Actual rating: 4.5 stars.
I have finally achieved it: I've read Emily's poetry in its entirety (well, except for the lost ones). This collection is truly outstanding for those of you who desire to read Emily's poetry. Janet Gezari has divided Emily's verse into 5 categories: poems published in 1846, dated poems, undated poems, poems of doubtful authorship, and poems as edited by Charlotte in 1850. This makes the reading experience much more enjoyable as you can observe Emily's writing evolve and witness how she begins to experiment with her verse to a greater extent.
The only reason I deducted half a star (cue shocked faces) is that there were the occasional poems that didn't captivate my interest as much as the others. Sometimes, I find Emily's Gondal poems a little burdensome (despite their great interest and wonderful demonstration of her brilliance). Also, even though this shouldn't impact the rating as it's not technically Emily's work, I didn't relish Charlotte's revisions. It was blatantly obvious to me that they weren't Emily's true and natural creations; they felt completely different.
Despite this, this was a charming collection of poetry. Emily has such an enchanting way with verse. I firmly believe that her greatest strength lies in her nature poems; these are my absolute favorites. They just resonate with me because I often understand and appreciate precisely what she is expressing. If I've gained anything from reading Emily's poetry in its entirety, it's the affirmation that 'The Bluebell is the sweetest flower' is my favorite poem by her. This is such a paradoxical, heartwarming, and tender read for me. I sense what she is saying on a spiritual(?) level.
I'd highly recommend this!!!