Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 45 votes)
5 stars
19(42%)
4 stars
12(27%)
3 stars
14(31%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
45 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

OK, so this manga -does- grow on you. At first, I was really put off by the erratic and disjointed style. It was so distracting that I simply couldn't get into the story or the characters. There seemed to be no flow, no proper development. Each chapter didn't continue the story from the previous one. Instead, it was built upon several random episodes that occurred. However, as I persevered and continued to read it, I gradually began to understand. Eiji Nonaka, the author, has a unique way of developing his characters. He does it as he goes along, and we get to learn about them through the various adventures and misadventures that befall these hoodlum misfits.


Cromartie High School is a rather unique institution. It attracts the lowest and least intelligent of students. The only admission requirement is that a student can do basic addition and subtraction, and even that doesn't seem to be strictly enforced. As a result, the student population is made up of hoodlums and badass tough guys. They have no interest in studying and are mostly concerned with their next fight. In fact, among the attendees, there are students who may not even be registered. There are even several that are not even human. For example, one of the "students" is a gorilla, an actual primate, who is often depicted as more intelligent than several of the other Cromartie students.


As mentioned earlier, the chapters are presented as mini-episodes. The events that take place do not necessarily have a direct connection to the events shown previously. But as they unfold, a clearer picture of each of the students emerges. And these episodes become quite unreal, leading to improbably funny situations. As I became more interested and involved in each of these characters and their quirks, I found myself constantly shaking my head and laughing out loud at their antics. I'm truly surprised. I really like this manga. I'm definitely going to read Volume 2 soon.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Straight up hilarious.

It's stupid humor, yeah, but it's so over-the-top that it works really well.

The concept of a school filled with nothing but thick-headed tough guys didn't initially strike me as a recipe for hilarity. However, it's precisely that very intensity that makes things truly funny.

The way these tough guys interact and the absurd situations they find themselves in are just comical.

It's a unique and entertaining take on the school setting.

I'll definitely read more if I can get my hands on it.

The story has a certain charm that keeps you engaged and laughing throughout.

It's not the kind of humor that requires a lot of thinking, but rather just pure entertainment.

I'm looking forward to seeing what other crazy antics the characters get up to in future installments.

If you're in the mood for some light-hearted and funny reading, this might just be the thing for you.

Give it a try and see if it makes you laugh out loud like it did for me.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Hilarious!!

It's just about a normal guy who decides to go to a high school that is full of punks. As soon as he steps foot in the school, all kinds of randomness ensues.

The punks are constantly causing chaos, pulling pranks, and making a general mess of things. The normal guy, who is used to a more orderly environment, is completely thrown off balance.

He tries to fit in and make the best of the situation, but it's not easy. Everywhere he turns, there's another crazy incident waiting to happen.

From wild classroom antics to unexpected cafeteria food fights, the normal guy finds himself in the middle of it all.

Despite the chaos, there are also some moments of hilarity and unexpected friendship. The normal guy discovers that beneath the punk exterior, some of these kids have hearts of gold.

Overall, it's a wild and crazy ride as the normal guy navigates his way through a high school full of punks.
July 15,2025
... Show More


Hahaha! This series is truly off-the-wall hilarious! It has the ability to make you laugh out loud uncontrollably. The storylines are so unique and unexpected, filled with absurd characters and situations that will leave you in stitches. Each episode is like a wild ride, taking you on a journey of non-stop laughter and entertainment. The humor is not only clever but also relatable, making it easy for viewers of all ages to enjoy. Whether you're having a bad day or just looking for a good laugh, this series is the perfect choice. So sit back, relax, and get ready to be entertained by the most hilarious series you've ever seen!

July 15,2025
... Show More
It's truly stupid. However, it's also funny, and yet sometimes it gives the impression of being a waste of time. Interestingly, it's self-reflexive in a really remarkable way.

The characters are rather one-dimensional. Nevertheless, the book or series appears to be cognizant of and intrigued by delving into the construction of masculinity and gender dynamics. At certain moments, it is completely absurd, which is quite fitting.

This combination of elements makes it a rather unique and somewhat perplexing piece of work. On one hand, the stupidity and one-dimensional characters might seem off-putting. But on the other hand, the self-reflexivity and the exploration of important themes add a layer of depth and interest.

Overall, it's a work that elicits a range of emotions and thoughts, and while it may not be everyone's cup of tea, it does have its own charm and value.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This work is essentially a compilation of short gags, each approximately 10 - 15 pages long.

It playfully mocks various elements from the 70s, such as high school manga, arena rock with a particular focus on Queen, badasses, the concept of sanity, and any form of action.

The unique and absurd nature of these gags makes it a must-see to truly believe.

It takes the familiar and turns it on its head, creating a humorous and entertaining experience.

Whether you're a fan of the 70s or just looking for something different and comical, this collection of short gags is sure to provide plenty of laughs and surprises.

It's a wild ride through a world of satire and parody that will keep you engaged from start to finish.

So, don't miss out on the opportunity to witness this one-of-a-kind creation that challenges your perception and tickles your funny bone.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This was such an extremely weird manga. It was truly nothing but a load of B.S. and crack situations that lacked any real substance whatsoever.


It's not a manga that one can approach with any degree of seriousness. There might be just one moment where a hint of seriousness can be detected at the very beginning of the volume. But after those measly eight pages, it perhaps pops up on only one other page throughout the entire volume.


The entire reading experience is a series of otherwise normal situations that are made utterly ridiculous by a continuous stream of the same bad, and eventually, old and tired jokes that are recycled over and over again throughout the entirety of the volume.


Considering that the handful of lines in the preview for the next volume seem to promise nothing much different, I can state with certainty that this is a manga series that you should read only if you are absolutely bored out of your mind and in desperate need of something completely void of any real value to fill up your time.


I did manage to laugh a couple of times at a situation or two, but it was such a mindless and fleeting event that there's really nothing of any consequence to take away from this.


I'll probably pick up the other volumes if I happen to come across them. Likely, it'll be one at a time, just to randomly read some blatant nonsense in between books that actually have real stories to offer. But make no mistake, this is a series that I would never, ever consider buying.


If for some strange reason my opinion changes as I lazily flip through these every now and then, I'll be sure to let you know. But for the time being, it's really almost not worth your precious time to even pay the slightest attention to. Unless, of course, you're actively seeking some mindless (and I really mean mindless here, folks) distraction.


Don't waste your hard-earned money on this one. If you're really curious, check it out from the library. And I would strongly suggest not even buying it if you happen to like the first one. It's simply not worth risking your money on if it continues to be the same crackpot mess it's been in this first volume and you quickly grow bored of it.


Recommended then? Definitely not. There are far better things to read out there. This is more like a brief mental break between things that actually require me to pay attention and care.


Either way, happy reading!
July 15,2025
... Show More
The original text "ไร้สาระดี" seems to be in Thai and might not have a direct and clear English translation. However, if we assume it means something like "lacking good content" or "no good substance", we can expand it as follows:

Nowadays, in the vast sea of information, we often come across various things that are described as "ไร้สาระดี" or lacking good content. This could refer to many aspects, such as some articles that are filled with empty words and lack in-depth analysis and valuable insights.

Similarly, some products may claim to have certain features but in reality, they are "ไร้สาระดี" and do not meet the expectations of consumers.

It is essential for us to be able to distinguish between what is truly valuable and what is just "ไร้สาระดี". We should strive to seek out and appreciate the things that have good substance and can bring us real benefits and growth.

Only by doing so can we avoid being misled by the abundance of "ไร้สาระดี" things and make more informed decisions in our lives.

July 15,2025
... Show More

Review for the whole series:

This series is truly one of a kind. It manages to strike a perfect balance between being outrageously stupid and hilariously funny. The storylines are so absurd that you can't help but laugh out loud at the ridiculousness of it all. The characters are equally as entertaining, with their unique personalities and antics. Each episode is filled with countless moments that will have you rolling on the floor with laughter. Whether it's the crazy situations they find themselves in or the witty dialogue, this series never fails to deliver the laughs. It's a refreshing change from the typical serious and drama-filled shows out there. If you're looking for something to brighten your day and make you forget about your troubles, then this series is definitely worth checking out. You won't be disappointed!

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.