...
Show More
This book was unbelievably tiresome.
I've read Hornby's fiction in the past with enjoyment, so I was expecting something better out of him here. I expected ties to class and race and politics and how fandom is a thing, sociologically. I expected some kind of real growth or enlightenment on the part of the fan writing. I expected, especially given Hornby's fiction, a moment that works like a plot high point, wherein he realizes that soccer is not and should not trump everything and everyone else in his life.
Instead, I was treated to an anal cataloging of what felt like every fucking soccer game he's ever attended, plus barrels of apologetic pseudo-self-awareness. This is that guy who, because he KNOWS he's an asshole, and he ADMITS that he's an asshole, considers himself excused for being an asshole. Spending time in this man's company is not enjoyable, and I don't know what's wrong with the legions of five-starrers here, but I suspect that they aren't that great either.
I could say more, about his glosses over things like hooliganism, stadium deaths, racist chants, neo-nazi fans, but it's just not worth it. Suffice it to say that he thinks his own fandom more important than all these things, no matter what he says. I'm not sure that this experience won't ruin his other books for me.
I've read Hornby's fiction in the past with enjoyment, so I was expecting something better out of him here. I expected ties to class and race and politics and how fandom is a thing, sociologically. I expected some kind of real growth or enlightenment on the part of the fan writing. I expected, especially given Hornby's fiction, a moment that works like a plot high point, wherein he realizes that soccer is not and should not trump everything and everyone else in his life.
Instead, I was treated to an anal cataloging of what felt like every fucking soccer game he's ever attended, plus barrels of apologetic pseudo-self-awareness. This is that guy who, because he KNOWS he's an asshole, and he ADMITS that he's an asshole, considers himself excused for being an asshole. Spending time in this man's company is not enjoyable, and I don't know what's wrong with the legions of five-starrers here, but I suspect that they aren't that great either.
I could say more, about his glosses over things like hooliganism, stadium deaths, racist chants, neo-nazi fans, but it's just not worth it. Suffice it to say that he thinks his own fandom more important than all these things, no matter what he says. I'm not sure that this experience won't ruin his other books for me.