...
Show More
Kind of a mixed bag. The first couple of stories--"Mr. Squishy" and "The Soul Is Not A Smithy"--felt like a bit of a chore, and I don't know that I really understood what Wallace was trying to get at in either of them. The book's title story was also underwhelming.
And yet, a mixed bag for Wallace is of a higher quality than what most writers produce at their best. "Good Old Neon" particularly was a profoundly affecting and evocative piece. I needed to go outside and have a smoke and go to sleep after reading it, to say nothing of the fascinating technical feats Wallace pulls off in the story.
We can see Wallace, in these stories, starting to move past irony and humor into what critics have called the "New Sincerity." There aren't a lot of laughs here, and when there are, the laughs aren't self-depricating, or at somebody's expense. The tone in these stories is honest, stark, and almost melancholic at times. I don't think he ever quite figured out how to jettison irony and get at the captial-T Truth, but he certainly came quite close in this collection, as well as in The Pale King, and either way, his work is a joy to read.
And yet, a mixed bag for Wallace is of a higher quality than what most writers produce at their best. "Good Old Neon" particularly was a profoundly affecting and evocative piece. I needed to go outside and have a smoke and go to sleep after reading it, to say nothing of the fascinating technical feats Wallace pulls off in the story.
We can see Wallace, in these stories, starting to move past irony and humor into what critics have called the "New Sincerity." There aren't a lot of laughs here, and when there are, the laughs aren't self-depricating, or at somebody's expense. The tone in these stories is honest, stark, and almost melancholic at times. I don't think he ever quite figured out how to jettison irony and get at the captial-T Truth, but he certainly came quite close in this collection, as well as in The Pale King, and either way, his work is a joy to read.