Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 77 votes)
5 stars
26(34%)
4 stars
28(36%)
3 stars
23(30%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
77 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I read this in bits and pieces over several months.

As a result, I lost the narrative thread a few times. However, it was still a great read.

This is the first work by Scott that I've really delved into. And oh! When he describes the scenery, you can truly envision it in your mind's eye.

The way he portrays the characters is also quite remarkable. Some of the characterizations are simply awesome.

And the reveal of the true identity of James FitzJames at the end is just beautiful. It adds an unexpected and captivating twist to the story, leaving a lasting impression on the reader.

Overall, despite the challenges of reading it in a fragmented manner, this book has been a wonderful literary experience.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I had the opportunity to read the version annotated by William Rolfe.

Oh, what a lush and beautiful poem it was! The words seemed to dance on the page, painting vivid pictures in my mind.

However, as I reached the end, I couldn't help but feel a sense of abruptness. It was as if the story of Ellen and Malcolm Graeme's joy had just begun to unfold, and then suddenly, it was over.

I found myself longing for more, yearning to know what happened next in their lives.

Perhaps this is the mark of a truly great poem, that it leaves the reader wanting more, eager to explore the depths of the characters and their emotions.

Despite the abrupt ending, I still thoroughly enjoyed the poem and the insights provided by William Rolfe's annotations.

It was a wonderful literary experience that will stay with me for a long time.
July 15,2025
... Show More

When I was twelve years old, my sister bought me a 1845 edition of this book. Now that I'm 17, I've finally mustered up the courage to read it. It wasn't the writing or the format that deterred me from reading it. Instead, it was the delicate pages and the worn spine that presented a problem.


The writing on the opening page makes me believe that it once belonged to a Scottish priest who is surely no longer alive. The thought of accidentally destroying that history prevented me from even picking it up.


I'm angry with myself for not reading it sooner. It is a rich and engaging tale of warriors and maidens, filled with thrilling descriptions that will keep you captivated. I became completely immersed in the narrative for hours. If you have a taste for such stories, I highly recommend that you do the same!

July 15,2025
... Show More
Anything Arthurian I fear.

The legends and tales surrounding King Arthur have always held a certain allure, yet there is also an underlying sense of unease that accompanies them.

The idea of a heroic king and his noble knights, engaged in epic battles and quests, is captivating. However, there are often elements of mystery and the supernatural that add a touch of the unknown and perhaps a hint of danger.

The tales may speak of magic, curses, and strange beings, which can make one's imagination run wild and fill them with a sense of trepidation.

Additionally, the Arthurian legends are so deeply ingrained in our cultural consciousness that they have taken on a life of their own.

There are countless interpretations and adaptations, each adding its own layer of complexity and ambiguity.

This can make it difficult to truly understand the essence of the stories and can leave one feeling a bit lost and unsure.

In conclusion, while the Arthurian legends may be fascinating, they also carry with them a certain amount of fear and uncertainty that cannot be ignored.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Was there ever an author as inconsistent as Scott? This question truly begs to be asked. When one delves deep into his novels, reading through each and every one of them, a rather interesting phenomenon emerges. Some of his novels are so captivating that they are simply un-put-downable. The stories draw the reader in and hold their attention firmly until the very end. However, on the other hand, there are those novels that are barely pick-up-againable. They lack the charm and the engaging quality that makes a book truly memorable.


Now, let's turn our attention to his poems. Marmion, for instance, can be described as something of a confusing and tedious ramble. It seems to lack a clear direction and fails to capture the reader's imagination. But then, there is The Lady of the Lake, which is nothing short of brilliant. Technically, it is faultless. The language is beautiful, the rhythm is perfect, and the meter is just right. But it's not just the technical aspects that make this poem great. It's also a rattling good story with wonderful descriptive passages that paint a vivid picture in the reader's mind. This poem is truly a gem and should not be missed by any lover of literature.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I discovered the copy of this remarkable book hidden beneath a floor board in our barn. The copyright date of 1882 immediately caught my attention, and as I leafed through it, I found numerous notes written in an old-style cursive. It seems that a student from long ago had been studying this very book at school.


I am truly enamored with the vivid descriptions within. Each individual sonnet or poem has the power to transport you to entirely new surroundings. When I am fully immersed in reading these, free from other distractions, I find myself deeply experiencing the emotions that are so beautifully described. I often read this to my children at bedtime to help them unwind and relax. Here is a sample from Canto 1, set in the vicinity of Loch Katrine in the Western Highlands of Perthshire.


The Lady of the Lake
Canto 1

XXXV.

The wild rose, eglantine, and broom
Wasted around their rich perfume;
The birch-trees wept in fragrant balm;
The aspens slept beneath the calm;
The silver light, with quivering glance,
Played on the water's still expanse,-
Wild were the heart whose passion's sway
Could rage beneath the sober ray!
He felt its calm, that warrior guest,
While thus he communed with his breast:
'Why is it, at each turn I trace
Some memory of that exiled race?"
Can I not mountain maiden spy,
But she must bear the Douglas eye?
Can I not view a Highland brand,
But it must match the Douglas hand?
Can I not frame a fevered dream,
But still the Douglas is the theme?
I'll dream no more, by manly mind
Not even in sleep is will resigned.
My midnight orisons said o'er,
I'll turn to rest, and dream no more.'
His midnight orisons he told,
A prayer with every bead of gold,
Consigned to heaven his cares and woes,
And sunk in undisturbed repose,
Until the heath-cock shrilly crew,
And morning dawned on Benbenue.


In addition to the captivating descriptions of nature and emotions, I also have a great love for the thrilling battle scenes. The detailed accounts make my heart race and my hands sweat as if I myself were being pursued. It's as if I am right there in the thick of the action, experiencing every moment. This book truly is a treasure trove of literary excellence.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Excellent. I love his work. His work is truly remarkable and has a profound impact on me. Every piece he creates seems to tell a unique story and evoke a wide range of emotions. The details and craftsmanship in his work are outstanding, showing his dedication and passion for his art. Whether it's a painting, a sculpture, or any other form of his creation, I am always amazed by his talent and creativity. His work has the power to transport me to another world, making me forget about the stress and烦恼 of daily life. It is like a window into his imagination, allowing me to see the world from a different perspective. I am truly grateful to have discovered his work and look forward to seeing more of his amazing creations in the future.

July 15,2025
... Show More

An ode to that mystery of lakes, women, and chivalry!!


Lakes have always held a certain allure, their still waters reflecting a world both beautiful and mysterious. They are like silent witnesses to the passage of time, their depths hiding secrets known only to themselves.


Women, too, possess an air of mystery. Their emotions, thoughts, and desires often remain hidden beneath a veneer of grace and charm. Like the depths of a lake, there is much more to them than meets the eye.


And then there is chivalry, that noble code of conduct that has long been associated with knights and gentlemen. Chivalry is about respect, honor, and protection. It is about treating women with kindness and courtesy, and upholding the values of justice and fairness.


Together, lakes, women, and chivalry form a captivating triad. The mystery of the lakes, the enigma of women, and the noble ideals of chivalry all combine to create a world of beauty, romance, and adventure. It is a world that we can only dream of, but one that continues to inspire us with its timeless charm.

July 15,2025
... Show More

I'm usually not one for reading poetry. Poetry has always seemed a bit too abstract and difficult for me to fully grasp. However, when I came across this particular piece, something changed. I really enjoyed the rhyme and imagery here. The words seemed to flow together in a beautiful and almost musical way. The vivid images that were painted in my mind as I read were truly captivating.


At times, I must admit, I didn't understand exactly what was going on. Some of the lines were a bit cryptic and required a second or third reading to try and make sense of. But despite these moments of confusion, I was still able to get the general plot of the poem. And that was enough for me to enjoy reading it overall. It was a unique and engaging experience that made me appreciate the power and beauty of poetry in a whole new way.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This romantic and action-packed narrative poem is truly entertaining and highly readable.

It takes the reader on a captivating journey through a world filled with passion and adventure.

The language used in the poem is simply exquisite, painting vivid pictures of the country and its landscapes.

Every word seems to be carefully chosen to create a sense of beauty and wonder.

The descriptions are so detailed that one can almost imagine themselves standing in the midst of the scenes described.

Whether it's the rolling hills, the flowing rivers, or the charming villages, the poem brings the country to life in a most enchanting way.

I find myself completely immersed in the story, unable to put the poem down until I reach the very end.

It's a literary masterpiece that combines romance and action in a way that is both thrilling and heartwarming.

Overall, I highly recommend this narrative poem to anyone who loves beautiful language and engaging stories.

It's a must-read for poetry enthusiasts and those who appreciate the art of storytelling.
July 15,2025
... Show More
It's less confusing then Shakespeare.

Shakespeare's works are renowned for their complex language, intricate plots, and numerous characters. The Elizabethan English used by Shakespeare can be difficult for modern readers to understand, with its archaic words and unusual sentence structures.

In contrast, other forms of literature or writing may be more straightforward and easier to follow. They might use simpler language, have clearer storylines, and present ideas in a more accessible way.

This doesn't mean that Shakespeare's works are not valuable or worth studying. They offer profound insights into human nature, emotions, and the human condition. However, for those who are looking for a less challenging read or who are new to literature, other options may be more suitable.

It's important to note that everyone has different preferences when it comes to reading. Some people may enjoy the challenge of deciphering Shakespeare's language, while others may prefer a more轻松的 reading experience.

In conclusion, while Shakespeare's works are a significant part of literary history, it's understandable that some may find other forms of writing to be less confusing and more enjoyable.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A wonderful classic I always enjoy re-reading is a source of无尽的 joy and inspiration for me.

Each time I pick up this particular classic, it's like embarking on a new adventure. The story unfolds with such vividness and charm that it draws me in completely.

The characters are so well-developed that they seem to come alive on the pages. Their emotions, struggles, and triumphs resonate deeply within me.

The language used in the classic is both beautiful and profound. It flows smoothly, painting a vivid picture in my mind.

Re-reading this classic allows me to discover new details and nuances that I might have missed before. It also gives me a chance to reflect on the themes and messages it conveys.

In conclusion, this wonderful classic holds a special place in my heart. It is a book that I will continue to re-read again and again, finding something new and wonderful each time.
 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.