Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 58 votes)
5 stars
20(34%)
4 stars
22(38%)
3 stars
16(28%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
58 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
A rogue state is typically regarded as a country like North Korea, with a dictatorial leader who causes trouble for everyone else. However, as is often the case, he turns this definition on its head.

First, he delves into the numerous war crimes committed by the US, ranging from our support of dictators (such as Saddam Hussein) to our suppression of the vast majority of citizens through class warfare. Each chapter seems rather random, lacking a great deal of coherence throughout the book. Nevertheless, they are quite understandable and easy to grasp due to the abundance of examples provided.

He is also a bit repetitive, but I don't mind this. In fact, I think it's rather helpful. It reinforces the key points and makes it easier for the reader to remember and internalize the information. Overall, despite its flaws, the book offers a thought-provoking perspective on the concept of a rogue state and challenges the traditional narrative.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Some truly great stuff is presented here. However, I find myself tending to agree with others. There exists stronger content by Chomsky that pertains to the same material. This can be discovered in other works of his, such as "Failed States" for instance.

It seems that while the current offering has its merits, the depth and comprehensiveness of the related content in other works might be more substantial. Chomsky has explored these themes in greater detail elsewhere, perhaps providing a more in-depth analysis and a broader perspective.

This doesn't mean that the present material is without value. It may offer unique insights or a different approach to the subject matter. Nevertheless, when considering the full body of Chomsky's work on this topic, it becomes clear that there are other resources that could be further explored for a more complete understanding.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The article can be rewritten and expanded as follows:

The so-called discussion on rogue states in this piece is quite a letdown. It doesn't actually engage in a proper exploration as the title might suggest. Instead, it devotes over 300 pages to painting America in a negative light, portraying it as the only rogue state in the world. This one-sided and repetitive approach makes for a rather dull read. It fails to consider the complex geopolitical situations and the actions of other countries. By simply singling out America and presenting a one-dimensional view, the author misses the opportunity to have a more in-depth and meaningful discussion. In conclusion, it can be summarized in two words: "America bad." However, this simplistic conclusion doesn't do justice to the real issues at hand.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Rogue States, which was published in 2000, serves as an excellent introduction to Noam Chomsky and his incisive critique of American foreign and domestic policy.

However, if one has already read other works by Chomsky, this book may seem somewhat repetitious as the examples he cites often tend to be the same.

There is one particular passage that I highlighted, and it showcases both Chomsky's remarkable insight and his unique sense of humor.

"You'll be pleased to know that the Pentagon recently downgraded the threat of Cuban conquest of the United States. It's still there, but it's not as serious as it was. The reason, they explained, is the deterioration of the awesome Cuban military forces after the end of the Cold War, when the Soviet Union stopped supplying them. So we can rest a little bit easier; we don't have to hide under tables the way we were taught to do in first grade. This elicited no ridicule when it was publicly announced, at least here. I'm sure it did elsewhere; you might recall the response of the Mexican ambassador when John F. Kennedy was trying to organize collective security in defense against Cuba back in the early '60s in Mexico: the ambassador said he would regretfully have to decline because if he were to tell Mexicans that Cuba was a threat to their national security, 40 million Mexicans would die laughing."

This passage not only provides a humorous take on the absurdity of some American foreign policy stances but also highlights the need for a more critical examination of such policies.
July 15,2025
... Show More

When Noam Chomsky begins to sleep as usual.


Noam Chomsky is a renowned linguist and political activist. His work has had a profound impact on the fields of linguistics, philosophy, and cognitive science.


As he lies down to sleep, his mind may be filled with thoughts of his latest research, upcoming lectures, or political issues that he is passionate about. Despite his busy schedule and the many demands on his time, Chomsky always makes sure to get enough rest.


Sleep is essential for his well-being and allows him to recharge and stay focused on his work. As he drifts off to sleep, he may be unaware of the many people around the world who are influenced by his ideas and inspired by his activism.


But even in his sleep, Chomsky's influence continues to spread, as his work continues to shape the way we think about language, mind, and society.

July 15,2025
... Show More
First - The translation is not good.

Second - The book is a collection of various articles and words that talk about different international issues in which America was involved (Nicaragua, Cuba, Cuba, Indonesia, the Philippines, Iraq, Libya, Bosnia...) and of course the immediate journalistic analysis is taken out of context and does not provide sufficient clarification of the issue it is facing.

It should be noted that this description seems rather one-sided and perhaps inaccurate. America's actions in the international arena are complex and multifaceted, and cannot be simply generalized or misinterpreted in this way. We should view historical events and international relations from a comprehensive and objective perspective, taking into account various factors and interests.

Moreover, the repeated mention of Cuba in the text may also indicate a certain bias. Cuba has its own unique history, politics, and social background, and its relationship with the United States is also influenced by many factors. We should respect the sovereignty and territorial integrity of each country and promote international cooperation and development through dialogue and negotiation.
July 15,2025
... Show More

With an abundance of vivid examples and scathing, withering commentary, Chomsky presents a case that is both blatant and yet, in a sense, implicit. He argues forcefully that the United States is, in fact, the single biggest rogue state among all nations. Consider, for instance, the numerous military interventions the U.S. has engaged in around the world. From the wars in the Middle East to covert operations in Central and South America, the evidence seems to support Chomsky's claim.


It would indeed be an arduous task to read Chomsky's works and then view the world through the same lens, particularly for an American. This is because Americans are often shielded from the true and unvarnished facts regarding their country's extensive involvement and aggression abroad. For example, the full extent of the U.S.'s role in regime changes and the resulting chaos and human suffering is not always presented in the mainstream media. Chomsky's writings serve as a wake-up call, challenging us to look beyond the surface and question the actions and motives of our own government.

July 15,2025
... Show More
The following is the rewritten and expanded article:

The perfect antidote to the patriotic Lee Greenwood bullshit.

If even a quarter of this crap is true, then America has a black soul.

Lee Greenwood's brand of patriotism seems to be built on a foundation of false ideals and empty platitudes.

It's as if he is trying to paint a rosy picture of a country that doesn't truly exist.

The reality is that America has a complex and often troubled history, filled with racism, inequality, and injustice.

To ignore these facts and simply spout patriotic nonsense is not only dishonest but also harmful.

We need to face the truth about our country and work towards making it a better place for all.

Only then can we claim to have a real and meaningful patriotism.

Until then, Lee Greenwood's bullshit will continue to be just that - empty words with no real substance.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Noam Chomsky is a renowned linguist and political activist. In this book, he reveals to you what you are most likely not going to hear from any other source.

He delves deep into hidden battles that have taken place behind the scenes, shedding light on the power struggles and conflicts that often go unnoticed by the general public.

Moreover, he also discusses the agreements that have been made, some of which may have far-reaching consequences.

Chomsky's unique perspective and in-depth knowledge make this book a must-read for anyone who wants to understand the true nature of the world we live in.

Whether you are interested in politics, linguistics, or simply want to gain a better understanding of the hidden forces that shape our society, this book has something for everyone.

So, if you are looking for a thought-provoking and eye-opening read, look no further than this book by Noam Chomsky.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The original text seems to be in Arabic and the translation "ترجمة سيئة جدا" means "very bad translation". Here is an expanded English article:

In the world of language and communication, translation plays a crucial role. However, sometimes we encounter translations that are less than satisfactory. A very bad translation can lead to misunderstandings and misinterpretations. It can distort the intended meaning of the original text and cause confusion for the readers or listeners.

This may happen due to various reasons such as lack of proficiency in the source and target languages, insufficient knowledge of the subject matter, or simply carelessness. When we come across a bad translation, it is important to be able to identify it and, if possible, seek a better alternative.

Good translations, on the other hand, are accurate,流畅, and convey the essence of the original text effectively. They help to bridge the gap between different languages and cultures and facilitate global communication. Therefore, it is essential that translators strive for excellence and continuously improve their skills to provide high-quality translations.
July 15,2025
... Show More
As always, it is succinct and incisive.

It is a post-Cold War and pre-9/11 book that is littered with ironies from the opening pages. These ironies establish a pattern of the US and the UK circumventing and ignoring international norms.

The book likely delves into the various actions and decisions made by these two powerful nations during that particular time period. It may explore how they justified their actions, the consequences that followed, and the impact on the international community.

Perhaps it also examines the role of international organizations and the efforts made to uphold international norms in the face of such behavior. By highlighting these ironies, the author aims to provide a thought-provoking analysis of the complex relationship between the US, the UK, and the international community during a significant era in history.

Overall, this book seems to offer valuable insights into a time when the world was undergoing significant changes and the actions of powerful nations had far-reaching implications.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Chomsky is a highly influential figure in the field of linguistics.

His work has had a profound impact on our understanding of language and its structure.

One of his notable contributions is the concept of "generative grammar," which suggests that the human mind has an innate ability to generate an infinite number of sentences.

This idea challenges the traditional view that language is simply learned through imitation and conditioning.

Chomsky's theories have also sparked intense debate and discussion among scholars, with some arguing that his ideas are too abstract and difficult to test empirically.

However, despite the criticism, his work continues to be widely studied and has inspired generations of linguists to explore the mysteries of language.

In conclusion, Chomsky's ideas have made a significant impact on the field of linguistics and continue to shape our understanding of this complex and fascinating subject.
 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.