Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
40(40%)
4 stars
25(25%)
3 stars
35(35%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

"Ulysses" is a complex and challenging work of literature that requires a great deal of effort and dedication to understand. For anyone intending to tackle this masterpiece, it is essential to have a solid foundation in literature and a willingness to engage with the text on a deep level.


One of the first things that readers should do is to familiarize themselves with the background and context of the work. This includes了解 the historical period in which it was written, the author's life and beliefs, and the literary traditions and conventions that influenced the text.


Another important aspect of approaching "Ulysses" is to read it carefully and attentively. The text is filled with dense language, complex symbolism, and multiple layers of meaning, so it is necessary to take the time to parse each sentence and paragraph and try to understand its significance.


In addition to reading the text itself, it can also be helpful to consult secondary sources such as critical essays, biographies of the author, and studies of the work. These can provide additional insights and perspectives that can enhance the reader's understanding of the text.


Finally, it is important to remember that reading "Ulysses" is a journey, not a destination. It may take multiple readings and a great deal of effort to fully appreciate the depth and complexity of the work, but the rewards are well worth it.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This truly illuminates numerous aspects of Ulysses that would otherwise remain entirely dark for me.

It stands as one of the finest companion books.

Not because it is inherently a delight to read on its own, but rather because it serves as an invaluable tool that aids one in appreciating and relishing one of the most remarkable pieces in the vast realm of literature.

With its in-depth analysis and exploration, it opens up new vistas and perspectives, allowing the reader to gain a deeper understanding and a more profound connection with the masterpiece that is Ulysses.

It enriches the reading experience, transforming what might have been a somewhat daunting or inaccessible text into a source of great pleasure and intellectual stimulation.

Truly, it is a remarkable and indispensable addition to the study and enjoyment of this literary classic.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The first two chapters are truly the most instructive ones.

After these initial chapters, there follows a chapter-by-chapter synopsis, which is then succeeded by a discussion of themes and other aspects.

Interestingly, there is also a chart present. This chart is of great interest as it functions as a sort of key to the allusions and symbolism within the text.

It is quite remarkable that Joyce essentially ghost authored this book, providing a wealth of source material and his applications of various techniques to the author.

However, despite all of this, it still leaves me with a sense of wanting a little more. There is a certain something that seems to be lacking, perhaps a deeper exploration of some of the themes or a more in-depth analysis of the characters.

Nonetheless, the book does offer many valuable insights and is definitely worth a read for those interested in the subject matter.

July 15,2025
... Show More
**Title: The Significance of Masterpieces**

Masterpieces are works of art, literature, music, or any other creative field that stand out for their exceptional quality and enduring value. They are the result of the artist's or author's talent, skill, and creativity, combined with a deep understanding of their medium and the human experience.


Masterpieces have the power to inspire, move, and transform us. They can make us see the world in a new light, challenge our assumptions, and expand our imagination. They can also provide a source of comfort and solace in difficult times, and remind us of the beauty and wonder of life.


Some of the most famous masterpieces in history include the Mona Lisa by Leonardo da Vinci, the plays of William Shakespeare, and the music of Ludwig van Beethoven. These works have been studied, analyzed, and admired for centuries, and continue to have a profound impact on our culture and society.


In conclusion, masterpieces are an essential part of our cultural heritage. They represent the best of human creativity and achievement, and have the power to enrich our lives in countless ways. We should cherish and protect them for future generations to enjoy.
July 15,2025
... Show More

A wonderful breakdown of this epic novel truly enhances the reading experience. It does so by shedding light on the scheme that isn't always crystal clear. This guide, which was also authorized by Joyce, provides valuable insights and interpretations. It helps readers to better understand the complex plot, the characters, and the themes that are interwoven throughout the story. With this breakdown, readers can delve deeper into the novel and discover new layers of meaning. It serves as a useful companion, guiding them through the intricacies of the narrative and making the reading experience even more enjoyable and rewarding.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This was an extremely great help while I was reading Ulysses.

Gilbert wrote it with Joyce's assistance, which indeed makes it far more authentic than the other guides.

Moreover, he has some truly remarkable opening chapters that vividly illustrate the style and character of the novel.

These opening chapters serve as a wonderful introduction, allowing readers to better understand and appreciate the unique qualities of Ulysses.

The authenticity provided by Gilbert's work, with Joyce's input, gives readers a more accurate and in-depth perspective on the novel.

It helps to clarify the complex themes, characters, and literary techniques employed by Joyce.

Overall, Gilbert's guide is an invaluable resource for anyone attempting to navigate the challenging yet rewarding world of Ulysses.
July 15,2025
... Show More

It is indeed arduous to evaluate Gilbert's classic study of James Joyce's novel. On one hand, its significant role in the history of Joyce scholarship cannot be ignored. For many decades, it was widely lauded as the most outstanding work on Joyce's mysterious masterpiece. It enabled two generations of readers to gain a sufficient understanding of its structure and method, thereby deriving pleasure from this magnificent work. However, some of its less favorable tendencies, such as Gilbert's penchant for stringing together numerous very long quotations, are precisely due to its age. Modern critics should bear in mind that it was first published in 1930, when the work it dealt with was inaccessible to most of the book's readers.


These justifications, however, have their limitations. This book belongs to a different era. Although we can still appreciate his exploration of Joyce's schematic structure, we are also compelled to scoff contemptuously along with Nabokov, who criticized Gilbert for his overly conspicuous enthusiasm for these schemas. It seems as if the profound meaning of the book can be best uncovered by decoding its most obscure and tangential Homeric parallels or understanding that the organ symbolized by the Circe episode is the "locomotor apparatus."


My rating of this book fluctuated between two and five stars, depending on my mood. I was inclined to be lenient because of its historical significance, but was ultimately forced to settle on three stars due to the disheartening and inept treatment of the Penelope chapter that concludes the book. Even the most forgiving person regarding the values of another era will be challenged by his idiotic conceptions of the universal feminine as masterfully portrayed by Joyce. For example, Gilbert's pungent observation that "The next phase of her monologue, equally feminine, reveals her cult of personal beauty and fine raiment and leads one to a characteristic homily on the nuisance a husband can be when one goes out shopping."


It suffices to say that Joyce himself never uttered such absurdities. In fact, he showed himself to be constitutionally averse to excessive theorizing in general, preferring to reveal glimpses of the universal through the particular. His understanding of that relationship was far more subtle than Gilbert's excavations would imply.


Nevertheless, I would be ungrateful if I didn't mention that he does make numerous extremely useful observations about various themes and ideas that I haven't seen echoed in other commentaries. One such observation was his convincing argument that the section of the "Oxen of the Sun" chapter that is universally regarded as a satire of Tacitus is not actually the case. He believes that this misconception stems from an early scheme Joyce described in a letter and later abandoned. However, anyone who has read both Tacitus and Joyce, as I have, can only be puzzled by this supposed connection. The passage in question does not sound anything like Tacitus.


All in all, I found it worthwhile to skim through for its valuable insights, although the entire introduction and large portions of the commentary are useless and tiresome to wade through. Still, its crucial role in the history of Joyce scholarship must be recognized and appreciated.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Masterpiece.

It is a term that represents the highest level of artistic achievement.

A masterpiece is a work that has withstood the test of time and has been widely recognized and praised by people.

However, understanding a masterpiece is not an easy task.

It requires a deep understanding of the historical, cultural, and social background in which the work was created.

It also requires a certain level of artistic literacy and审美 ability.

Even then, we may still not be able to fully understand the true meaning and value of a masterpiece.

Perhaps this is the charm of a masterpiece.

It always leaves room for us to explore and discover, and it always inspires us to think and reflect.

Although I may never understand a masterpiece completely, I will always be in awe of its beauty and power.

I will continue to study and appreciate masterpieces, hoping to gain a deeper understanding and appreciation of the art world.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Gilbert obtained his tips directly from Joyce's own mouth when he was contributing to a French translation of Ulysses. It is truly fascinating to speculate about how long the world would have had to wait for that extremely enlightening Odyssey-episode title/Organ/Art/Symbol/Technic schema if Joyce hadn't simply informed him. Some of the opening essays are equally useful (such as "Met-him-pike-hoses." Read it!), and during Gilbert's analysis of the episodes, he would periodically throw out a nugget of interpretation that would untangle the whole thorny Ulysses messes.

However, after having completed the actual Ulysses, I am somewhat perplexed by the way he allocated his attention. He dwelt on things that seemed relatively peripheral, while glossing over others that appeared more central. But then this guy gets to, quite seriously, state things like, “the ideas, interpretations and explanations put forward in these pages are not capricious or speculative, but were endorsed by Joyce himself.” And as for me, I've read Ulysses once and could hardly even tell when Stephen Dedalus was peeing, so who are you going to trust?

Still, if you're reading Ulysses with that big old red "V" on your forehead and only want to splurge on one piece of tutsi-fruitsi, I have to say The New Bloomsday Book: A Guide Through Ulysses might be a better option.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This book is truly an excellent guide to Ulysses, specifically catering to Joyce's passionate student lovers.

Alas, it manages to establish fascinating connections with Greek mythologies and other works. It does so by skillfully comparing the author and, through context, with other renowned authors.

The first part of the book provides a profound reflection on Ulysses itself. Meanwhile, the second part represents eighteen Greek mythology characters and their corresponding author's works.

However, on the other hand, it also left me with a sense of confusion regarding certain aspects of the work. There are still elements that elude my full understanding, perhaps due to the complexity and depth of Joyce's masterpiece.

Nonetheless, this guidebook offers valuable insights and perspectives that enhance one's appreciation and comprehension of Ulysses. It serves as a valuable resource for those eager to explore the rich and intricate world of Joyce's literature.

Overall, despite the lingering questions, it is a worthwhile read for anyone interested in Joyce and his remarkable work.
July 15,2025
... Show More

At the end of the series, a man writes about the monologue of a woman, which was written by a man. Moreover, it is the same man who had previously written the rest of the series. In the quote, there is another gentleman who had never read anything better and believes that this will never change. And they say: "Gaea-tellus" - Greek-Roman, of course, self-confident and strained - the series comes to an end. And because the earth is speaking there, Mother Nature, affirming femininity and setting itself aside, over its inscribed "IRDIG", that's why the series was worth it. It is supposed to have happened historically-systematically. Always emphasizing the day, the hours and their passing, always emphasizing the encounter - does it stay out, does it not happen, does it happen after all? More than getting involved in it and confusing it with truth; mistaking the H for the S. Calling oneself Elias, James Stephen Leopold, already anticipating the apotheosis in and from the "land of poets and prophets". Then, logically (!), setting oneself aside from the series, putting the word of the OTHERS into the mouth. Not recognizing one's own fatalistic optimism, taking on the noble gesture of circularly-distant (as if Greece had not existed) writing for oneself. As if the YES was literal in contrast. Willful unconsciousness about the precedence of optimism before the inscription. In fear of and consciousness about "the fleeting advantage of the word against violence", the hElDeN escape the Cyclops (Polyphemus, citizen, nation) only by being able to force the female YES through the violence inherent in themselves (historically). Just being able to write it down and think about it, that would be okay as it is, would have its justification in the whole, as the opposite, "Gaea-tellus", to the supposed suffering of systematization, which history supposedly imposes as well. Whereas this only tolerates that one abstractly because that one is fleeting in comparison! This too is fear-consciousness. Then, here, now, in the apparent lack of an outcome, that monologue always opens up, DARF (! - how infamous) it open itself. Independent of the apparent difference between all hElDeN and their specific historicity, in the face of which systematization can only be ignorance. This ignorance is the core of that study around the "riddle" and of the rÄtSelS itself. It is the ignorance of prophetic poetry, the violence of words that do not want to know themselves literally and to which another literality must come to the rescue in the end.

July 15,2025
... Show More
At times, the text can seem overblown and fusty. It has a tendency to take flights of fancy that seem to come out of nowhere. It piles metaphor on top of metaphor, all while adhering quite closely to a literalist mapping of every single parallel between Ulysses and the Odyssey.

Nonetheless, I found it to be a rather nice thing to read alongside Ulysses. It spared me the inconvenience of constantly having to Google references.

Gilbert's usage of French, Latin, and German, with the assumption that readers wouldn't require it to be translated into English, did make me feel a bit undereducated. However, it didn't really matter. Overall, it was an enjoyable read.

The way the author weaved together these complex literary elements and allusions was quite impressive. It added an extra layer of depth and richness to the reading experience.

Despite its flaws, I would still recommend this text to anyone interested in exploring the connections between Ulysses and the Odyssey. It offers a unique perspective and can enhance one's understanding of both works.

Perhaps with a bit more effort on my part to brush up on my knowledge of foreign languages, I could have gained even more from reading this. But as it stands, I still found it to be a worthwhile and engaging read.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.