...
Show More
A (perhaps) more nuanced and complete review can be found here: https://youtu.be/WXr4na44a-g
Clavell's debut novel is the story of life in a Japanese POW camp, and was semi-autobiographical. This seems odd to consider as part of his "Asian Saga" as it really touches upon other themes, and appears to have no tie-ins to the rest of the books. (Unless some of these characters end up in Noble House, book 5). Additionally, this story lacked the East vs. West narrative that made so many of the other books compelling. At times the narrative was incredibly meandering, and honestly dull. But Clavell's conclusion - especially the last 50 pages - was quite strong. I wish that a lot of the themes he explored so well at the end had been incorporated into the text, which honestly had a lot of frippery that seemed inconsequential. 3.5/5
Clavell's debut novel is the story of life in a Japanese POW camp, and was semi-autobiographical. This seems odd to consider as part of his "Asian Saga" as it really touches upon other themes, and appears to have no tie-ins to the rest of the books. (Unless some of these characters end up in Noble House, book 5). Additionally, this story lacked the East vs. West narrative that made so many of the other books compelling. At times the narrative was incredibly meandering, and honestly dull. But Clavell's conclusion - especially the last 50 pages - was quite strong. I wish that a lot of the themes he explored so well at the end had been incorporated into the text, which honestly had a lot of frippery that seemed inconsequential. 3.5/5