When Blanche Met Brando: The Scandalous Story of "A Streetcar Named Desire"

... Show More
Exhaustively researched and almost flirtatiously opinionated, W hen Blanche Met Brando is everything a fan needs to know about the ground-breaking New York and London stage productions of Williams' "Streetcar" as well as the classic Brando/Leigh film. Sam Staggs' interviews with all the living cast members of each production will enhance what's known about the play and movie, and help make this book satisfying as both a pop culture read and as a deeper piece of thinking about a well-known story.

Readers will come away from this book delighted with the juicy behind-the-scenes stories about cast, director, playwright and the various productions and will also renew their curiosity about the connection between the role of Blanche and Viven Leigh's insatiable sexual appetite and later descent into breakdown. They may also--for the first time--question whether the character of Blanche was actually "mad" or whether her anxiousness was symptomatic of another disorder.

"A Streetcar Named Desire" is one of the most haunting and most-studied modern plays. Staggs' new book will fascinate fans and richen newcomers' understanding of its importance in American theater and movie history.

Community Reviews

Rating(4.3 / 5.0, 20 votes)
5 stars
10(50%)
4 stars
5(25%)
3 stars
5(25%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
20 reviews All reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

A history of Tennessee Williams' "A Streetcar Named Desire" is explored here, with a particular focus on the original 1947 Broadway production and the 1951 film. Both of these played a significant role in catapulting Marlon Brando to stardom. Hidden within the book are several interesting, albeit mostly gossipy tidbits. However, the book is written in a personal and idiosyncratic style. Initially, it can be quite fun, but by the halfway point, it begins to wear one down. It seems as if the author is attempting to emulate the style that Ethan Mordden employs in his series of books on Broadway history. Yet, while Mordden's books are a delight to read, this one unfortunately becomes a bit of a chore. It's like a long, drawn-out Vanity Fair article that eventually runs out of steam. Most irritatingly, the author disrespects Jessica Tandy, who was the original Blanche on stage, even though he didn't witness her in the role. His judgment is based solely on a televised excerpt that she appeared in years later.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This article is essentially a biography that delves into the transformation of a great play into an equally great movie.

The author has clearly conducted extensive research, which is evident in the detailed and accurate information presented.

The writing style is also quite good, making the content engaging and easy to follow.

It takes the reader on a journey through the development of the play, highlighting its key aspects and the decisions that led to its successful adaptation into a movie.

Overall, this is a well-written and informative piece that provides valuable insights into the world of theater and film.

Whether you are a fan of the original play, the movie, or simply interested in the creative process behind such adaptations, this article is definitely worth a read.

It offers a unique perspective and showcases the talent and hard work that goes into bringing a great story to life on both the stage and the screen.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I so very much enjoyed Mr. Staggs' informative and amusing background story, "All About All About Eve." It was truly a delight to read. As a result, I delved right into "When Blanche Met Brando: The Scandalous Story of 'A Streetcar Named Desire.'" However, after slogging through hundreds of pages, I'm sorry to say that I did not have the same experience.

There is nothing new here. Every date of historical note regarding both the Broadway production and the film version of the play (and there are a LOT of them) are noted with numbing efficiency. Each of the tales, "scandals," gossipy backstage stories, and censorship troubles have been well documented before. It seems that literally every single piece of information has been reported upon more than once. And being a fan of "Streetcar," I've read them all.

If you have no real background information on the play and you're interested, this might be a book to hold your attention. However, do not expect any light moments. Well, perhaps there is ONE - when there was a brief discussion about Shelley Winters playing Blanche and the author opines that it would be the one time when Blanche was more masculine than Stanley. But for anybody who is a Tennessee Williams devotee, this will be a dry re-hash, I'm very sorry to say.
July 15,2025
... Show More
There's a wealth of impressive research that lies beneath Sam Staggs' history of Tennessee Williams' most renowned play.

Particularly, as he delves into the original Broadway production and the 1951 film version, his work seems quite comprehensive.

However, he unfortunately brings some rather definite prejudices to bear on his storytelling.

Mr. Staggs has firmly decided that the Method is the only way, the absolute truth, and the guiding light.

Consequently, he completely trashes Jessica Tandy's performance as Blanche. He bases this harsh judgment solely on having witnessed her perform a scene many years later on TV and having recorded some scenes for radio.

He treats Judith Evelyn even worse. She played Blanche in one of the two touring productions.

Apparently, he has no knowledge of her extensive stage career. If he did, he would know that she was a major dramatic star and her casting was quite a coup.

Instead, he focuses only on her supporting roles in films and then reports entirely on a memo that recounts her causing trouble during costume fittings.

Those two actresses truly deserve a great deal better than such unfair treatment. So, be forewarned.

If you know and admire their work, you're likely going to end up royally pissed off.
July 15,2025
... Show More

It is truly very interesting indeed. One of the most fascinating aspects is getting to learn the back story of the play. This provides a deeper understanding and adds an extra layer of richness to the overall experience. Additionally, delving more into the life and works of Williams is equally captivating. By exploring his background, his creative process, and the influences that shaped his writing, we gain a greater appreciation for his genius. It allows us to see how his personal experiences and emotions were translated onto the stage, creating powerful and memorable works. Overall, learning about the back story of the play and more about Williams is a journey that enriches our understanding and enjoyment of the theatrical art form.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Staggs is truly a delight to read. His works are filled with charm and entertainment. However, every so often, he delves into the realm of quasi-academic "camp" literary theory.

This tendency is also present in his book "All About All About Eve." But interestingly, in this earlier work, it seems to function a little more effectively.

Perhaps it's because the context and the overall narrative of the book allow for a more seamless integration of this theoretical aspect.

Staggs manages to strike a balance between providing an engaging read and introducing these somewhat esoteric literary concepts.

His exploration of "camp" in "All About All About Eve" adds an extra layer of depth and complexity to the work, making it not just a simple analysis but a more thought-provoking examination of the subject matter.

Overall, while his forays into quasi-academic theory may not always be to everyone's taste, in this particular book, they do contribute to making it a more unique and interesting read.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Such a huge disappointment.
My all time favorite piece of dramatic literature, one of my favorite movies, and the topic of my college thesis, I have long loved "A Streetcar Named Desire."
I was so excited to find this book, which promised a behind the scenes look at the original Broadway production, its transfer to film, and subsequent productions.
However, in spite of the amazingly interesting source material, this book is a complete snooze.
The writing is awful, in a pretentious way.
The author actually gives opinions on performances he hasn't seen and second guesses the opinions of those who were in the audience!
The best example of the awful writing was this line regarding a production of 'Streetcar' by a Deaf company: "Perhaps it's fair to say that American Sign Language is harder than Esperanto, but easier than Hungarian."
The book is peppered with bizarre and arbitrary sentences like that.
I'm giving it two stars just because there are some really interesting bits of information here on one of the greatest plays of the 20th century.
It's a shame that the writing fails to do justice to the fascinating subject matter.
Overall, I was left feeling let down by what could have been a great book.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I found this book extremely absorbing.

I have perused several books that delve deeply into the making of films. I have also read works by this author and others.

This particular book delves into every detail of the film, including some of the extras who appeared in it.

It provides a comprehensive and in-depth exploration of all aspects related to the film's production.

The author's attention to detail is remarkable, and it makes for a truly engaging read.

Whether you are a film enthusiast or simply interested in learning more about the behind-the-scenes process of filmmaking, this book is well worth reading.

It offers valuable insights and perspectives that will enhance your understanding and appreciation of the art of cinema.

Overall, I highly recommend this book to anyone looking for a fascinating and informative read about the making of films.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.