Crime and Punishment in American History by lawrence m. friedman

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

April 26,2025

This book is boring but too useful to abandon. I hate it. 4 Stars for usefulness, minus one because it was so dry it took me almost a month to complete it. I wouldn't recommend it for anyone not actually studying this, unless you really like dry historical tomes written by someone who is not as funny as he thinks he is.

0 0 Reply

manocame

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

April 26,2025

Sooo good, was really thorough without being repetitive. Like the title says, its a summary of criminal justice in America, from colonial times to the 1990s. As the years went by criminal justice got more professional; police departments instead of posses/constables, public prosecution instead of private and jury trials have been (largely) replaced with plea bargaining. Similarly, punishment moves from being physical/public in the colonial era (whippings, public hangings) to imprisonment.

Also kinda interesting to track how reform changed over time. Lots of bizarre/inhumane experiments (totally silent prisons? indefinite prison sentences? forced sterilization?) over the years that thankfully fell off. Sad to know that many of our current issues with criminal justice, like the American public's paranoia over crime and the constant dehumanization of criminals have been constant. However, lots of good reform/change over time. Due process and criminal procedure as we know it was basically created by the Warren Court and we all take for granted now that people have a right to an attorney and such. Overall, great book, good summary of not just criminal justice, but America as a whole.

Quotes

“ Yet the life attracts young lawyers with ideals, hardworking men and women who love trial work, who are committed to the noble goal of defending anybody, good or bad, rich or poor; and who are then trapped by the deep ambivalence of a society that believes in fair trials, but also (and more so?) in punishment.”

“Why did the state of Alabama fight like a bulldog to put these young black men to death? There was a perverse kind of principle at stake. Many white southerners hardly cared whether the defendants were guilty or not. That was a secondary issue. The real issue for them was the southern caste system. They somehow believed it would fall apart like a house of cards if any black accused of assaulting any white (and especially a white woman) escaped extreme punishment.”

“There was less of a double standard for traffic crimes and traffic control—that staple of twentieth-century police work—partly because drivers of cars were, on the whole, the better class of citizen. Even when dealing with drunks, the police were often careful to distinguish between respectable drunks, middle-class men on a binge; and the dirty common drunk.”

0 0 Reply

marvy

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

April 26,2025

Overall, this is a great book on the American legal system and how it has come to be today. The first section details the legal climate during the Colonial Period then delves into the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries. Each section has chapters that cover the moral, political, cultural and legislative atmosphere of the time period. There are a few landmark cases sprinkled in but more focus is given to the surrounding parts of the laws (I.e, how they evolved to be as opposed to detailed summaries).

0 0 Reply

AKFarhan

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

April 26,2025

Read it for my Crime and Punishment class. It is very insightful and detailed, definitely an easy book to get discussion (and even dissent) going off the research. One of the easiest (meaning not having to push myself through) assigned readings I’ve had to do for a course. Definitely recommend.

0 0 Reply

AngelicCharizard

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

April 26,2025

Very interesting book about crime throughout the ages. Information about a lot of cases from the "old days".

0 0 Reply

MomoiAisuki

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

April 26,2025

A well-researched history of the American penal system.

0 0 Reply

kuriikata

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

April 26,2025

As the title implies, this book is broad in scope, both as to subject matter and time periods. It does a good job of covering most, if not all, of the major issues related to American crime and punishment. I do wish there was more information as to the early years of this country, but there simply isn't enough historical documentation to support a more in-depth discussion in a scholarly work.

My only real complaint with the book is that, while the author insists upon adequate, independent sources in the early parts, he seems to relinquish this concern later on and relies instead on his own (seemingly unsupported) conclusions. For instance, he cites the studies of other scholars as to the number of people in prison in the 1800's, but provides no cite for the statement that "People probably, in fact, drank less" in the section about Prohibition. This is both surprising, as there are more statistics and more study of those statistics for events of a more recent nature, and troubling, especially when combined with the author's occasional subjective commentary on 20th century law changes. He's absolutely entitled to his opinions, but those opinions have no place in what purports to be an objective historical account.

It's also worth pointing out that this book was published in 1993 and is therefore out-of-date on many of the important issues of the late 20th century, such as abortion, the death penalty, homosexual rights, etc.

0 0 Reply

flyingpardin

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

April 26,2025

The book provides an excellent overview of the development of the American criminal justice system from the colonial period through the early 1990s. I was intrigued with the way the author chose to structure the book - sort of both thematically and chronologically - and it demonstrates to me that there isn't really enough scholarship on the subject for people to have come up with a clear periodization for the broad narrative. The writing style is also unique - you can hear the author speaking, as if he's giving a (witty and well constructed) lecture. He doesn't provide as many specific examples as one might like.

0 0 Reply

Leave a Review

You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.

Crime and Punishment in American History

lawrence m. friedman

This edition

More editions

About the author

lawrence m. friedman

Readers also enjoyed

Community Reviews