Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 93 votes)
5 stars
36(39%)
4 stars
29(31%)
3 stars
28(30%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
93 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More

My introduction to several months of study of "Ulysses" by Joyce has been an enlightening journey. This work is not an exhaustive biography by any means. Instead, it can be seen as a love letter from a major Irish author to her forebear. O'Brien clearly holds Joyce in high regard, flaws and all. She delves into the various aspects of Joyce's life and work, providing valuable insights and interpretations. The book is a quick and worthwhile read, as it offers a unique perspective on one of the most important literary figures of the 20th century. Through her study, O'Brien helps readers to better understand the genius and complexity of Joyce's "Ulysses", and to appreciate the significance of this literary masterpiece.

July 14,2025
... Show More
Biography is a complex and challenging art form, requiring no less in the way of writerly skills than novel writing. The subject of a biography is a character who must be brought to life and developed, with conflict and resolution extracted from the countless details of daily life and woven into a narrative. What we ultimately have is not a comprehensive account of a life, but rather a particular perspective; it is as much fiction as it is fact.

It is therefore understandable that the Penguin Lives series employs well-known novelists to write their short biographies. Just as Jane Smiley's Dickens: A Life does, Edna O'Brien's Joyce: A Life presents a story. Her Joyce is not the same as Ellmann's Joyce, or Gilbert's Joyce, or the Joyce presented by his brother Stanislaus, although O'Brien acknowledges her indebtedness to those biographies. O'Brien's Joyce is a unique character, earthy and full of passion and hubris, with the story constructed around the development of Joyce's work.

The writing in this biography is playful and referential, inspired by a close reading of both Ulysses and Finnegan's Wake. The book contains some of the most concise and well-crafted summaries of these two works that I have encountered anywhere. Of course, there is far more to Ulysses and Finnegan's Wake than any summary can convey, but O'Brien assumes the reader's interest and familiarity and makes a tender and informed connection between the events of Joyce's life and the resulting work.

The biography unfolds chronologically, beginning with Joyce's school days and presenting the context of Ireland at the time, as well as his relationships with his father and mother, which are crucial, as any reader of Ulysses would know, to his characters. It then quickly moves into Joyce's adult life, his relationship with Nora Barnacle, and his move to Italy, where he struggles with his appetites, his penchant for debauchery, and his meager finances. Later, there are patronages, support and rebukes, censorship, health problems, business ventures, and the loss of his eyesight, war, and a series of betrayals, some of which are brilliantly avenged in the pages of his work. Ireland, of course, is Joyce's greatest betrayer, failing to publish or promote him and driving him into permanent exile, a subject that O'Brien understands and portrays masterfully. Above all, O'Brien takes pleasure in the words that Joyce has left behind, words that have become the centerpiece of this concise yet powerful biography.

O'Brien is never critical of the man, even when he rather flippantly abuses the unwavering affection and support of Harriet Weaver. Readers will also feel sympathy for Nora, who is left to fend for herself with little financial support and two young children while James lives it up. Nora is so well-portrayed in this book that the connection between Molly Bloom and Nora becomes crystal clear. Others who are sacrificed on the altar of Joyce's art include his brother Stanislaus and his children. Although there is little mention of young Giorgio, Lucia's madness and Joyce's influence on it, as well as the pain it causes him and his work, are both chronicled. Although O'Brien's Joyce is a flawed character, often abusing others with a self-confidence bordering on narcissism, he remains both fascinating and oddly likeable. For those of us, like O'Brien, who are deeply in Joyce's literary debt for what he has created and who cannot imagine the world of literature without the linguistic play his writing has enabled, this is a joyful book, full of fun, interest, and great imagination. I suspect that Joyce himself would have approved.

Article first published as Book Review: James Joyce: A Life by Edna O'Brien on Blogcritics.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Highly recommend the audio version.

It is truly a great pleasure to sample Joyce's novels through audio books. You will be completely mesmerized by his remarkable linguistic skill and his meticulous attention to the sound and beauty of words. This makes the books extremely approachable.

Edna O'Brien writes so lyrically with enthusiastic flourishes when she describes James Joyce's writing, and it pairs up very well with listening to Joyce. The section on Ulysses will give you the confidence that you can venture into some of the chapters without getting frustrated and giving up, as Joyce can be quite obscure. (I, for one, am going to attempt Chapter 18, Penelope.)

She does a wonderful job of outlining Joyce's life and his many flaws. In fact, the only thing that can really be praised about Joyce is his writing.

If you are seeking a more standard biography that objectively delves into most of the layers that Joyce presents both as a person and in his books, you might prefer the Ellmann biography.

However, this audio version offers a unique and engaging way to experience Joyce's works and gain a deeper understanding of his literary genius.
July 14,2025
... Show More

An odd experience indeed: during my college days, I seemingly had a profound love for Joyce. I delved into his works and even read Ellmann's biography. I was of the opinion that Joyce was more or less right about everything.


Here I am, less than 15 years later, reading O'Brien's short life in anticipation of re-reading Joyce's work (excluding the Wake). However, I have arrived at almost the exact opposite conclusion. I now think that Joyce is more or less wrong about everything. He was an awful human being who hid behind tiresome romantic cliches regarding Truth and Beauty. His prodigious linguistic talents were squandered on puerile and dull topics and ideas. He wrote at great length about his own non-existent victimization and the objects he had fondled at various times, and then justified it all with some half-hearted discussion of the inner spiritual essence of whatever.


And this book exacerbates those feelings, simply because O'Brien allows those cliches and puerilities to be regarded as marks of Genius and Independence. She believes that "writers have to be such monsters in order to create," which is so blatantly false that it's difficult to fathom what she is talking about.


On the positive side, it is a short and relatively easy read. O'Brien throws in the odd Joyceism, but they can be ignored. The real problem, as with anyone who self-consciously follows Joyce, is that she writes sentences rather than paragraphs. That's fine if you want to quote a hagiographical sentiment in a pub, but not so great if you want to read, understand, or, heaven forbid, criticize what you are reading.


More specifically, there is almost nothing in her about PAYM, and I have no idea why.

July 14,2025
... Show More
James Joyce is a highly influential figure in the world of literature.

He was born in Dublin, Ireland in 1882. Joyce's life was filled with both struggles and triumphs. He had a complex relationship with his homeland, which is often reflected in his works.

His thinking was deeply influenced by various philosophical and literary traditions. He was interested in exploring the inner workings of the human mind and the nature of consciousness.

Joyce's writing is known for its experimental style and its use of stream-of-consciousness technique. His works, such as "Ulysses" and "Finnegans Wake," are considered masterpieces of modernist literature.

Despite facing initial criticism and censorship, Joyce's works have had a profound impact on subsequent generations of writers. His unique approach to storytelling and his exploration of the human condition continue to inspire and challenge readers today.

Overall, James Joyce is a remarkable writer whose life, thinking, and writing have left an indelible mark on the history of literature.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Hardly a standard biography and not quite literary criticism either, though there are elements of both here certainly.

It would perhaps be too glib to call this a portrait of the artist. O’Brien assumes her readers have a familiarity with both the outline of Joyce’s life and his major works.

She dives right into the story, parodying Joyce’s style.

Once upon a time there was a man coming down a road in Dublin and he gave himself the name of Dedalus the sorcerer, constructor of labyrinths and maker of wings for Icarus who flew so close to the sun that he fell, as the apostolic Dubliner James Joyce would fall deep into a world of words—from the “epiphanies” of youth to the epistomadologies of later years.

Baby Tuckoo indeed. I liked this, it was refreshing. However, I could not recommend it to anyone who hasn’t already read Richard Ellmann’s 1959 biography, which Anthony Burgess called “the greatest literary biography of the century”.

One should also be familiar enough with Joyce’s output that the allusions and references make sense.

In which case, this will prove a lovingly eccentric reflection on the author’s life and work.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Finished this on the last day of the year.

All in all, I truly enjoyed this book. It presumes that the reader has perused Joyce's works (as there are spoilers aplenty throughout; some in great detail) and is well-versed in Joyce's life. I, on the other hand, came in having read only one of his books and knowing next to nothing about his life.

In those respects, the book breezes through Joyce's life, spotlighting the key details and significant events, without delving into analysis or providing explanations. In truth, none are really necessary. Some questions were raised due to my lack of knowledge, so perhaps one day a more comprehensive biography would be in order.

I've got to admit that I'm now rather intrigued by the missing details regarding how he became the person he was. Joyce comes across as a somewhat arrogant individual, but beneath the surface, he seems to live with a great deal of loneliness and insecurity. Then again, maybe not.

----------

(page 47)

I'm not entirely sure whether to laugh or not. I entered this book with very minimal knowledge about Joyce's life.

So far, O'Brien presents Joyce's life in small snippets of fact, interwoven with a Joycean-type writing style of filler. It's a rather Ulyssian read for such a diminutive book.

That being said, many of the events in Joyce's life appear to have resurfaced in Ulysses and, according to O'Brien, A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man. The man seemingly didn't forget a single fact of the events he lived through. Incredible memory indeed. And excellent journal-keeping.

The timelines are rather jumpy: we move through Joyce's childhood, then leap to his father's teenage/pre-marriage years, then to his father's deathbed, and then back to young adult Joyce.

According to O'Brien's interpretation, Joyce was a complete jerk in many ways. Bummer, if that's true. However, I'm not convinced that O'Brien's interpretation is anywhere close to the truth, aside from a few well-documented chronological facts.

----------

(pg 101)

Strange little book, yet enjoyable in a rather odd way. The author assumes that the reader has a basic understanding of Joyce's life. It's a bit disjointed and somewhat lacking in details, but there's enough there to maintain interest, and someone like myself, who doesn't know much about Joyce, can still keep up and find this an engaging read.

There's some commentary on his works (so those who don't want minor spoilers to his work might want to postpone reading this book until after reading them), some commentary on his life, and a basic overview of his life. He doesn't come across as a particularly nice person most of the time.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Edna O'Brien offers a deeply compassionate perspective on the tumultuous and tortured existence of James Joyce.

She delves into the lives of not only Joyce himself but also his wife, children, parents, and siblings.

Almost without fail, the details within his books are sourced from the experiences of these beloved individuals, as well as his friends, competitors, foes, and the city of Dublin.

Alcoholism, guilt, mental illness, deteriorating eyesight, and various other undiagnosed health issues were among the personal trials that Joyce had to confront.

Despite these numerous challenges, he managed to pen great stories that have endured through the ages.

His ability to create such masterpieces in the face of so much adversity is truly remarkable and a testament to his extraordinary talent and determination.

O'Brien's exploration of Joyce's life provides a fascinating and poignant insight into the man behind the literary legend.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Read in Swedish, perhaps I should have read it in the original language, but it was still enjoyable and gave an interesting portrait of Joyce.

It makes me eager to take on Ulysses again!

This short text reflects the experience of reading a work related to Joyce in Swedish. Despite not reading it in the original language, the reader still found the reading to be pleasant and gained an interesting understanding of Joyce. The mention of wanting to tackle Ulysses again shows the reader's curiosity and enthusiasm for Joyce's works.

It could be that the Swedish translation captured some of the essence and魅力 of the original, allowing the reader to engage with the material.

Overall, this brief account highlights the power of literature to engage and inspire readers, even when read in a different language.
July 14,2025
... Show More
This cannot have been an easy book to write.

Distilling a major author, perhaps the author of the 20th century, down to a mere 178 small pages is no mean feat. It covers his complex and often difficult relationships with family, friends, and his native country, while also delving into his books.

I was truly impressed with how skillfully Edna O'Brien accomplished this. It's a short book, but by no means an easy one. The vocabulary is rich and nuanced, the style is sophisticated, and the depth of analysis is remarkable.

Perhaps it would be better appreciated by a more literary-minded person than myself, but I still found great enjoyment and interest in it. It offered a fascinating glimpse into the life and works of a significant literary figure.

Overall, it's a book that I would recommend to anyone with an interest in literature and the lives of great authors.
July 14,2025
... Show More
This short biography, like many others, is a bit too idolizing for its own good. However, O'Brien manages to create a good story out of this cult, and doesn't even hide the dirty - James Joyce was, to a large extent, a scoundrel.

Half - sincere, half - passionate, the book is engaging, informative and, damn it, exciting. It delves into the life of Joyce, revealing both his flaws and his genius. The author doesn't shy away from presenting the less flattering aspects of Joyce's character, which makes the biography all the more interesting.

Despite its idolizing tendencies, the book offers a unique perspective on Joyce and his work. It shows how his life experiences influenced his writing and how he became one of the most important figures in modern literature.

Overall, this is a must - read for anyone interested in James Joyce or modern literature. It's a fascinating and well - written biography that will leave you with a deeper understanding of one of the greatest writers of the 20th century.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Edna O'Brien offers a comprehensive view of the life of James Joyce in this short biography of the Irish writer.

I confess that I knew little about his biography, but I wasn't entirely surprised by his tumultuous life, largely due to his own excesses. Some may say it's a matter of genius, while others will claim it's about the excesses that all human beings have. However, among the biographies I have read, whether of authors, artists, actors, etc., it's difficult to find lives that don't have their "sins," both small and large.

Joyce's life was filled with various experiences and challenges. He had a complex relationship with his family, faced financial difficulties, and struggled with his own demons. His works, though highly regarded today, were not always well-received during his lifetime.

Despite all the hardships, Joyce remained dedicated to his craft and continued to produce some of the most influential works in literature. His unique writing style and exploration of human nature have had a profound impact on generations of writers.

Overall, Edna O'Brien's biography provides a fascinating glimpse into the life of James Joyce, highlighting both his achievements and his flaws. It serves as a reminder that even the most remarkable individuals have a story to tell, and that their lives are often a complex mix of triumphs and tragedies.

 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.