Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 77 votes)
5 stars
26(34%)
4 stars
28(36%)
3 stars
23(30%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
77 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is a truly beautiful and romantic poem that emerged during the intense rivalry between James the fifth and the Clan of Douglas in Scotland. It was initially printed in 1810, carrying with it the essence of that era.

In this particular version, there are not only explanatory notes but also a wonderful introduction. The introduction plays a crucial role as it vividly explains the times in which this poem was written. This helps the readers to have a deeper and more comprehensive understanding of the poem, enabling them to fully immerse themselves in its beauty and significance.

I wholeheartedly recommend all of Walter Scott's books. However, this one holds a special place. It is a literary gem that offers a unique window into the past.

So, go ahead and enjoy this wonderful piece of literature. May it bring you joy and be a source of blessing.

Diamond
July 15,2025
... Show More
If you haven't delved into the world of Romantic poetry previously, there's no better place to begin than with Scott's "Lady of the Lake".

The first canto is an absolute tour de force. It has the power to completely captivate you and leave you in awe. If it fails to do so, one might question if you truly have a pulse.

Admittedly, the pace slows down a bit after the initial canto. However, Scott's remarkable command of language is more than sufficient to carry you through even the most verbose and drawn-out discussions regarding Scottish patrilineal historical feuds.

Should you find your interest waning at any point, simply retrace your steps and reread that magnificent first canto. It has the ability to reignite your passion and keep you engaged in the wonderful world of Scott's poetry.
July 15,2025
... Show More

I typically have a great appreciation for poetry. However, this particular type of overly sentimental material simply doesn't appeal to me.


Moreover, in order to truly understand the essence of this epic, one must possess at least a basic understanding of the history of Scotland, which I unfortunately lack.


Adding to the difficulty, the profusion of Scottish dialect words further hindered my comprehension. It seems that without a solid foundation in both the subject matter and the language used, fully grasping the significance and beauty of this work is a challenging task.


Perhaps if I were more familiar with the history and dialect, my perception of this epic might change. But for now, it remains a mystery that eludes my understanding.

July 15,2025
... Show More

Nothing is better than a long poem. A long poem is like a vast ocean, carrying within it a wealth of emotions, ideas, and stories. It has the power to transport the reader to different worlds, to make them feel the joys and sorrows of the characters, and to inspire them to think deeply about life and its meaning.


A long poem allows the poet to explore a theme in great detail, to develop complex characters, and to create a rich and vivid atmosphere. It gives the reader the opportunity to immerse themselves in the poem, to savor every word and phrase, and to discover new meanings and interpretations with each reading.


Whether it is a classic epic like Homer's Iliad or a modern masterpiece like T.S. Eliot's The Waste Land, a long poem has the ability to touch the hearts and minds of readers across generations. It is a form of art that stands the test of time and continues to inspire and delight us with its beauty and power.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly have a strong preference for my poetry to convey a story. It would have been such a delight if I could have immersed myself in reading this in one continuous, extended sitting rather than having to do it over multiple sessions.

Alas, the reality of life is that it often doesn't unfold in the way we wish. There are countless distractions and obligations that come our way, preventing us from fully indulging in the things we love all at once.

Nevertheless, I still find great joy in the process of reading my poetry, even if it has to be spread out over time. Each session allows me to discover new nuances and interpretations, adding to the overall richness of the experience.

Despite the challenges posed by life's demands, I will continue to cherish and appreciate the power of poetry to tell a story and touch the hearts of those who read it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Terrific!

This is such a wonderful word that can express a great deal of excitement and enthusiasm.

When we say something is terrific, we mean it is excellent, outstanding, or really great.

It can describe a person's performance, a movie, a book, a meal, or any other thing that impresses us.

For example, we might say "That movie was terrific! I really enjoyed it." or "The food at that restaurant is always terrific."

Using the word terrific can add a sense of energy and excitement to our language.

It shows that we are truly impressed and that we have a positive attitude towards the thing we are describing.

So, the next time you want to express your admiration or excitement, don't be afraid to use the word terrific!

It's a great way to let others know how you feel.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The only thing I read during my Romantic Literature MA that truly mattered to me. If you're seeking Romantic poetry that challenges Wordsworth and his rather tiresome contemporaries, then this is the man for you. Hail Scotland, the originator of provoking others.

This poem is accompanied by extensive notes, and it is absolutely crucial to read the poem in conjunction with these. All the paratextual materials, such as the introduction and the notes, are as essential to the poem as the Cantos themselves. They展现 a level of detail, both real and fabricated, that truly reveals the truth behind the poem's agenda - what is history? Is it a song? Is it folk law? Is it the enduring landscape that bears the scars of previous generations? Is it all of the above? Or none of the above? Scott employs all his powers as an antiquarian to historicize Scotland's national identity in this poem. To such an extent that, upon its publication, it became the premier Victorian vacation destination. Literary tourism at its largest and most influential.

Like much of Scott's work, it is now consigned to the depths of obscurity. I would never have come across it if I hadn't pursued my postgraduate course. So much of fiction is so easily forgotten, but at one time, this was the most widely printed book in the world. Perhaps that's why you can find so many editions of Scott's poetry in second-hand bookshops. Not everyone has the staying power of Austen or Shakespeare. Scott deserves more attention. He's a remarkable individual.

This poem is an exercise in creative innovation. A vision of the past that defines the future. The great thing is - he succeeded. A great neo-medievalist text. He carried the torch high. Well done, Scotty-boy!
July 15,2025
... Show More
Literature died the day it became unacceptable to call your cast of characters James, James, James Fitz - James, and Brian the Hermit.

This statement may seem rather bold at first glance, but upon closer examination, it holds a certain truth. In the past, authors had the freedom to name their characters in a more creative and perhaps even idiosyncratic way. However, in today's society, there seems to be a growing trend towards political correctness and conformity in all aspects of life, including literature.

Authors are now often pressured to create characters with names that are more diverse and representative of different cultures and backgrounds. While this is a worthy goal in many ways, it can also limit the creativity and imagination of the writer. What if an author has a vision for a story that involves a group of characters with similar names? Should they be forced to change those names simply because it doesn't conform to the current standards of acceptability?

In conclusion, while it is important to promote diversity and inclusivity in literature, we should also be careful not to stifle the creativity and individuality of the author. After all, it is the author's unique vision and voice that ultimately makes a work of literature truly great.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A beautifully written love/adventure type setting with excellent verse!

It is a world where love and adventure intertwine, creating a tapestry of emotions and experiences that are both thrilling and enchanting. The setting is richly detailed, with vivid descriptions of landscapes, characters, and events that draw the reader in and make them feel as if they are a part of the story. The verse is excellent, adding a layer of elegance and beauty to the narrative that elevates it to a whole new level. Whether it is the passionate declarations of love between two characters or the heart-pounding action of an adventure, every word is carefully chosen to create a powerful and moving experience. This is a love/adventure story that will stay with you long after you have turned the final page, leaving you with a sense of wonder and a longing for more.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Read this 3 times and still love it.

This simple statement holds a world of meaning. It implies that there is something truly special about the text or piece in question. Maybe it's the way the words are crafted, the emotions it evokes, or the ideas it presents.

When we read something multiple times and still find joy and value in it, it becomes a part of us. It can inspire us, comfort us, or make us think in new ways.

Perhaps it's a favorite book that we return to again and again, a poem that speaks to our souls, or an article that offers profound insights. Whatever it is, the fact that we love it after reading it 3 times (or more) is a testament to its power and significance.

So, the next time you come across something that you read 3 times and still love, cherish it. Let it be a source of inspiration and a reminder of the beauty and wonder that can be found in the written word.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I absolutely adored every single word!!!

It was as if each word was a precious gem, shining with its own unique光芒.

The way they were strung together created a beautiful tapestry of language that captivated my heart and soul.

I couldn't get enough of it.

Every sentence was a delight to read, filled with such vivid imagery and powerful emotions.

It was like taking a journey through a magical world, where words had the power to bring everything to life.

I found myself completely immersed in the text, unable to tear myself away.

This piece of writing was truly a masterpiece, and I will cherish it always.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly believe that if I possessed a more extensive vocabulary, I would have been able to comprehend a greater portion of this poem. It is exquisitely written and sounds absolutely beautiful when read aloud.

I find myself completely enamored with this piece. It has a certain charm and allure that keeps drawing me back. I know that on this first reading, there were several aspects that eluded my understanding.

However, I am determined to come back to this poem later in life. I have a strong hope that with the passage of time and the growth of my knowledge, I will be able to pick up on those things that were previously just out of my reach.

This poem has left a lasting impression on me, and I look forward to the day when I can fully appreciate its depth and beauty.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.