One L: The Turbulent True Story of a First Year at Harvard Law School

... Show More
Newsweek calls him "an extraordinarily canny and empathetic observer." In bestseller after bestseller, Turow uses his background as a lawyer to create suspense fiction so authentic it reads with the hammering impact of fact. But before he became a worldwide sensation, Scott Turow wrote a book that is entirely true, the account of his own searing indoctrination into the field of law called...

The first year of law school is an intellectual and emotional ordeal so grueling that it ensures only the fittest survive. Now Scott Turow takes you inside the oldest and most prestigious law school in the country when he becomes a "One L," as entering students are known at Harvard Law School. In a book that became a national bestseller, a law school primer, and a classic autobiography, he brings to life the fascinating, shocking reality of that first year. Provocative and riveting, One L reveals the experience directly from the combat zone: the humiliations, triumphs, hazings, betrayals, and challenges that will make him a lawyer-and forever change Turow's mind, test his principles, and expose his heart.

Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
30(30%)
4 stars
31(31%)
3 stars
39(39%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews All reviews
April 17,2025
... Show More
Mr. Turow's 'One L' was published in 1977. His memoir covers his first year at Harvard Law School which began in September 1975. The author was 26 years old and three-or-four-years older than most of the other students. For three years prior to entering Harvard, Mr. Turow taught creative writing at Stanford and it shows. 'One L' is a clear, gripping, heartfelt presentation. The guy certainly is smart but also, even more valuable, observant, introspective, speculative, thoughtful, and progressive in his attitudes. For a young man he appears more mature than people typically his age. Despite me not having either the work ethic or intelligence to succeed at Harvard or demanding fields as the law or medicine, for that matter, I found the memoir to be very informative, entertaining, and interesting.

Mr. Turow puts a very human face on the challenging career path. Terror for first-year students seems to be a constant companion. The author covers such topics as professors' reputations and teaching styles, the legal structure, tort suits, study groups, the aspirations on being selected for Harvard Law Review, legal thinking, career potential, burn out, personal sacrifices, the competitive environment, oral arguments, exams, moot court, research skills, racism, sexism, and the Socratic method of teaching. When I was at college, if I had been exposed to the Socratic method, it's a sure bet I'd have soiled my underwear and flipped out by yelling at the professor every nasty profanity-laced pejorative known to man. The book also has some humor and, thankfully, ignores dorm room shenanigans. The pressure to perform well also manifested itself in personality conflicts and altered relationships. Because the memoir was written in 1977 I'd imagine the Internet has changed certain aspects of the law school process in 2017, especially involving research.

I can understand why people thinking of entering law school would find 'One L' informative but Mr. Turow does such a great job of conveying the mood and difficulties of Harvard law school that even laymen like myself found the book engrossing. His conclusion to the work was especially humane and well thought out. I finished the book appreciating the challenges of the demanding field. Getting that degree sure isn't a cake walk.
April 17,2025
... Show More
It is profoundly ironic and just-about-right that most people who will study law and become lawyers read “One L” BEFORE their first year of law school. Before they know anything about what the book references. Before they can relate. Before all the nuances and insights have any real meaning. This book is not at all a guide, and so it is of very limited utility when it is read in advance instead of in reflection. But law students simply cannot help themselves. In anticipating and trying to prepare for the tumultuous first year, most readers are already, subconsciously or not, engaging in a kind of slow-motion oneupmanship. In some sense, the book describes and critiques the natural inclinations displayed by the very people most often reading it.

I (solely by coincidence) did not read “One L” until I had completely finished my 1L year. I started the book one hour after I hit send on the final assignment for NLaw’s Write-On. Immediately, I felt like I was being given the hug I had not known I needed. Turow writes with such honesty and frankness, and only a very small and tasteful dose of rose-tinted-glasses syndrome, that one is sometimes left wondering why he didn’t abandon the law for a career as a psychologist.

I highly recommend that absolutely no one reads One L before starting law school; it would seem overwrought, melodramatic, and serious in ways that are crude and self-important. I also highly recommend that absolutely everyone reads One L after their first year. In doing so, I realized that the neuroses and paranoia, the complex emotional cocktail of competitiveness, pride, envy, forced collaboration, genuine companionship, shame, and self-effacing identity crisis that Turow puts under the microscope are common to first year students at American law schools and have not evolved substantially since the mid 1970s (by Turow’s estimation, since the late 1880s). The sense of connection I feel now, after peering into Turow’s mind and heart, flows from his sheer vulnerability, an aspect of humans that is sometimes hard to come by at law school, but, when found, is always the diamond in the rough that makes the whole experience bearable.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Now, granted, I didn't go to Harvard Law, but I DID attend a fairly high ranked law school and, from my experience, Turow protests FAR too much. It makes for a good story, but oh, the drama! I only wish that William and Mary had been that exciting and filled with academic intrigue!
April 17,2025
... Show More
"They will be the One Ls"

I was given this book to be given more insight in how the legal world works since I am leaning in that direction myself. I now understand that the first year of law school is something hysterical for many students to navigate through.

I think that Turow seemed a bit exaggerated at some places of his novel. However, the book was enjoyable. Through a tale of his first year, Turow manages to capture the headaches that students all around him suffered in a game of deciphering the codes of law.
April 17,2025
... Show More
The one thing that I got form this book is that I'm very glad that I'm not a lawyer or ever contemplated law school. Even though this book is decades old, the systems still sound similar, the environment doesn't seem like one that is conductive to learning. I really hated how by the end it seemed like everyone was happy when someone else failed. Not sure how that could possibly build an environment where you have a good support system when you need one the most.
April 17,2025
... Show More
I'm a fan of Scott Turow's writing and have been aware of this book that he wrote about his first year at Harvard Law School, but didn't give much thought to reading it until someone donated the audio book to our library's used book store. I don't normally listen to audio books because I can't concentrate on a book if I am doing other things, but I listened to this one in my car while I was driving around town so it took me several days to finish. I would have been able to read the actual book much more quickly.

The audio book begins with an introduction by Scott Turow. I'm glad he did not narrate the entire book, because his voice was not particularly pleasant. I am happy that I listened to this book. My brother graduated from Columbia Law School in the late 1960's. This book gave me a better understanding of what he might have gone through during his first year. Turow talks a lot about the competition to make the Harvard Law Review and my brother was on the Law Review at Columbia. As I listened to the book, I was trying to picture which of the characters in Turow's class my brother would have been.

At times the author was a little whiny about how difficult law school is and what the students went through. I would expect Harvard Law School to be extremely demanding and it is. This would be a good read for anyone considering attending law school.

One fun item in the book was that there was a student in Turow's class whose name was Sandy Stern and that is the name of one of the major characters in Turow's books.

Holter Graham did a nice job of narrating the book. Since it was autobiographical about one person's experience, he didn't have to use a lot of different voices or accents.

April 17,2025
... Show More
There are issues I have with this book: it’s a little dated, the progressive portions fall flat to a modern, critical perspective, and the author is, of course, an ivy league law school graduate–meaning he’s not the most likable person (although he willingly acknowledges past mistakes that he accounts to being driven mad his 1L year).

That said, the author and his accounts of words from his peers hit hard continuously throughout the book for an incoming 1L. First is the realistic look into the slough that is the first year of law school—with substance abuse, mental health, interpersonal relationships, poor eating and sleeping habits, temptation, and cruelty, popping up time and time again.

Gina, for any student, especially a female one, is consistently insightful. Two examples come to mind:

“They’re turning me into someone else…They’re making me different…It’s someone I don’t want to be…Don’t you get the feeling all the time that you’re being indoctrinated?”

“I know how this sounds…but a lot of the women say the same thing. When I get called on, I really think about rape. It’s sudden. You’re exposed. You can’t move. You can’t say no. And there’s this man who’s in control, telling you exactly what to do. Maybe that’s melodramatic…but for me, a lot of the stuff in class shows up all kinds of male/female power relations that I’ve sort of been training myself to resent.”

I think these quotes speak to the core of the book, the turmoil of going to law school and maintaining a good, principled heart while within the epitome of an ivory tower.

The book is so honest, that I felt my stomach twist and my heartbeat quicken in empathy for the 1975-1976 Harvard 1Ls and worry for my own future. At the same time, though, I felt excited and resolved to work hard.

The writing is inarguably good, with a gripping voice and excellent word choice. But that's to be expected from an accomplished writer like Scott Turow.

I wouldn’t go as far as to give it the praise that every 0L needs to read this book, but I found it enjoyable and affirming. So if you're anxious and unsure, it's worth the try.
April 17,2025
... Show More
idk it was well written but it didnt say anything that surprised me
like yeah its harvard law school, its gonna be hard and the people are going to be prestigious and competitive. kinda expected that
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.