Considering he spent the previous three books essentially presenting us with three diverse views of the same story, while introducing various adjustments to what we knew or believed we knew along the way, I had expected that the fourth volume, which would finally advance the timeline, would be a sort of final revelation and disclose the real story behind all the events we had witnessed previously. All the numerous questions would be answered. What were Justine and Nissim truly up to? Did Mountolive have a diplomatic endgame or was he simply improvising? And perhaps the most crucial question, how on earth did Darley manage to attract two extremely different women?
None of those questions are answered and maybe that's the intention, but he does manage to complicate that last question by having Darley be the lover of yet another woman. Maybe it was the war, perhaps tastes were different in 1940s Alexandria, but goodness ladies, were the choices that scarce?
But as promised, we pick up the story about six years later on the same island where Darley has been relating us the story and raising the child that resulted from Melissa and Nissim's affair several years back. Events bring him back to Alexandria and we are treated to what amounts to "Olde Home Week During Wartime" as he proceeds to check in with various old friends, obtain a job and then commence a romance with practically the only female character remaining.
For those hoping for stunning revelations or perhaps at least a continuation of the more realistic tone of the last novel, we're back to the territory that characterized the first two books, where Darley narrates everything in a self-absorbed and contemplative manner, spending pages pondering everything that has happened and will ever happen to him without much attention given to anything resembling a central plot. As Darley was perhaps my least favorite aspect of the first two books, this didn't bode well. However, as a person who reads those appendices at the end of "The Lord of the Rings" and gets emotional over the biographical details afterwards, I have to admit some curiosity as to what happened to all the characters when all the main action is completed.
And that we do get. Some of it we receive through hearsay and dispatches, but much is from meeting the characters themselves. After spending three books with these people, you do sense the ways they've changed over time. You don't quite get a Proustian broad sweep of unstoppable aging, but that may not be what Durrell is aiming for here. His observations are still finely tuned and there's a strange hazy morning-after vibe to the whole affair, as if the characters are stumbling through the aftermath of a dream they can't quite believe they've awakened from. Most of the old characters like Nissim or Justine get a scene or two (the child Darley's been raising seems to be dropped off with them and then forgotten about, which seems odd but perhaps it was a different era). And Durrell brings out the old tricks like devoting time to dear departed Pursewarden, who is back to being a mocking voice coming through in letters that probably helps to support whatever philosophical structure Durrell is attempting to build here. Mostly it halts what little plot is occurring (unlike the last book, where Pursewarden got to posthumously shed some light on things) and doesn't do much to justify the cast and the series' obsession with him, especially since half the time he comes across as a smart person unable to refrain from proving to you how clever he is.
Eventually Darley encounters Clea and literary nature takes its course. What's interesting about this pairing is how astonishingly normal it feels and while I still can't understand what she sees in him, it dissolves some of the heated melodrama of the earlier books into something that mature adults might recognize. As an examination of two people falling and perhaps out of love, it's fascinating. But more and more you feel like you're a witness to Darley's internal journey and for me he wasn't interesting enough to care about what discoveries he makes about his inner soul.
Durrell does get to showcase his suspense writer skills one last time, with an underwater tragedy that shocked me into realizing how much I'd come to care about some of these characters. With a series of events arranged so precisely, the gradual feeling of dread makes you reluctant to turn the page and change a status quo you've become accustomed to.
A lot of how you feel about this series may ultimately depend on how engaged you are with the philosophical approach to life and love that Durrell is exploring here. It's calm and nuanced but I found it difficult to connect with on an intellectual or emotional level. There isn't much sense of tragedy here (even Pursewarden's earlier suicide feels more like an inevitable background function than the total loss it should be, but that might be because he makes more appearances dead than alive) and what might have been a searingly intense character study takes the opposite approach into something more thoughtful. For someone on the same wavelength as what he's doing here, this will probably rank as one of their favorite books. For someone who can't quite make the leap, you're probably going to have to do what I did and focus on the staggeringly good prose, as well as the atmosphere that Durrell creates. More than trying to define a specific place and time, he's working to create something far more intensely personal, a state of mind shaped by both place and time but still unique to the mind being formed. His characters seem to be in a constant state of submerging, emerging only to discover there's still so much deeper to explore. How much and how closely you want to follow may depend on how in tune you are with Durrell's gift for construction. The events here rely on intersection, collaboration, and analysis but if you don't care about the whys of who is sleeping with whom, even the most shocking revelations are going to at best be met with grudging admiration for the effort and a shrug at the results.
I would say this: This is why I read. To find this, to reach this. I have completed one of the most magnificent, delicious, and extraordinary things I have read in my life with Clea. Starting the new year by reading this amazing tetralogy seems like such a right decision! The Alexandria Quartet is not a work that can be recommended to everyone, nor is it a work that everyone will love for sure. It is difficult because it requires effort and hard work from the reader, but it also gives back in kind. Its language is very flowery, yes, but when the sentences can be both magnificent and elegant at the same time, that's when the thing I love so much comes out: baroque. When baroque literature is mastered properly, it truly fascinates me, and unfortunately, the number of writers who can do this is very small. This tetralogy will remain in my mind - and not only in my mind, but also in my heart and on my skin - as one of the best examples of baroque literature I have read. Like a strange prism - in each book, it changes your point of view and presents the truth from another place with such delicacy that it is truly difficult for the writer to describe. You were right when you said, "A work of art is as like life as it is unlike it," Durrell. I am very happy to have met your Alexandria, which is the main character of the book, just like in the case of M., the main character of the beginning of In Search of Lost Time. Fortunately, I read it. Literature should be just like this. Thank you a thousand times and goodbye for now, Alexandria. I'm sure I'll come back to you one day. "I tried to find his trace on the pillow. One must try everything to find the moment again. There are so many places where it could be hidden."