A classic work of Ulysses scholarship presents an interesting perspective. The author's personal connection to Joyce is evident, as it is conveyed in an almost essayistic and casual voice. This unique approach gives the work a certain charm and authenticity. However, the author's claims to authority, which are based on his acquaintance with Joyce himself, do raise some questions. It makes the reader wonder about the very idea of authority. Is it really possible to claim absolute authority based on personal acquaintance? This doubt is actually a good thing. It encourages critical thinking and forces the reader to question and analyze the author's arguments. It also shows that even in the field of scholarship, there is room for different interpretations and perspectives.
Helpful, but misses the point I feel in many places.
Re: Joyce was much better. I'd recommend that book over this one to read alongside Ulysses.
Though the chapter by chapter theme was helpful and some of the Homeric parallels were insightful,
it still didn't fully capture the essence of Joyce's work.
The analysis could have been more in-depth and comprehensive.
There were areas where the author seemed to skim over important details.
However, it did provide some useful information and perspectives.
It's a decent attempt, but there's definitely room for improvement.
Overall, while it has its merits, it doesn't quite measure up to the standard set by Joyce's masterpiece.
I would suggest that readers look for other works that offer a more complete and accurate understanding of Ulysses.
Perhaps a more detailed study of Joyce's life and times would also enhance the reading experience.
In conclusion, this book is helpful to a certain extent, but it's not the definitive guide to reading Ulysses.
Anyone who has an interest in the renowned literary work "Ulysses" would be well-advised to pick up and read this particular book. It holds a unique position as it is the sole reader's guide that was penned under the direct supervision of the great author Joyce himself. This ensures that the insights and interpretations provided within its pages are as accurate and in line with Joyce's intentions as possible. With this guide, readers can delve deeper into the complex and rich world of "Ulysses",解开 its many mysteries and layers of meaning. It serves as an invaluable companion, enhancing the reading experience and allowing enthusiasts to gain a more profound understanding of this classic piece of literature. Whether you are a first-time reader or a seasoned scholar, this reader's guide is an essential addition to your literary collection.