This book has been an eye-opening experience for me. It has taught me in-depth about what the Middle East crisis is truly all about.

It also clearly explains the role that America has played in the Middle East. The book accurately describes the essence of the Iraq war and the reasons behind America's foreign policy, which unfortunately has ignited violence and hatred towards it.

It is truly astonishing to realize that a government could lie to such an extent for the sake of power. Through reading this book, I have gained a better understanding of the complex and often controversial issues in the Middle East, and it has made me think more deeply about the consequences of political decisions.

I believe that more people should read this book to have a more accurate and comprehensive view of the Middle East situation and the role of various countries in it.

A Superb Revelation of Hidden Truths behind Masked Democracy

Both Chomsky and Achcar offer an incredibly insightful exposition of the main dynamics within the Arab World and the Middle East specifically. Their work is a superb revelation of the many truths that are often hidden behind the facade of so-called democracy. The dialogue between them holds a profound significance, as it allows us to gain a deeper understanding of the complex political, social, and economic issues at play in this region.

I highly recommend reading this work whenever you have the inclination to listen to two of the most respected gurus in the world of politics exchanging thoughts in a flowing and spontaneous manner. Their insights are not only thought-provoking but also offer valuable perspectives that can help us to better understand the world we live in. Whether you are a student of politics, a concerned citizen, or simply someone who is interested in learning more about the Middle East, this dialogue is sure to provide you with a wealth of information and food for thought.

Released 17 years ago, a significant portion of the analysis in this book has become outdated as it fails to apply to the present era. Iraq, Israel, Iran, and Afghanistan have all witnessed both heart-wrenching and remarkable changes.

Although the events have diversified, the same fundamental problems endure. And there is one major issue that appears to be eternal - namely, US Foreign Policy.

Chomsky, a prominent figure in international leftism, offers acute, insightful, and well-connected analyses. Achcar, whom I had never encountered before, presents some astonishingly intelligent points, informed by his extensive knowledge of the situation. Together with Shalom, they have crafted a remarkably readable book, adhering to plain and simple language.

However, my one gripe is that much of it remains undefined. They often rapidly descend to a level of depth that only experienced observers can comprehend - with name-drops, situations, and ideologies, etc. While this is understandable in a conversation between two formidable academics, the editor could have created a glossary or provided explanations in his own words.

Nonetheless, this is an excellent book that serves two purposes: 1) as an intermediary introduction and 2) as a deeper exploration of issues such as Iraq, the Israel-Palestine conflict, terrorism, and US foreign policy. It is a great read.

A truly remarkable debate/dialogue book exists between Noam Chomsky and Gilbert Achcar, which is "moderated" (or at least somewhat kept on track) by Steven Shalom, who is no intellectual lightweight himself.

Noam Chomsky and Gilbert Achcar are both highly outstanding thinkers. It is an absolute pleasure to gain an inside perspective on their thought processes. There are indeed some truly spectacular moments within the book. In these moments, both Chomsky and Achcar are collaborating to work out theories, all the while modifying each other's views.

This interaction between two brilliant minds provides readers with a unique opportunity to witness the evolution of ideas and the power of intellectual exchange. It enriches our understanding of various complex topics and challenges us to think more deeply about the world around us. The book serves as a valuable resource for those interested in exploring the前沿思想 and engaging in meaningful intellectual discussions.

If you want to know the history behind much of American foreign policy in the Middle East, and its relationship with Saudi Arabia, its stance on Syria, Iran, Hezbollah and Israel, then you must acquire this book.

The book consists of conversations between the two authors, Noam Chomsky and Gilbert Achcar, over a period of three consecutive days. It is a book that every person interested in the political situation of the region should obtain.

Chomsky and Achcar are both renowned scholars and analysts, and their discussions offer valuable insights into the complex web of political, economic and strategic interests that shape the Middle East.

By reading this book, you will gain a deeper understanding of the forces at play in the region, and be better equipped to form your own opinions about the future of the Middle East.

This is an interesting and at times challenging analysis of contemporary events in the Middle East and US policy, which was published in 2007.

That makes it old enough to be read retrospectively, yet recent enough to give its analysis of the situation in Iraq and Syria a particular poignancy. It is depressing to observe that in the 8 years since then, things have mostly worsened.

Much of the analysis is not very surprising to an attentive watcher of the news with some historical awareness. The form of the book, a transcribed dialogue, perhaps does not lend itself to very deep insights. However, it is a debate between two well-informed, albeit somewhat biased, observers. They sometimes fail, in their analysis of US policy, to apply Hanlon's Razor - "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity." Chomsky also has a tendency to burst out in colorful rants.

But on the whole, it is an engaging dissection of years of rather unsuccessful foreign policy and military intervention. The big lesson seems to be that you cannot have a successful foreign policy if you do not understand the people for whom it is their domestic policy; that local motives and pressures will always assert their power over decisions made (and illusions fostered in) foreign capitals, no matter how powerful the people there think themselves to be.

This analysis provides valuable food for thought and serves as a reminder of the importance of understanding the complex dynamics at play in international relations.

A book that tells a conversation which is really interesting.

It may not be a great book on Middle East politics if someone is looking for a super essay.

However, it does provide a sketch of why things happen as they do and some brave criticisms of the foreign policies of Western imperialist countries.

This book offers a different perspective and can make readers think about the complex issues in the Middle East.

Although it may not be a comprehensive and in-depth analysis, it still has its value in presenting some important ideas and views.

It can serve as a starting point for further exploration and study of the Middle East region and its politics.

Overall, it is a book that is worth reading for those who are interested in understanding the Middle East and its geopolitical situation.

Must Read.

As is everything else by Chomsky, this work offers a profound and enlightening perspective. It delves into the extremely complicated issues of the Middle East and American foreign policy. The analysis presented here is not only relevant to the specific context of the Middle East but also extends more generally to a wide range of issues that we are facing today.

Chomsky's insights provide a valuable framework for understanding the complex web of political, economic, and social forces at play. His work challenges us to think critically about the actions and decisions of our governments and to consider the broader implications for the world.

Whether you are interested in international relations, politics, or simply want to gain a deeper understanding of the world we live in, this article is a must-read. It will expand your knowledge and help you to form a more informed perspective on some of the most pressing issues of our time.

It is truly unfortunate that Noam Chomsky passed away while I was engrossed in reading this particular work. However, the book itself stands as a brilliant and incisive discourse on war and the complex situation in the Middle East.

I was deeply impressed by the way it was presented. It was not just a one-sided narrative but rather a lively discussion among eminent persons. They meticulously took apart and examined every single facet of the situation. From the political intrigues to the social implications, no stone was left unturned.

Moreover, throughout this exploration, they also presented a potential way out for both America and the people in the Middle East. It offered a glimmer of hope in a region that has been marred by conflict and turmoil for far too long. This book is not only a valuable contribution to the understanding of the Middle East but also a thought-provoking piece that challenges us to think about solutions and a more peaceful future.

This statement presents an important perspective on the conflict in the Middle East.

It points out that the commonly believed approach or summary might not be the simplest one. In fact, there are hundreds of interesting data points related to this complex conflict.

These data can provide a more comprehensive and in-depth understanding of the various aspects and factors involved.

By delving into these details, we can gain a better appreciation of the true nature of the conflict and potentially explore more effective solutions or strategies for peace and stability in the region.

It is essential to look beyond the surface and consider the wealth of information available to form a more accurate and informed view.

This way, we can avoid being misled by simplistic or one-sided interpretations and work towards a more just and sustainable resolution of the Middle East conflict.

A book that reveals and clarifies the true face of America. Through the narration of events and their analysis, it leaves you to infer the painful truth.

This book delves deep into the various aspects of American society, politics, and history. It presents a comprehensive view of the nation, unearthing hidden facts and shedding light on the real motives behind certain actions.

By examining historical events and their consequences, the author helps the reader understand the complex web of relationships and power dynamics that shape America. The analysis is not only thought-provoking but also eye-opening, challenging the reader's preconceived notions and beliefs.

Overall, this book is a must-read for anyone who wants to gain a deeper understanding of the true nature of America. It provides a valuable perspective that is often overlooked or ignored in mainstream media and education.

A really good overview of the complexities of the Middle East and the evil influence of Washington.

The Middle East is a region of great significance and complexity. It is a place where multiple cultures, religions, and interests intersect, leading to a web of political, economic, and social issues.

Washington, on the other hand, has long exerted its influence in the Middle East. Its actions and policies have often had far-reaching consequences, some of which have been less than desirable.

The relationship between the United States and the Middle East is a complex one, marked by both cooperation and conflict. While the United States has provided economic and military assistance to some Middle Eastern countries, it has also been involved in military interventions and regime changes that have disrupted the region and caused great harm to its people.

In conclusion, a comprehensive understanding of the Middle East and the role of Washington is essential for anyone interested in international affairs. By examining the historical, political, and economic factors at play, we can better understand the current situation in the region and work towards a more peaceful and stable future.