...
Show More
By and large I found this collection overrated. Which is not to say that I didn't find some of the stories fantastic, the title story for example, as well as the 2nd story in the book. And nothing was really bad here, but seldom did any of these stories strike me as anything as phenomenal as Ms. Lahiri's novel The Namesake.
The collection can be sorted into two main types of stories, those in the East, and those in the West. In both cases, what separates most of these stories from the tale of The Namesake is that they simply reproduce all the stereotypes and tropes of Indian-Bengali culture, whereas the novel actually took the time to explore the realities of such cultural norms. And maybe The Namesake could take that time BECAUSE it was a novel. But for a book to receive as much praise as Interpreter of Maladies, I was hoping for similar insights, merely compressed and distilled into short stories, but no such luck. Instead I found most of the stories repeating the same-old learning to love (or not love) the person with whom your marriage has been arranged (the American stories) and a couple commentaries about the persistence of the caste system (the Bengali stories). The characters do not challenge the culture (which I admit is a very Western expectation), but they didn't even add any nuances to the day-to-day of arranged marriage.
Lahiri is a good writer, as a few of these stories and her novel indicate. But high expectations can only hinder you with this collection. Read The Namesake instead, and watch it succeed despite the dominance of exposition over scene!
The collection can be sorted into two main types of stories, those in the East, and those in the West. In both cases, what separates most of these stories from the tale of The Namesake is that they simply reproduce all the stereotypes and tropes of Indian-Bengali culture, whereas the novel actually took the time to explore the realities of such cultural norms. And maybe The Namesake could take that time BECAUSE it was a novel. But for a book to receive as much praise as Interpreter of Maladies, I was hoping for similar insights, merely compressed and distilled into short stories, but no such luck. Instead I found most of the stories repeating the same-old learning to love (or not love) the person with whom your marriage has been arranged (the American stories) and a couple commentaries about the persistence of the caste system (the Bengali stories). The characters do not challenge the culture (which I admit is a very Western expectation), but they didn't even add any nuances to the day-to-day of arranged marriage.
Lahiri is a good writer, as a few of these stories and her novel indicate. But high expectations can only hinder you with this collection. Read The Namesake instead, and watch it succeed despite the dominance of exposition over scene!