...
Show More
Well, the first instalment was terrible enough, but this was even worse. What can I say? It was awful. Just awful. In the first book you had the Sloths of Wisdom. Here, you have the Yetis of Doom. Which, according to Ms Allende, are degenerate Neanderthals. And that's just one of the many strange story elements in here. The story is very plain, with a generic and foreseeable plot. Furthermore, the characters are walking clichés, the religious aspects seems bogus at best, even to my limited knowledge of Asian religions; moreover, the settings are positively colonial. The writing is atrocious, particularly the asinine dialogues and the endless repetitions. I don't speak enough Spanish to read novels in it, but I doubt that the subpar quality of this book is due to a bad translation.
Who is target group for it, really? Supposedly, this is young adult literature, but do young adults really enjoy stories like this? I'd assume a 14-year-old would probably feel punked. Maybe it is meant for small children, elementary school age who like plain, one-dimensional adventure stories. What was Ms Allende thinking, dabbling into this genre? In a way, this was very reminiscent of phoney Hollywood comic adventure action movies such as The Mummy (Tom Cruise, anyone?), Indiana Jones, or (my only example with a Himalayan theme) The Golden Child. Good fun if you are into this kind of entertainment. To a more sophisticated readership / viewership, it might come across as silly, botched, and culturally disrespectful.
Who is target group for it, really? Supposedly, this is young adult literature, but do young adults really enjoy stories like this? I'd assume a 14-year-old would probably feel punked. Maybe it is meant for small children, elementary school age who like plain, one-dimensional adventure stories. What was Ms Allende thinking, dabbling into this genre? In a way, this was very reminiscent of phoney Hollywood comic adventure action movies such as The Mummy (Tom Cruise, anyone?), Indiana Jones, or (my only example with a Himalayan theme) The Golden Child. Good fun if you are into this kind of entertainment. To a more sophisticated readership / viewership, it might come across as silly, botched, and culturally disrespectful.