Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 98 votes)
5 stars
23(23%)
4 stars
38(39%)
3 stars
37(38%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
98 reviews
March 26,2025
... Show More
ما هذه القدره المذهله
أعتقد أنِّى مهمـا قرأت لن أقرأ لأحد يكتب مثل ما يكتب ماركيز

قصه لم تكن مبهره لكن غندما يكتبها ماركيز فهى كافيه كى يعبث فى جذورها وطرحها بهذا الاسلوب المذهل الذى طالما ادهشنى

أحقاً يوجد أفضل من ماركيز ؟
لا أعرف وأحتاج الكثير والكثير لكى اجيب على هذا السؤال

March 26,2025
... Show More
muhteşemdi, muhteşem! işleneceği baştan beri bilinen cinayeti nasıl anlatabilirsin diye düşünmüştüm kitaba başlarken. sanırım bundan güzel anlatılamazdı. başı ve sonu bir tutup sürekli o noktadan çıkıp ufak halkalar çizerek o noktaya dönmesiyle çiçek gibi bir kurgu yaptı adeta :) bayıldım. gördüğüm herkese öveceğim, insanları bıktıracağım kitaplardan biri oldu kırmızı pazartesi.
March 26,2025
... Show More
"Kırmızı Pazartesi" Marquez'in kendine has dilini/kurgusunu taşıyan, kısa ama vurucu bir roman. Herkesin işleneceğini bildiği ancak bir müdahalede bulunmadığı bir cinayete giden yolları ayrıntılı bir şekilde aktaran Marquez aslında toplumun sosyo kültürel yapısının, nasıl namus cinayetlerini legalleştirdiğini açıkça ortaya koyuyor.

Namus cinayetleri bizim ülkemizde de aynı Kırmızı Pazartesi'de olduğu şekliyle yaşanageldi yıllardır. Toplumun her kesiminden insanın, namus cinayetlerini gerek ekonomik sebeplerle, gerek dini sebeplerle, gerek "ahlaksal"(!) sebeplerle, gerek kişisel/ailesel sebeplerle normalleştirebilecek/meşrulaştırabilecek sebepleri var. Bu mide bulandırıcı durum, çeşitli sebeplerle kanıksattırılabiliyor.

İşte kitabı okurken düşündüğüm bir şey varsa bizim çok kırmızı pazartesimiz, salımız, cumamız, perşembemiz olduğu. Kadın cinayetleri karşısında herkesin sorumluluğu olan bir ülkede yaşadığımızı düşünüyorum. Bu roman, benim bu sorgulamalarıma daha bütüncül ve üçüncü bir göz olarak bakmamı sağladı. İnsanın kendine hatırlatmalar yapması gereken hassas bir konu bu. Kesinlikle okumanızı tavsiye ederim.
March 26,2025
... Show More
কী বই রে বাবা! পড়ার সময় ভান ধরতেছিলাম যে আমার কিছু হচ্ছে না, আরে, এ আর এমন কি, মার্কেজ চাইলে কত কিছু করতে পারেন, এইটা ত লিটারালি নস্যি, কত খেলা দেখলাম এক এই মার্কেজ বেটার। ভাবছিলাম পড়া শেষ হইলে নিজেরে বলবো, হ্যাঁ, হইলো ত, হাতের সূক্ষ্ম কারুকাজ ছিলো ভালোই, কিন্তু বই হিসাবে, নাহ, তেমন জমে উঠে নাই।

কিন্তু এই অনধিক দেড়শো পাতায় একটা এলাকারে এইভাবে তুলে আনা, একটা ঘটনারে পুঁজি করে এতগুলি চরিত্র, কোনোটা শুধুই কাজ দেখাইতে, আবার কোনো কোনোটা এর ফাঁকেই উপুড় করে দিতে মানুষের মন, প্রচণ্ড উচাটন সব বাক্য, চিরে যাওয়ার মত একেকটা, এবং মার্কেজের কমবয়সের হাতিঘোড়ার কিছুই নাই আর এইখানে। এইখানে এসে মার্কেজ সংযত হইতেছেন মনে হয়, আমার অন্তত সময়কালের বিচারে মনে হচ্ছে যে এই বইয়ের সময়েই মার্কেজ কলেরা এবং তৎপরবর্তী পাথেয়ের সন্ধান পাইছেন, অলৌকিক ঘটনাবলী ঘটাইতে কেউ বাতাসে উড়ে যাওয়া জরুরী না, মানুষের মনের বিচিত্র টান কলমের ডগায় যথেষ্ট অলৌকিক। না হইলে বায়ার্দো সান রোমানের কাজকর্ম, বা পাবলো-পেদ্রোর কীর্তি, বা প্লাসিদা লিনেরোর দুয়ারের খিল এঁটে দেয়া, এইসবরে আর কি উপায়ে ব্যাখ্যা করা যায়?

এইটা মানুষের সাহিত্যের ইতিহাসের একটা মোড়। এর আগে পরে বই লেখা হইছে, কেউ কেউ এত সুন্দর, এত ভয়প্রদ, এত গভীর, এমন কি এর চেয়ে ত এর চেয়ে, মারিয়ানা ট্রেঞ্চের চেয়ে ঢের গভীর কিছুও লিখে থাকতে পারেন, কিন্তু এইরকম বিধ্বংসী পকেট সাইজ হাতবোমা আর কোনো লেখক লিখতে পারবেন বইলা মনে হয় না।
তবে এইরকম হ্যাণ্ডগ্রেনেডও মনে হয় আছে একটা দুইটা, বেশ কয়েকটা। যেমন, ব্রিজ অফ সান লুইস রে। ঐ বইয়ের কি কড়া একটা ছাপ এই বইয়ে নাই? মার্কেজ কিছু না বলে থাকলেও, সম্ভবত আছে। তাতে যদিও সমস্যা নাই, থাকতেই পারে। সুযোগ্য প্রভাব বলতে হবে।

আচ্ছা, হইলো, পৃথিবীর সাহিত্যের অন্যতম সেরা হাতবোমা, সবচেয়ে সেরা যদি নাও হয়।
অবশ্য, অন্য কেউ ত আর এই হাতবোমার কারিগর না, এই লোকটার নাম গার্সিয়া মার্কেজ। উনি সবই পারেন।
March 26,2025
... Show More
n  "On the day they were going to kill him, Santiago Nasar got up at five-thirty in the morning to wait for the boat the bishop was coming on."n


A grand wedding. A gruesome murder. And a multitude of lives changed forever. Chronicle of a Death Foretold is a novella which recounts a fictionalized account inspired by an actual incident of honor-killing in Colombia back in 1951, now immortalized in this 1981 novella.

The story is about the series of events leading up to a murder, and its aftermath. It is written in pseudo-journalistic style in the form of interviewed accounts staged 20 years after the tragedy. The more fantastic aspects of the novel are that the victim is made to be a Jesus-like figure, so much so that his death is almost likened to crucifixion. One can also relate to the theatrics of the death of Julius Caesar while reading this story.
n  
n  n  
n  n    The death of Julius Caesarn  n  
n
Fun fact: The novel led to a 17-year legal battle after a man claimed unlawful use of his life story for the novel.
March 26,2025
... Show More
They had decided he had to die, yet they wished someone had stopped them. The assassins of Santiago Nasar had gone, but in vain, beyond the imaginable not to kill him.
Among the villagers who heard the two Vicario brothers say that they would wash away their sister's honor, some did not believe it, and others who tried something failed with a lot of goodwill. Santiago Nasar died from multiple blows from his murderers.
Will chance or fate, the death of a man depend on a tradition of honor and a combination of unhappy circumstances? The investigator - it seems to be Gabriel Garcia Marquez himself - seems to believe it. And then, Nasar was an Arab, which made him an ideal culprit in this small Caribbean village despite the lack of evidence.
Although brief, this novel is teeming with contradictory sensations and feelings. Gabriel Garcia Marquez takes us into a wild and fascinating world. That's a colorful world, whimsical but authentic, sublimated by the Nobel Prize for Literature winner's admirable narrative imagination.
March 26,2025
... Show More
اقای مارکز لازم بود این داستانو بنویسی؟ حالا گیریم نوشتی، لازم بود منتشرش کنی؟ وات د فاک دود
March 26,2025
... Show More

ما هو انا اللى غلطان اصلا , اذا كان لما قرأت مئة عام من العزلة اول مرة مقدرتش اكملها من الملل وقيمتها بنجمتين وبعد فترة بالعافية كملتها وقييمتها بتلات نجوم , وبيقولوا عليها احسن حاجة كتبها ومش عارف احسن رواية فى التاريخ ومعجبتنيش اوي , اقوم اقرأ قصة موت معلن ما أكيد مش هتعجبني .

ده الرواية 100 صفحة وكنت عايز اخلص منها بسرعة من كتر الملل, الرواية بتحكي يا جماعة عن واحد اسمه سنتياغو ابراهيم نصَّار ده مش تهريج هو اسم ابوه ابراهيم وتقريبا من الطوابق في فيصل, المهم عم الحج سنتياغو عبد الحميد ده اتقتل بس كدا , اقعد انا ليه بأه مئة صفحة اقرأ مات ازاى واللى حواليه كلهم كانوا عارفين انه هيموت , ماشي وبعديييين ما هو اتنيل مات , ايه الجديد بترغي ليه بأه , الله يرحمه يا سيدى عم سنتياغو عبد الحميد ده ويرحم امواتنا .

مش ناقصة والنبي تضييع وقت فى رويات زى ده تانى, اخر تجاربي لماركيز , كنت ناوي اقرأ الحب فى زمن الكوليرا بس مش ناقصة ليجيليى انا اصلا كوليرا من ملل الرواية.
March 26,2025
... Show More
أوصي بهذه الرواية دائماً كمدخل لعوالم ماركيز، قراءة (مئة عام من العزلة) قد تبدو مرهقة ل��بعض بكل واقعيتها السحرية وبكل شخصياتها وتداخل الأسماء فيها، هذه الروية أكثر واقعية، تروي قصة حقيقية عن جريمة معلنة كان الجميع يعلم بوقوعها ولكن لا أحد تدخل لإيقافها، هذه قصتنا كبشر في النهاية، نتابع الأحداث من حولنا ونفهم تداعياتها وإلى أين ستقودنا ولكننا لا نفعل شيئاً حتى يفوت الأوان، فكروا فقط بالـ حروب/ العنصرية/ الطائفية/ الأوضاع الاقتصادية/ الجريمة
March 26,2025
... Show More
n  n


ما الذي جرى لك يا بني سنتياغو؟
تعرف عليها وقال :
-لقد قتلوني أيها الأم ويني

اول تجربة لي مع ماركيز وسعيدة جدًا بها ❤️❤️
الرواية رغم صغر حجمها ولكنها تحمل معانٍ كثيرة وتفجر قضية حقيقة وواقعية

قصة موت معلن" هي توثيق لقصة حقيقة جرت أحداثها عام 1951 في الريف الكولومبي, مسقط رأس "غابرييل غارسيا ماركيز", و تروي حيثيات جريمة قتل سانتياغو نصار على يد الإخوة فيكاريو انتقاماً " لشرف" العائلة بعد أن أعيدت أخت القتلة, "أنخيلا", إلى أهلها من قبل زوجها ليلة الزفاف عندما اكتشف أنها ليست عذراء.

كلنا نعرف قضايا الشرف ، الشرف الذي نحيا به
"قضايا الشرف هي وقف مقدس لا يقربه إلا أصحاب المأسأة (الشرف هو الحب) "

الروايةتدور حول قتل سنتياغو نصار ،كل القرية تعرف أن نصار سيُقتل اليوم ولكن هو نفسه لم يكن يعرف شيء ،" هو راح لقدره برجليه زي ما بيقولوا " ولكن هل أهل القرية هم السبب في قتل سنتياغو لأنهم لم يخبروه ،كأن الجميع تسببوا في قتل سنتياغو حتى أمه التي كانت سبب في غلق الأبواب
الرواية اسم على مسمى قصة لموت معلن ، موت من أول سطور الرواية حتى آخرها تعرف من القاتل ومن المقتول ولكن التفاصيل هي ساحرة خاصة مشهد القتل الأخير ، كأن الرواية بدأت من النهاية للبداية ❤️

"القدر يجعلنا غير مرئيين"

تعاطفت مع سنتياغو نصار كأنه قُتل بدم بارد ، كأنهم حاسبوه على فعل ارتكبه هو وحده أو كأنه اغتصاب وليس برضى الطرف الآخر في علاقة غير شرعية!!
بالنسبه للأخوين فيكاريو هل يمكن اعتبارهم قتلة حقيقون؟ رغم أن أهالي القرية لم يصدقوا لأنهم لا يستطيعون قتل حتى حيوان؟ هل الدفاع عن الشرف يمكن أن يجعل من الإنسان قاتل؟
هل سينسى ذلك الدم الذي تلوثت بيه يده؟ هل سيتخلص من عذاب الضمير ؟



"على الرغم من المرات الكثيرة التي دلكت يها نفسي بالصابون والإسفنجة فإنني لم أستطع انتزاع الرائحة عني "
تعقيبي على الرواية هو تفاصيل ليس لها داعي وكثرة الاسماء في الرواية (قنبلة اسماااء وانفجرت )
March 26,2025
... Show More
n  n

I can't believe I had not written a review for this book. Since I'm constantly recommending it to people, I should have written a review at some point... but I didn't. Now is the time when I try to do it justice with this, as it is one of my fave books.

Chronicle of a Death Foretold... that's exactly what this book is about: A death foretold. You may be asking yourselves, wtf is that? Well, that was pretty much my reaction in 2013 when I read this for the first time.

Santiago Nasar is found dead. He has been stabbed multiple times by a pair of twins (Pablo and Pedro Vicario), but really, that's nothing unusually remarkable - happens every day. What about his death makes it so impressive? The fact that the twins told EVERYONE they were going to kill him.

Funny thing is NO ONE believed them, as they were supposedly the role model of the neighborhood - they would never do such a thing! That's just a joke! And btw, why would they even tell they're planning a murder? Yep, definitely a joke.

Turns out they were speaking seriously.

And that's why it is a chronicle of a death foretold.

The story is narrated through interviews to people who were related to Santiago in some way - be it directly or indirectly. It follows the events that led to the death: How it happened, why they did it, and why no one did anything... or why they actually tried to do something when it was already too late.

This book belongs to magical realism: What happens in it are things that theoretically are normal in real life, but they are so ridiculously improbable of actually happening that they are "magical." Why, you say? Well, this is not fantasy, obviously, but when you're reading the novel, you're always thinking, "please, this is NOT realistic. If someone was threatening to kill another person, people WOULD do something. They would not stay quiet."

Yeah, I agree with that, since that was pretty much me when I read this for the first (and now second) time. But the thing is that the more you read, the more sense the things make. Improbable things suddenly become common and the usual becomes rare.

That's the effect this writer provokes.

Not only did he do that to me, but also the writing is so good (I read the original version in Spanish, so I don't know how the translations are) it grips you. He does not hide any of the facts and it's SHOWING, not telling – meaning the kind of writing we all love.

Characterization is excellent too, even when you never know the characters by some kind of narrator telling you how they think. As I said, the book is written in interviews format, so all you know about everyone is what the author of the article for the newspaper knows, including his own opinions about them.

I am really aware I am babbling right now, but I just wish you could just give this book a try. It's one of those classics that are worth it. It managed to approve the test of the 2015 rereads, which if I remember correctly, has just been approved by one series of all the books I reread.

Anyway, please, please, PLEASE add this book. If you're a fan of magical realism, you should read this too. I know latin-american authors are not very popular, but at least give this one a try. He really deserves your reading time.

I have not read anything else by this author, but I sure will. My mother has recommended me One Hundred Years of Solitude and Love in the Time of Cholera... and I have plans of reading another one of his books. If you have read and liked one of those books, then this is just for you; if you didn't like them, then ehhhh; BUT if you're a newbie, I repeat: READ THIS.
March 26,2025
... Show More
“Lera sem dúvida os clássicos espanhóis, e alguns latinos, e conhecia bastante bem Nietzsche, que era o autor da moda entre os magistrados do seu tempo. As notas à margem, e não apenas pela cor da tinta, pareciam redigidas com sangue. Estava tão perplexo com o enigma que lhe tocara em sorte, que frequentemente incorreu em divagações líricas contrárias ao rigor do seu ofício. Acima de tudo, nunca lhe pareceu legítimo que a vida se servisse de tantos acasos proibidos à literatura, para que viesse a cumprir-se sem entraves uma morte tão anunciada."

Na transição dos livros de mistério em que era viciada em adolescente, este foi um dos primeiros exemplos de “literatura a sério” a que tive acesso. Na altura, impressionou-me que "Crónica de Uma Morte Anunciada" começasse pelo final e, agora, depois de todos os livros com estruturas mais sofisticadas que já li, acho que a admiro ainda mais. A incredulidade e a sensação de impotência é o que permanece após esta releitura, porque quem soube previamente da tragédia que se ia dar não quis, não pôde ou não teve garra suficiente para evitar uma morte descabida.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.