Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
34(34%)
4 stars
35(35%)
3 stars
31(31%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
A good science fantasy novel

American author Madeleine L'Engle crafted a remarkable science fantasy novel titled A Wrinkle in Time, which was initially published in 1962. This book achieved significant acclaim, winning the Newbery Medal, Sequoyah Book Award, and Lewis Carroll Shelf Award, and it was also the runner-up for the Hans Christian Andersen Award. It is a part of L'Engle's Time Quintet, following the Murrys and Calvin O'Keefe.

The story revolves around a thirteen-year-old girl named Meg Murry, along with her twins Sandy and Dennys, and her five-year-old brother Charles Wallace Murry. They embark on a journey to rescue their missing scientist father. They are joined by good characters like Calvin, Mrs. Whatsit, and Mrs. Who, and they have to battle against evil forces such as IT. At the start of the story, Meg's classmates and teachers don't like her and even think she is stupid. They believe she doesn't belong in the scientist's family because of her talented parents. The family consists of her scientist mother Katherine, her missing scientist father Alexander, and a child genius Charles Wallace who can sometimes read Meg's mind. Her parents, however, think she is very smart but just needs time to prove it.
I have a great affection for this novel as it presents readers with the wise thoughts of the good characters, especially Meg, as they combat the bad guys. People around her in school often assume Meg isn't smart because she struggles in some aspects of her studies. But she ultimately proves her intelligence during the adventure to save her father. The novel reveals to me that not everything is as simple as it appears on the surface. People should think and feel more deeply to uncover the truth. This novel, a fictional story for young readers, is regarded as an important teaching book. The author directly focuses on the profound and delicate issues that young people must confront, such as death, social conformity, and truth. In the book, the author designs unpredictable scenes to engage and entertain the readers. A Wrinkle in Time is indeed a valuable novel worth reading.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I have a rather specific opinion about this trilogy.

To be honest, I only had a genuine liking for the story 'A Wrinkle In Time' within this trilogy.

The reason is that the next two stories seemed to have some drawbacks. They lacked the clear conflict/resolution scheme that was so prominent in the original plot.

Moreover, the neat and steady pacing that made the first story so engaging was also absent.

Admittedly, the concepts of time traveling and mind exploration in these stories are quite interesting.

Nevertheless, the paragraphs in the latter two stories became overly busy.

As a result, you often need to re-read what you have read in the past few pages to truly understand what is happening.

This can be a bit of a hindrance to the reading experience and makes it less enjoyable compared to the first installment.

In conclusion, while the trilogy has some interesting ideas, the quality seems to decline after the first story.
July 15,2025
... Show More



WARNING This review is filled with comments and thoughts that might overwhelm you, just as this book series overwhelmed me, causing a severe migraine and a bad mood as a secondary effect. So, if you're sensitive, please stay away.

This series really confused me. In fact, I haven't been this confused in a long time. But first, I need to share a brief personal experience so you can better understand my confusion.
In 2013, I went on an exchange program to Quebec, Canada. I thought, "Okay, it's Canada. People here speak English, and English is my second language, so it'll be fine." Unfortunately, I ended up staying with a 95% French-speaking family. It was horrible not being able to understand French or know more than a tiny fraction of their language. But I still remember the worst day of all.
The family was invited to a dinner at an aunt's house, and of course, I had to go. But I didn't expect everything to be so bad for me. Everyone spoke French the whole time! I didn't understand a single word and just sat there looking confused, with the fakest happy face you could imagine. The words started to overwhelm my brain, increasing my anxiety and desperation, and giving me a feeling of "I have to get out of here" that I've never experienced before.
This is what happened with the "A Wrinkle In Time" series.

The idea behind it is wonderful. I mean, who doesn't like space travel and fantasy these days when books of that kind are so popular? However, the development of the ideas is poor and disappointing.
But I need to talk about each book so you can see what's bothering me about each one.

I liked "A Wrinkle In Time." It's by far my favorite book in the trilogy. I liked the characters, the setting, and the conflict, including the concept of the tesseract, which is kind of crazy but acceptable since it's science fiction. However, I felt that the ending was very incomplete. Mrs. Whatsit, Mrs. Who, and Mrs. Which disappear out of nowhere, and the book ends abruptly there. "All right, that's going to be explained in the other books," I thought foolishly. But they weren't mentioned again! It's like the whole adventure never happened, and we never learn more about those three characters. Why?!
The adventure is never mentioned again, the old ladies never appear again, and the children never talk to each other about what happened. Did the kids have early Alzheimer's? Were they injected with some amnesic substance by Mr. Murry? Did they think it was a dream? Were they hallucinating?

I was really upset about that. I wanted to know more, but now I can't because L'Engle left everything inconclusive. That really sucks.

Then there's book #2, "A Wind In The Door," which is my least favorite book in the trilogy. It's really slow, and in some parts, it's really boring and tedious, especially when they explain things over and over again until we're sick of it. The ending just comes out of nowhere, as if L'Engle didn't have anything "magically" more to add, so she invented a strong wind that blew all the doors, even though it had nothing to do with the story.

And finally, book #3, "A Swiftly Tilting Planet." Oh my, I really tried my best to love this story, but in the end, I couldn't. It was just too much. It has time travel, which I love, and the idea of changing the future by altering the past or finding a "might-have-been" was absolutely fabulous. But again, it wasn't well explained or developed at all.
We're so confused with all the time travel and so many characters with similar names like Zillah, Zillo, Bran, Zylle, Maddox, Madoc, Gwen, Gwyrel, Chuck, Charles, etc. that you end up not understanding anything, like where we're going, what's going on, who's who, or who did what. It's the most confusing book I've ever read. It's cool that everything was connected, but it was just enough. I even skipped 70 pages that talked about Mathew Maddox, whom nobody cares about.
It ended okay (compared to the other two books), and although the ideas are better in book #3, it's the worst explained.

In all three books, we have our main three characters: Meg Murry, Charles Wallace, and Calvin O'Keefe.

Calvin is my favorite character. He's smart but not too much, strong, cute, and sometimes romantic with Meg. He helps when it's the right moment, and I hated that he didn't appear in book #3, despite the fact that he married Meg and had a baby with her.

Meg, ugh, she's so sensitive that it annoys me. She cries about everything and for no reason. She gets hysterical all the time, and one second she's angry, and the next second she's happy. What the f*ck? Is she sick? Seriously, something's not right with that girl. Fortunately, she acts more normal in book #3, which is better because in book #2, she's unbearable.

I like Charles Wallace, even though at first he scared me because he was so smart. Too smart. But then he gets to a more normal (?) stage of life.

Now, I gave the series 3 stars because:

**** (A Wrinkle In Time) + ** (A Wind In The Door) + *** (A Swiftly Tilting Planet) / 3 = * * *

So, if you're planning to read the series, I only recommend you read "A Wrinkle In Time." But maybe you can try the other two; I hope your patience lasts longer than mine.

July 15,2025
... Show More
My partner was truly astonished when I confessed that I had never read the books. This topic only emerged due to the movie. I watched the movie, and although it can never compare to the book, it did manage to spark my interest, even though I'm not typically a fan of sci-fi and fantasy.

However, this! This story captivated my attention just like The Never-ending Story did when I was a child! Now, I own the trilogy and am completely fascinated by tesseracts, Meg, Charles Wallace, and of course, the mysterious "Mrs" figures who appear in their path.

This novel delves into the delicate boundary between science and fiction, pulling the reader into the lives of Meg and Charles Wallace with its intricate twists and turns.

Don't forget to visit my YouTube channel for more reviews here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i1OgT...
July 15,2025
... Show More
I originally intended to read just "Wrinkle in Time". However, I then noticed that I had the entire trilogy.

I truly relished "Wrinkle in Time". Nevertheless, "The Wind in the Door" and "A Swiftly Tilting Planet" seemed rather bland in comparison.

Most likely, a significant portion of this can be attributed to the fact that these are children's books.

Nonetheless, I firmly believe that a child would take great pleasure in this book. Perhaps the best approach would be to read it aloud to some younger kids. This way, they can fully immerse themselves in the magical world and captivating story that the book has to offer.

It would be a wonderful experience for both the reader and the listeners, creating memories and激发 their imagination.

Overall, despite the differences in quality among the books in the trilogy, "Wrinkle in Time" remains a remarkable and engaging read that can bring joy to children and adults alike.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This trilogy is truly a work of wonder, filled with incredibly vivid and imaginative elements. It presents the reader with a story that is like a fairytale for a young child, yet it also has a depth and complexity that makes it thought-provoking. As we follow the adventures of Meg and Charles, we are drawn into a progressively unfolding narrative that keeps us on the edge of our seats.

The characters are well-developed and relatable, and their problems and challenges are ones that many of us can identify with. We root for Meg and Charles as they face seemingly insurmountable obstacles, and we are inspired by their courage and determination.

Overall, this trilogy is a must-read for anyone who loves a good story. It has something for everyone, whether you are a child or an adult, and it will leave you with a sense of wonder and a desire to read more.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly have a deep affection for this book, although it frequently causes me to experience minor frustration palpitations. This is a reread, which means I'm not as objective as I would be if I were approaching it for the very first time.

The relationship between Meg and Calvin in the first book continues to drive me crazy because it seems to come out of nowhere. Additionally, the heavy-handed religious aspect persists in annoying me. However, I was aware of what I was getting into the first time around, and I don't wish to make a big deal about it. It remains a light, enjoyable, and easy read. I still have a great love for the relationships within the family. I truly enjoy Charles Wallace. So, I'll give it that.

I'm awarding three stars for all the old love I had for this book and for the fact that I can still reread it with pleasure, even though I had to write an essay on it just last month. It's remarkable how a book can still hold a certain charm and appeal, despite the flaws that become more evident upon subsequent readings. This particular book has a special place in my heart, and I look forward to many more rereads in the future.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I absolutely loved it so much!!! It was truly an amazing experience.

Every single moment was filled with excitement and joy. The details were so well thought out and presented in a way that kept me engaged from start to finish.

I couldn't put it down and found myself completely immersed in the story. It had a unique charm that set it apart from other works.

The author's writing style was captivating and made the words come alive on the page. I highly recommend that everyone reads it. You won't be disappointed! ❤️
July 15,2025
... Show More
This story is extremely entertaining.

It has the power to grip you from the very beginning and keep you completely engaged, making you unable to put it down. You'll find yourself sitting on the edge of your seat, completely immersed in the narrative.

The author masterfully weaves a tale that elicits a range of emotions, causing your heart to race with both excitement and fear.

It's a thrilling adventure that takes you on a wild ride through a world filled with mystery, danger, and unexpected twists.

I wholeheartedly encourage people, especially those who are still young, to pick up this book and embark on this unforgettable literary journey.

You'll be glad you did, as it will leave you with a sense of wonder and a desire for more.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I mean, it's a classic?


A classic is something that has withstood the test of time. It is a work that has endured and continues to be relevant and influential. Classics can be found in various forms such as literature, art, music, and film.


They often possess certain qualities that make them stand out. For example, a classic novel may have a well-developed plot, complex characters, and beautiful prose. A classic painting may have a unique style and composition that captures the essence of the subject. A classic piece of music may have a memorable melody and harmonious arrangement.


The term "classic" is subjective to some extent, as different people may have different opinions on what constitutes a classic. However, there are certain works that are widely regarded as classics by the majority. These works have become an important part of our cultural heritage and continue to inspire and delight generations of people.


In conclusion, when we say "it's a classic," we are acknowledging the significance and value of a particular work. It is a testament to its quality and enduring appeal.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Last time I read this, I was only 14 years old. At that time, I was just a young and innocent teenager, and perhaps I didn't fully understand the profound meaning hidden within the words. However, now that I'm 23, when I picked up this piece of writing again, it still held the same power and significance for me.


It's truly amazing how some things can remain so unchanged and yet have a completely different impact on us as we grow and mature. This time around, as I delved into the words, I was able to see the message of love triumphing over evil with even greater clarity and conviction. It serves as a powerful reminder that no matter how dark and difficult the world may seem at times, love always has the ability to prevail.


Love is a force that can overcome hatred, jealousy, and all forms of evil. It has the power to heal wounds, bring people together, and create a better world. This simple yet profound truth has been with me throughout my life, and it continues to inspire me to be a better person and to spread love wherever I go.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I did like the first one. It was very well thought out. However, it did leave you with a lot of questions.

Unfortunately, most of those questions are not answered in the next two books. Instead, it continues a story and one still wonders how.

The third book is way better than the second book. It helps explain the purpose of the second.

But overall, the storyline is very jumpy. It seems to lack a smooth flow, which makes it a bit difficult for the reader to fully engage and understand the entire plot.

Despite this, the author has managed to create an interesting world and characters that keep the reader intrigued.

Perhaps with a bit more refinement and a more连贯的 storyline, the series could be even better.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.