...
Show More
I read this book because my daughter's fourth grade class is reading it to go along with their social studies unit on the Revolutionary War. It was a little uneven to me. The beginning and end, which take place in the present day didn't do much for me. I was mildly irritated by the unnecessary anti-girl remarks in a couple places. Yes, boys and girls are often unimpressed with each other at the age of the characters in the story, but I just didn't feel that it contributed to the story. Maybe it's just a little dated. Anyway, once the children time travel back to the Revolutionary War the story really takes off. I immensely enjoyed the descriptions of the soldiers and the adventures the children had in the past. Literature is such a great way to help students really imagine the historical events they are studying. I'm sure kids get tired of hearing their parents tell them that they should be grateful for what they have, but I guarantee after reading this story they will definitely appreciate their shoes and winter coats! I was happy that the book introduced some thought-provoking ideas about war, for example, that not all soldiers are fighting for lofty ideals. Some are fighting for economic reasons, to support their families. Finally, in one dramatic scene the young characters in the book are confronted with the ugly gray areas of war when some prejudiced and disrespectful Patriots kill a kind-hearted Hessian who had helped the children. I'm glad that my daughter will be able to start thinking about the hard truth that real life isn't as clear-cut as a good-guy vs. bad-guy cartoon. Overall, I think this was a great choice for the class.