground lab and the other taking place above ground was also really well done because the author flops between the 2 fights perfectly, never having a dull moment and always keeping the fights balanced, not giving too much of one or the other.

One complaint I had about volume 10 was some lazy writing regarding Barry the Chopper. Barry was such an intriguing character and had become more of a main character in the past 2 volumes. However I think the way Barry simply ran away from the apartment because he sensed his old body was lazy. The way he sensed it was never explained either. Another thing that was really lazily written was his death. Barry wasn't killed by a homonculus or anything in that regard, his blood rune was simply rubbed off by himself. His suit of armor was broken into pieces and his original human body was attracted to the armor because it wanted its soul to return. So the decomposed body crawled over and wiped away Barry's blood rune. This was definitely lazy writing, even if zombies existed in the Fullmetal Alchemist world, which isn't far fetched as we have seen mind control and almost magical things before. Even if they existed, a badly decomposed body would not be able to move, let alone crawl more than 20 feet. I just think Barry deserved a better and more significant death after his character developed so much in the story. Though I do see how killing Barry off in this battle made sense since he wasn't going to be needed in the future of the story and he completed his personal goal of finding his old body.
Even though this volume resolved some issues and killed off some characters, it still introduced newer problems and foreshadowed greater things. For example the mysterious voice of Pride that spoke to and made Envy quiver during the fight. I think that Lust's words after Mustang kills her foreshadows a huge battle between the 2 sides. Lust says "I look forward to the day when those eyes will be wide with agony. It's coming. It's coming..." To Mustang after he defeats her, meaning that soon in the series there will be an even bigger battle or a multitude of bigger battles that will bring more death and action. This built a lot of excitement in me for the next and coming volumes. Overall I think this volume was one of the more enjoyable volumes in recent memory, having a perfect balance of fight scenes as well as plot.
April 26,2025
... Show More
thank u for curing my reading slump arakawa i owe u my life
April 26,2025
... Show More
This is getting more interesting and more"dirt" is coming out related to the higher-ups in the military. Getting more in love with the entire manga as it involves of brotherhood, loyalty, love and friendship among the main characters.

Fullmetal Alchemist Vol. 10 by Hiromu Arakawa.
April 26,2025
... Show More
Despite the major action set pieces, at this point FMA has become a story of international intrigue and conspiracy. Put aside the fantastical elements, and the central question has grown much bigger than the Elrics' quest. The country of Amestris is in turmoil, and the brothers are now two among many players in a drama of historic scale, reaching back to a legendary past. Both of them (especially Edward) have a more limited role in these chapters, but the story doesn't depend on them anymore.
April 26,2025
... Show More
It Was fun, exciting and gribbing with the strong fights and the plot


Brief about what happened ( spoiler)

Lust is dead, this trap was set by mustang to know who is from the military is behind what happened to huge and the stone, got closer to where those behind all the schming and philosophet ston arr
We k ow that second luttanune rose is a live but escaped

Share information, ED, lieutenant and the people from xing who are searching for the philosopher's stone and way to never die
April 26,2025
... Show More
Her cilt başka bir heyecanlı noktada son bulduğu için okumaya ara vermesi zor bir seri. Mustang vs Lust çok heyecanlı ve aksiyon doluydu. Serideki şu ana kadar en heyecanla okuduğum kısım oldu. Felsefe taşını da kanlı canlı görmüş olduk. Bir önceki ciltte Armstrong apar topar Ed'i Resembool'a doğru götürmüştü. Şimdi vardıklarında neye ve daha önemlisi kime götürdüğünü görüyoruz. Epey barizdi ama güzeldi. Bir önceki ciltte yaşanan "elim" hadisenin perde arkasını burada öğreniyoruz. Bu ciltteki heyecanlı son ise  Hohenheim ve Ed'in karşılaşmasıydı.
April 26,2025
... Show More
In the country of Amestris, the highest form of science known is alchemy, the ability to transmute substances into another form. It seems limited only by the Law of Equivalent Exchange “to obtain an object, something of equal value must be lost.” Transmutation of humans is therefore forbidden. But grief-stricken child prodigies Edward and Alphonse Elric decide to break this taboo when their mother dies prematurely.

They do not get their mother back; Ed loses an arm and leg in the process, and Al’s entire body is consumed. Ed is able to preserve Al’s consciousness by binding it to an empty set of armor. They both gain the ability to perform transmutation without the cumbersome necessity of an alchemical circle, and Ed has his missing limbs replaced by automail, a form of cybernetic prostheses.

Edward Elric is determined to find a way to restore Alphonse’s body, but to do this he’ll need information on the Philosopher’s Stone, an item that allegedly allows transmutation to be performed without equivalent exchange. To do this, Ed joins the State Alchemist corps, becoming “a dog of the military” and codenamed “the Fullmetal Alchemist.” He soon finds himself and Al enmeshed in a government conspiracy, and about to learn even more hard truths about the nature of alchemy.

Fullmetal Alchemist was originally published as a monthly shounen (boys’) serial in Monthly Shounen Gangan. It did very well, spawning two anime series (one with a different ending than the manga, which was still being written at the time), video games and light novels. Arakawa went on to write Silver Spoon, the anime of which I’ve previously reviewed.

In the volume I have at hand, Alphonse, the military team led by Roy Mustang (“the Flame Alchemist”) and Ling, prince of Xing (essentially China) have temporarily teamed up with Barry the Chopper (serial killer who’s also been bonded to a suit of armor) in an attempt to make the government conspiracy break cover. They engage in battle with the homunculi Envy, Gluttony and Lust. The battle between Roy Mustang and Lust is particularly heated.

Meanwhile, Edward and Major Armstrong head across the border into the wasteland that was once Cselkcess before the unknown disaster that destroyed it overnight. In the ruins of the capital city, they meet with an old friend who gives them information on the conspiracy. Edward also meets a group of Ishbalan refugees, and learns the fate of the parents of his friend Winry Rockbell.

In addition, the Elric boys’ father Van Hohenheim resurfaces after many years. He had abandoned the family some time before his wife’s death, and hadn’t been heard from until now. Ed is…less than pleased to see him. The readers know, but Ed does not, that Hohenheim looks almost identical to the person codenamed “Father”, creator of the homunculi. That’s pretty suspicious.

This is a pretty nifty series. The monthly format allows more plot and character development per chapter, and Arakawa doesn’t let that opportunity pass. There are some heartwrenching moments, as well as exciting battles. (Even in this volume, Roy finally manages to defeat Lust, but at a terrible cost.) The art is distinctive and competent, if never spectacular.

Alchemy, which is basically magic, works by a set of rules which is easily understood, and seeming exceptions are carefully explained over the course of the series.

Less good is that some of the comedic bits get overused, particularly Edward Elric’s oversensitivity about his height. And while yes, the particular usage of the Seven Deadly Sins for the homunculi is nifty, that particular structure for a villain group is nearly a dead horse by now. (And Lust is the only female in the group. So shocking.)

I understand there are omnibus volumes out now, which will make collecting the series faster. Also, because this series was very popular, the hipper libraries may stock it in their teen rooms.

Recommended for fans of shounen manga.

April 26,2025
... Show More
Increíble todo. 100/10. Sin duda uno más de mis favoritos. Aquí continúa la tensión del tomo anterior, hay muchas más acción, los héroes innegables de este volúmen son Alphonse y Roy Mustang. Vemos por primera vez a la teniente Riza ser vulnerable y quebrarse ante algo que ella, ni nadie, esperaba enterarse, lo que (en mi opinión) nos demuestra sus fuertes lazos y sentimientos con el coronel. La batalla contra Lust está, literalmente, prendida en candela. Luego descubrimos mediante un flashback el plan de Roy y sus verdaderas intenciones con toda la situación de María Ross. Ya hacía el final del tomo Ed tiene un interensate encuentro con unos Ishivalianos y con cierto personaje que solo está en sus primeras memorias...
En fin, podría seguir hablando de este maravilloso volúmen. Todo lo que me gusta de FMA en el tomo 10
April 26,2025
... Show More
La primera de mis batallas favoritas: Roy es tan absolutamente badass y lo amo tanto.

Como siempre, uno se ríe en los momentos más drámaticos y eso es genial.

Al final, las ruinas de Xerxes que cada que las veo me gustan más y Hohenheim… y entiendo tan bien a Ed.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.