Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 98 votes)
5 stars
34(35%)
4 stars
28(29%)
3 stars
36(37%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
98 reviews
April 16,2025
... Show More
ظل الريح ..
تلك الأسطورة الأدبية الساحرة
التي أسرتني من أول سطورها حتى أخر حرف
فوقعت في عشقها تائهة أتحسس الخطوة لأصل لذروة المتعة
في هذا العالم المتشابك الذي نسجه كارلوس زافون بحرفية منقطعة النظير
من كاتب يملك زمام القلم والسرد فيطوعهما كيفما شاء
لتجد أبطال تم رسم شخصياتهم بانسيابية من يرسم بالسن الفضية تلك الرسوم القادمة من العصورالوسطى بخطوطها الدقيقة التي تضمن دقة وبراعة في خلق ورسم أدق التفاصيل
وبنفس البراعة والإحترافية كتب زافون ظل الريح
ونسج شبكة أبطال لكل منهم قصة مفردة لا تنحرف عن النسق الدرامي الذي أراده الكاتب لها فتظل تُثري العمل وتتفاعل مع بقية أبطاله فلا مجال لك أن تضل أو تفقد الأحداث وتقع في براثن اللغو والملل أو تشعر أن هناك جسد منهم زائد عن الحاجة
فقط تسير خلف كل بطل مبهور تلتقط أنفاسك لتصل معه حتى خط النهاية الدقيق الذي لا تراه ولا تستوعبه ولا تعرف
بدايته ولكنك تسير بهدوء من يعلم لهذا العالم نهاية مسبقة

هكذا سار أبطال زافون في شوارع برشلونة ولكي يمنحك الكاتب تشويقًا لا حد له شكلت أنامله الدقيقة مغامرة بوليسية لها بعد سياسي وعدة جرائم وشخصية غامضة تلتحف الظلام لتشعل النار في كتب قديمة أنتهت طبعاتها تطوي بداخلها قصة حب أسطورية وشخصية كاتب وعاشق لا تملك إلا أن تقع في حبه كما المراهقات
ويستمر زافون في سلب إرادتك وسحب عقلك بكامل إرادتك الحرة معه في هذا التيه الممتع الآسر
حتى يقرر أن يهديك قمره الذي أضاء ظلمات روحك التي تتوق لمعرفة الحقيقة
في الفصل الذي جُمعت فيه عبقرية السرد وذكاء الحبكة
لتعرف ما هية حارق الكتب
وحقيقة مؤلمة خلف قصة حب أسطورية
وتعرف أنك لم تدخل مقبرة الكتب المنسية عبثاً ...

بالتأكيد أن من أهم أسباب نجاح تلك الرواية وصداها المبهر في جميع دول العالم
هو عالم الكتب التي تدور في فلكه أحداث الرواية
فليس هناك مو��وع أحب على قلب أي قاريء من أن يقرأ مؤلف عن الكتب
فما بالك إذا تجاوز النص حدود الإبداع الأدبي وصعد على قمة الفنون جميعها
وخرج كلوحة فنية أو معزوفة موسيقية هى الأروع في تاريخ الفن

ومع ذلك انتقصت من التقيم نجمة لوجود تجديف مزعج في الرواية
أعتدت عليه في النصوص المترجمة ولكنه كفيل أن يخرج النص من دائرة العمل الكامل حسب مقاييسي الشخصية ..
April 16,2025
... Show More
This is a book about books, a story about stories. It starts and ends in a library of sorts, themes and plots are echoed across decades, tied together by actors who find their roles changing, and by a pen that links two cycles of the story and has its own tale that started before and goes on beyond.

"the art of reading is slowly dying, it's an intimate ritual, a book is a mirror that offers us only what we already carry inside us, when we read, we do it with all our heart and mind, and great readers are becoming more scarce by the day.”

Zafón is a master of prose, he is eminently quotable even in translation. The story is set in Barcelona and stretches from the turn of the 19th century to the sixties, though focusing most heavily in post civil war Spain recovering in the 40s and 50s. It's a bitter sweet story, as much about the slow acceptance of loss as about fighting against it or finding happiness.

"Most of us have the good or bad fortune of seeing our lives fall apart so slowly we barely notice it."

The setting is vividly brought to life. Many of the characters live in poverty or close to it, and the ventures into Paris bring to mind Orwell's descriptions. Barcelona is the star of the piece though.

"one of the many places in Barcelona where the nineteenth century had not yet been served its eviction notice"

Shadow of the Wind is a love story, or two love stories, or several love stories to be honest. We focus on Daniel, a young man growing up, and becoming obsessed with the story of another man, a writer whose young life (decades earlier) is unfolded for us through Daniel's investigations. Both of them finding difficult and potentially tragic love.

"Her voice was pure crystal, transparent and so fragile I feared that her words would break if I interrupted them."

The Shadow of the Wind has a lot to say about books and reading, rather less to say about the business of writing though.

"Books are mirrors: you only see in them what you already have inside you."

"Novels, as everyone knew, were for women and for people with nothing better to do."

It's a complex interwoven plot, not without threat and violence, with a series of reveals that undermine what you think you know.

A fascinating and lovely read, and a nice break from the fantasy books that I have read almost exclusively over the last 5 years.

Give it a try!



Join my Patreon
Join my 3-emails-a-year newsletter #prizes

...
April 16,2025
... Show More
After reading The Shadow of the Wind, I was left with somewhat mixed feelings. On the one hand, this is such a beautifully written book, and is in essence an ode to literature. On the other hand, there are some serious flaws which distracts from the whole experience.

The best thing about the book, in my opinion, is Zafon's skill in artistic writing. It reminds me of why I love to read in the first place, and makes me wish I could write as beautiful as this. The book contains lots of memorable quotes as well, definitely a good thing as far as I'm concerned.

So after about 50 pages in, I was ready to love this book as I seldom loved another book before. But as the story progressed, that resolution started to diminish slowly but surely. Ironically, one the more obvious flaws is Zafon's overuse of stylistic writing. It seems like everyone acts or talks in a very elaborate manner, even in the simplest of situations, and this can really become tiresome after a while.

The plot also isn't as ingenious as the hype would make you believe. Zafon does a good job creating a sense of mystery early on, and there are obvious parallels between the main character Daniel Sempere, and Julian Carax, the writer whose past he is trying to uncover. But ultimately, the stories of Daniel and Julian are seperate ones, and they just happen to interconnect with one another more by chance than by design.

By far the most troublesome flaw is the way the mysteries are "resolved". All too often, answers are given by having some side character or another tell his or her story for pages. Nowhere is this more evident than at the end of the book, where literally every single detail is revealed in the form of a (very) long letter, even details which the writer of the letter never could have known, since she wasn't even involved in those events. It's as if Zafon did not have a clue or the motivation to write a logical conclusion, and decided to just dump all the information in one place.

With a bit more attention to actual plot and character development, this could have been one of my favourite books. Nevertheless, I still enjoyed reading the Shadow of the Wind. It's just a shame that it falls some way short of its potential.
April 16,2025
... Show More
n  "نحن نستمر في الحياة في ذاكرة من يحبّنا، اذكُرني دومًا حتى لو في سرّك، في إحدى زوايا قلبك، حافظ عليّ في قلبك إلى الأبد، وتذكّر دوماً أننا أحياء طالما يذكرنا الآخرون"n

آه من ويلات الحرب وما تجعلنا نقاسيه ونعايشه، ولكن ثمة حروب أخرى أكثر ضراوة، حروب تعصف بنا وتترك جروحاً لا تندمل ونزيفاً لا يكف، حرب الذكريات، حرب الفقد والضياع، حرب الضمير، حرب الفشل والندم.

"لا شئ يحظى بفرصة أخرى مثل الندم"


upload images


"ثمة أشياء لا نستطيع رؤيتها إلا في الظلام"

في شوارع مدينة الظلال برشلونة، يمسك بيدنا زافون كما أمسك الأب سيمبري بيد ابنه دانيال فجراً ليصطحبه إلى "مقبرة الكتب المنسية" ذلك الحلم الذي يراود كل قارئ، مكان عتيق يضم كمّاً لا نهاية له من الكتب النادرة التي لم يتبقّ منها سوى نسخة واحدة ليختار منها دانيال كتاباً يكون رفيقه ورفيقنا نحن أيضاً، رواية كتبها "خوليان كاراكس" وسماها "ظل الريح".. تلك هي بطلة روايتنا، نعم.. كتاب بطله الأول كتاب

"هذا المكان سر يا دانيال إنه معبد، حرم خفي، كل كتاب أو مجلد تراه هنا تعيش فيه روح ما، روح من ألفه وأرواح من قرأوه وأرواح من عاشوا وحلموا بفضله، وفي كل مرة يغير الكتاب صاحبه أو تلمس نظرات جديدة صفحاته، تستحوذ الروح على قوة إضافية"



يتوحد دانيال مع الكتاب ومع كاتبه الذي بات لغزاً لا يعرف أحد مصيره، لكن صديقنا قرر البحث عنه ومعرفة سر "كاراكس"، كان يبحث عنه، أو يبحث عن نفسه، أو عن ذكريات وروائح ماضِ بعيد قبل فقدان والدته، وخلال ذلك يصادف رجلاً غامضاً يطارده كظله، رجلاً يحرق كل ما كتبه كاراكس ويصر على محو صدى حروفه من الحياة، وعدم ترك أي دليل على أن خوليان كاراكس قد مَرّ من هنا يوماً..



ليأخذنا دانيال ورفاقه الذين يدخلون إلى اللعبة بعد ذلك في رحلة آسِرة ومُحررة، غريبة لذيذة، حلوة وحامضة، دافئة وباردة كالصقيع، مبهجة ومؤلمة، عشرون عاماً بين الحاضر والماضي ومفاجآتهما، بين شوارع وأحياء برشلونة وباريس، ستدخل مقبرة الكتب المنسية، ومكتبة سيمبري، ومدرسة سان جبريل، وقصر آلدايا، ومنزل مونفورت، ودار نشر كابيستاني.. هي رحلة برائحة الورق والحبر، لن تتركك إلا لاهث الأنفاس متسارع ضربات القلب تتخبط مشاعرك من الدهشة والصدمة والسعادة والحيرة مثل حروف كلمات كتاب تفككت ولم تستطع التشابك مرة أخرى.. وعندها فقط ستفهم معنى أن الظلال لا تُرى إلا في الظلام، ولكن لابد من نورٍ بسيط ليظهرها لنا بوضوح..




في رسم الشخصيات وتشابكها البارع الذي لم أرَ مثله من قبل، تجد أمثلة الخير والشر والحب والكره والوفاء والخيانة والحقد والغل والانتقام وكل ما يخطر على البال، بحبكة وعمق تجعلك تكاد ترسم ملامحهم وكأنك تعرفهم منذ زمن بعيد.

كما تجد العلاقات الإنسانية بجميع أشكالها:

- الأبوة الحانية والمتفهمة في دانيال ووالده
- الأبوة الرافضة والقاسية في خوليان ووالده
- الأمومة بمختلف أشكالها وصورها في معظم الشخصيات
- الحب الوردي الملتهب المبني على الأحلام والمستقبل والمهدد بالصراعات في دانيال وبيا



- الحب المؤلم بلا أمل من طرف واحد في نوريا وخوليان كاراكس
- الحب الحنون الذي جاء بعد عناء ليصلح ما أفسده الزمن في فيرمين وبيرناردا
- الزواج الصوري في ميغيل ونوريا
- الزواج الحقيقي في العديد من الشخصيات الأخرى
- الصداقة والإخلاص في فيرمين ودانيال وفي ميغيل وخوليان
- الخيانة والمصلحة والبشاعة والوضاعة والدونيّة والخسّة وكل ما يرد على الذهن من سوء في فوميرو

وشعرت أن أكثر ما يعبر عن معظم تلك العلاقات على اختلافها ما بين بداية القصة ونهايتها، جملة قرأتها في مكان ما منذ سنوات وتشطر قلبي في كل مرة أقرأها فيها: "لن أخبر الصورة بما حدث لنا، سأتركها سعيدة هكذا"
April 16,2025
... Show More
I cannot rave enough about this book! So enthralling & compelling, it sucked me in with every word. I was a bit intimidated at first because it's quite a large book, but I was praying for it not to end! I just recently discovered there's a prequel, so I can't wait to read that!

*Reread- In the several years that have passed since I first read this book, I've discovered my love for it has not changed one bit. This is the type of book that is SO beautifully written, it completely captivates you and you are transported into the setting. One thing that especially amazes me about this book is considering how beautifully lyrical it is while being a translation! I can't wait to start the next two!

Reread for the third time. These books will forever be treasures in my library.
April 16,2025
... Show More
The Shadow of the Wind is wonderfully atmospheric, descriptive and a totally compelling read.

Barcelona 1945 and the aftermath of the Spanish civil war. An antiquarian book dealers son called Daniel mourns the loss of his mother. His father takes him to the secret and mysterious cemetery of Forgotten books, Daniels choses a book called the Shadow of the Wind by Julian Carax and when he sets out to discover the authors other works, he makes a shocking discovery and here the story begins.

A historical fiction novel that for me read more like a gothic style mystery which is my favourite type of novel. I really enjoyed the sense of time and place in the novel and enjoyed reading about landmarks in Barcelona which I really want to visit on finishing this novel.
I love books about books and this one is unique and different, It’s a quiet sort of novel and yet it totally absorbing and a really well crafted mystery.

A lot of characters to keep track of in the novel, and at times I felt I struggled with keeping track of all the characters but this but it didn't take away from my enjoyment of the book.

A Gripping tale, suspenseful, atmospheric and extremely well written novel for lovers of books about books.
April 16,2025
... Show More
The best book club in the entire Bay Area (proud to be part of it) picked this book for Sept. ---Its FABULOUS.......
I'm loving-loving-loving it!!!

I give this book 5 stars---No question its a masterpiece ---(a book hard to ever forget)>>>even with lots of characters!

However---If I could ---I'd really give it 4.5 stars ---not the 5 ---(but its close)

There were a few areas of the book ----that I felt were a 'little' weak --- (the way it unfolded towards the end-- some of it was 'dragging' to me). I was like "come on already".... Ever have that experience when reading a book? Especially when its long and you've been waiting to wrap things up?

......I think I've seen too many movies--often I was 'looking' for trouble in places where there wasn't any ---and then later, it bugged me! lol I thought I would be 'so smart' (ha ha)


This is a GOOD BOOK!!! NO QUESTION
April 16,2025
... Show More
Catching up…

I remember when this book was first donated to my Little Free Library Shed, I picked it up and I held it, and a bookmark flew out of it. It was quite colorful. A postcard, no words, just a picture of a scene of a mountain and cactus and flowers on the side. It was quite old, perhaps 1940’s.

And then...There was the book.

The book had a daunting cover of a man with a shadow, looking like he was running from something.

But…The book said it was about books.

And…It got me because it was about books.

I was faced with a dilemma. How could I not read this? All 487 pages of it. Another big book.

1945 Barcelona. Bleak. Shattered from the Spanish Civil War.

Daniel, a 10-year-old boy grieves for his mother, still, as his father a solicitous bookseller for the Cemetery of Forgotten Books awaits someone to choose the next book. The idea, is that each book awaits someone to choose it, and thereby renewing the books own lost life.

Mostly for its handsome binding, Daniel picks out a novel titled “The Shadow of the Wind” by an obscure Spanish writer, Julian Carax. This choice will shape his life, launching him as a young man, upon a gothic quest, which will be the center of this novel.

At the same time, the book will go back to the 1920’s and tell the story of the odd redemption for Carax’s own dark tragedy.

Once grown, Daniel is drawn to pursuing the mystery of Carax, who was supposedly killed in Barcelona at the start of the civil war. He continues his investigation through meeting others connected to Carax, especially as he learned that many of his books had been burned.

So…Who is the arsonist?

Carax was a failed author whose books never sold but the few who read them found their lives transformed.

Why would anyone want to burn and destroy Carax’s books – or him?

Also…Readers learn the mystery of the message of the Cemetery and how it became to have books first possess and then transform the lives of those who rescue and read them.

Much passion, mystery, revenge, against-the-odds love story, coming-of-age saga and melodrama (mildly supernatural thriller?) play out through these pages.

And…Will readers be satisfied with the outcome?

At the end of the book, the author provides maps and pictures and a tour of where the characters went…

“The city is a sorceress, you know, Daniel? It gets under your skin and steals your soul without you knowing it.”
April 16,2025
... Show More
Ruiz Zafon writes and constructs his novel like an older man of literature; he knows all the tricks and codes. He read the classics of the 19th century, the serial stories mixed with gothic fantasy, the detective novels. He knows the Francoist past of his country and the geography of Barcelona; he makes us with this baggage, an initiatory story (of a teenager?). Add a sympathetic, earthy, and funny character (Fermin), others quite terrifying, a nod to Borges' Library of Babel, and voila for a bestseller. As a reader, I see them well, these strings and even these big strings, so it lacks a bit of that magic that makes excellent books, and then there are a few lengths towards the end, yet I admit it, I enjoyed reading this novel of more than 500 pages (anyway!). So here it is, 3.5 * (although I still haven't figured out what a half * is). Come on.
April 16,2025
... Show More
4.5 stars...This was heartachingly beautiful....a guilty pleasure for sure....
April 16,2025
... Show More
Where do I begin? This is by far my favourite book of the year so far and I have already bought the second in the series so I can quench my obsession with Carlos Ruiz Zafon's gorgeous writing.

The story begins in Barcelona just after the Spanish Civil War, a young boy named Daniel lives alone with his Father and helps run the family bookshop. One day Daniel's Father takes him to a place knows as 'The Cemetery of Forgotten Books' - a labyrinthine place completely packed with beautiful and rare books. Daniel is allowed to spend some time there and pick out one book that he can to keep, this is how he come across 'The Shadow of the Wind' - a gripping novel written by one Julian Carax.

After falling in love with the book Daniel sets out on a mission to find out more about it's illusive author, he also discovers that a mysterious cloaked figure is hell bent on destroying any remaining books by Julian Carax, including the one that Daniel now owns. We are then thrown into an epic adventure with twists and turns at every corner, Zafon tells such a brilliantly thought out story that you won't want to put down!

The themes explored in this novel are too many to list but some more prominent ones include; forbidden love, murder, adultery and family ties. Zafon spins such a intricate tale that won't fail to surprise! I laughed, I cried and also found myself longing to be working alongside Daniel as he uncovers the mysteries surrounding 'The Shadow of the Wind'.

Zafon's writing has to be one of the most beautiful I have ever read. I was constantly finding myself sitting back from the book just to take in the profound nature of what was written on the page. I was taken aback by the flow and poetic feel that permeates this novel, this all the more surprising as this book was originally written in Spanish, I can't even begin to imagine how striking this novel must be to those who can read it the way the Zafon intended it to be.

The characters were fantastically built up, my favourite would have to be Fermin, Daniel's partner in crime, who aids his younger friend in his quest - Fermin has to be one of the most intellectually funny characters that I have ever read.

The conclusion of the story was great and I can't wait to read the next in this brilliant series of books. A definite five out of five and I highly recommend to anyone who is a lover of books and literature surrounding books!
April 16,2025
... Show More
It’s a story of love, of hatred, and of the dreams that live in the shadow of the wind.

I absolutely loved this reread and this is one of my favourite books ever. This is the book I recommend to people when they ask.

The plot is immersive and includes mystery and intrigue, love and hate, enemies and lovers, friendships and families, loss, hope, revenge, tragedy, and comedy. This book is filled with beautiful prose that kept me ensnared in its plot and atmospheric in its setting of Barcelona.

This is about a book (“The Shadow of The Wind”) that a young boy, Daniel, finds in the mysterious Cemetery of Forgotten Books and his quest to find out more about the author and the authors other works. However, he discovers that the authors previous works strangely keep being bought and being burned. As Daniel keeps getting closer to the truth, finding out about the dark and tragic past of the author and of those that knew him, someone else is also watching- a dangerous enemy feared by those in Barcelona.

This book was gothic and atmospheric, painting a vivid picture of Barcelona (a place I’ve never been but the authors descriptions lend to the imagination). Also, the enemy in this is one of the most memorable villains- so much hatred and disgust wrapped around this character. I loved the friendship between Daniel and Fumero, with Fumero providing several comic lines that had me laughing.

I wish I could visit the fictional Cemetery of Forgotten books with its wall-to-wall, and ceiling-to-floor, bridges and steps, full of books. It would be every book lovers dream.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.