Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
33(33%)
4 stars
38(38%)
3 stars
29(29%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
April 26,2025
... Show More
Okaaaaay, that was interesting. I really liked that the beginning of the book had some historical background of The Nutcracker and how it eventually became the ballet. As for the story itself, it was both cute and odd. Definitely very fairytale-like. There were parts of it that I liked better than others due to the moments of oddness, but there were also plenty of charming things too. Also, I know it’s historical fact that there was a day when children were thought to be nothing less than little adults and therefore got married off REALLY young, and you see that pop up in some classic literature… For example, I read that in an original version of “Snow White”, she’s actually only 7 years old when she marries the prince, and in “Romeo and Juliet”, Juliet’s mother tells 12-year-old Juliet that there are many girls her age in Verona who are already married and have families of their own… But it’s still extremely weird to my modern sensibilities, knowing extremely well that children are not just mini-adults and how incredibly immature 7 year olds are, to read about Mary, who is only 7 years old, getting engaged and then marrying the guy who was once the nutcracker only a year later. And that guy also seems to have changed age by the end??? I thought he was 18-ish when he was turned into a nutcracker, but at the end, he was significantly shorter and it seemed like it was being implied that he was a child not much older than Mary. Godfather Drosselmayer (sp?) even called them both “children.” I mean, we are talking about a story where Godfather Drosselmayer was able to disassemble and reassemble a human baby to try to figure out how to fix what was wrong with it, and also was able to attach a wooden lever to the neck of a human young man to help him crack nuts better, so I guess I can’t say much, but… *brain starts to shoot sparks from trying to make sense of these things* You know what? I’m just going to let it go.

While this story was cute, it was also too odd for me to totally fall in love with it, (admittedly, the ballet has parts that are odd, too, but at least that has beautiful dancing and music to help) so I am giving it a solid 3 stars for didn’t-love-didn’t-hate.


Content advisory for those who want to know:

Violence: There is a battle in which there is mouse-on-toy violence. Mary witnesses toys kill mice, and mice rip toys to shreds. This is generally not described, but at one point it is said that a mouse has torn open the belly of a toy and is pulling out its “entrails”.

There are a couple mentions of mouse blood, too. Once, when Dame Mousey is accidentally crushed by someone’s foot, blood is briefly mentioned in relation to her squished body. And, when the 7-headed mouse king is defeated (this is not witnessed by Mary) the Nutcracker’s sword is said to have mouse blood on it.

A child accidentally cuts their elbow on glass. Pain is mentioned, and they eventually faint and have to be seen by a doctor.

There is also one illustration in the book that shows dead mice hanging from their necks by pieces of string. It’s a black-and-white ink drawing and not graphically detailed, but if I was reading the story to a child so young that they couldn’t read yet, especially a sensitive child, I don’t know that I’d show them that picture.


Other: In the mini story explaining how the nutcracker became the nutcracker, something happens that upsets the king so much that the servants put locks on the palace windows to keep him from throwing himself out of them, and they put padding on the stone walls to keep him from dashing his brains on them.
There are threats of violence by mice towards children several times during the story. Dame Mousey threatens a baby and it is thought that she intends to use her teeth to do physical harm to the child. (She does fulfill her threat, but does something that is non-violent, but still not very nice, instead.)

There are threats of violence by mice towards children several times during the story. Dame Mousey threatens a baby and it is thought that she intends to use her teeth to do physical harm to the child. (She does fulfill her threat, but does something that is non-violent, but still not very nice, instead.)

The 7-headed mouse king repeatedly coerces Mary to give him items of food and objects that are important to her by threatening to eat her beloved Nutcracker if she refuses. Mary thinks that the mouse king may even eat her up in the end, whether she obeys him or not.

Mary’s family members—both parents and brother included— laugh at her on multiple occasions when she tries to tell them the truth about fantastical things she has seen.

Mary’s brother is repeatedly disrespectful to adults, though he is (sometimes) reprimanded for it.
April 26,2025
... Show More
The Nutcracker while being a Christmas classic, is quite boring. It starts out as a character telling a story to children but then a character in that story starts telling another story. A frame story within a frame story. Confusing right. Also there was a questionable marriage between a seven year old girl and a teenage boy? Not about that.
April 26,2025
... Show More
Whimsical and occasionally creepy as hell, this precursor to the famous ballet successfully put me in a festive mood and entertained me for a couple hours. I found that I enjoyed the backstory of the toy maker and the Mouse King far more than the actual story of Clara and the Nutcracker. Would reccomend!
April 26,2025
... Show More
جمال الأدب الكلاسيكي هو في بطء إيقاع أحداثه.

وإذا كان هذا الأدب موجهاً للأطفال أو الناشئة فإنه يصبح رحلة خيالية تحملنا على محفة البراءة إلى المدن الفاضلة حيث يسود السلام وينتصر الحق ويتزوج الأمراء الشجعان أميراتهم اللواتي كن جزءاً من حكايات بطولاتهم.

ولا أظن بأن أي قارئ مهما بلغ به العمر وتعددت قراءاته لن يقع أمام إحدى هذه القصص فريسة حنينه إلى أحلام طفولته حيث كانت أقصى أمنياتنا أن نتقمص شخصيات أبطال القصص التي نقرأها أو نتابعها على شاشة التلفاز، وكذلك أن نلج صفحات الكتاب أو نخترق الشاشة لكي نساندهم ونخوض إلى جانبهم أعنف المغامرات في سبيل إحقاق الحق وطرد الأشرار وهزيمتهم.

كسارة البندق شيء جميل من طفولتي، لا أذكر منه إلا مشهداً على شاشة التلفزيون حيث يقف الكسارة الشجاع باستعداد أسفل شجرة عيد الميلاد.


لذا فعندما وجدت نسخة الرواية لم أتردد في اقتنائها، خاصة وأنها ستغدو بإذن الله إحدى قراءات أطفالي الشيقة بعد سنوات قليلة.
April 26,2025
... Show More
أسطورة كسّارة البندق

إنها الحكايه التي لطالما أحببتها حينما كنتُ طفله
كنت أحرص على مشاهدتها حينما كانت تُعرض على قناة " دبي الأولى "
لازلتُ أتذكر تلك الأيام كأنها حدثت بالأمس ، و كيف لي أن لا أتذكرها و قد كنت أحب هذه الحكايه حباً جماّ إنها جزءاً من ذكرياتي الجميله ...

أحببت أن أعود إلى قرآءتها بعد كل هذهِ السنوات..
لقد مر زمنٌ طويل إلاّ أنها لم تفقد رونقها عندي ، لازالت من أجمل الحكايات التي قرأتها
لا زلتُ أحبها و أحببتها الآن أكثر من ذي قبل ..
April 26,2025
... Show More
Moral of the story is never trust mice and if you treat your toys right one of them may just be a king that marries you
April 26,2025
... Show More
Es un cuento clásico infantil muy mágico perfecto para esta época, pero me sigo quedando con la película. La edición que he leído contiene el cuento original de Hoffmann y la versión de Dumas, pero siento que he leído prácticamente lo mismo dos veces.
April 26,2025
... Show More
Scorre via come una vera fiaba che si snoda come un nastro piena di sorprese
April 26,2025
... Show More
A story within a story. Being open to imagination and discovery of new places is what I like most about reading, and this book demonstrates literature's ability to take you to new places. The best quote is at the end, "all kinds of wonderful and extraordinary things may there be seen by those who have eyes sharp enough to discover them."
April 26,2025
... Show More
Kinda weird. Kinda interesting. Kinda strange. I dunno.

The story was pretty different from the ballets that you can see nowadays, but it was still followed the story a little bit. There was a lot on the history of the Nutcracker which was quite interesting. Also, Clara’s name is actually Mary and she is only 7!!! Why is she getting married at 7 yrs old?!?!

Over all….

WEIRD.
April 26,2025
... Show More
I haven't seen the Nutcraker ballet since I was a child. When I investigated the ballet for an upcoming performance, and found out that Alexander Dumas wrote the version that Tchaikovsky was inspired by, I had to get a copy. I love everything about this edition. The cover is beautiful and reading it was a delight.
April 26,2025
... Show More
It’s a very strange story of which the ballet resembles barely. Here you will discover how the Nutcracker was once a boy and became a Nutcracker. And if you ever found Drosselmyer to be a bit creepy, your judgement will be well justified. Overall it was strange but interesting enough to hold the attention.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.