Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
32(32%)
4 stars
34(34%)
3 stars
34(34%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I'm not much of a short story fan. However, something about these short stories appealed to me this summer.

My three-star rating is an average. Some of these stories were truly great, captivating me from the very beginning and leaving a lasting impression. Others were good, with interesting plots and engaging characters. And then there were some that were just okay, lacking that certain spark to make them truly stand out.

But through reading these short stories, I think I am beginning to discover some of the charms of a well-written short story. The ability to convey a complex emotion or idea in a concise and powerful way is truly remarkable. It's like a snapshot of a moment in time, frozen forever on the page.

I'm looking forward to reading more short stories in the future and seeing what other hidden gems I can uncover.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Powerful, astonishing, intense short stories - amazing writer.


This writer has an extraordinary talent for crafting short stories that leave a lasting impact. The power within their words is palpable, as they draw the reader in and hold their attention from the very first sentence.


The stories are filled with astonishing twists and turns that keep the reader on the edge of their seat. The intensity of the emotions and the vivid descriptions bring the characters and settings to life, making it easy for the reader to immerse themselves in the story.


Each short story is a masterpiece, carefully constructed to deliver a powerful message or evoke a strong emotion. Whether it's a story of love, loss, or redemption, this amazing writer has the ability to touch the reader's heart and make them think.


In conclusion, if you're looking for short stories that are both powerful and astonishing, then look no further than this amazing writer. Their work is sure to leave you breathless and wanting more.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Read the short story, The Petrified Man, for class and it didn't seem so bad. At least, not at first.

As I delved deeper into the story, however, I did reach a point where it felt like it could have been significantly shorter than it actually was. The pacing seemed to drag in certain parts, which made it a bit of a struggle to stay fully engaged.

Additionally, I think part of the issue for me was the narrator. I found myself becoming weary of listening to the same voice and perspective throughout the story. It lacked the variety and dynamism that might have kept my interest more firmly piqued.

Maybe one day I'll try more of Eudora Welty's work, but that day isn't coming anytime soon. I need a break from her writing style for now and time to explore other authors and their unique voices.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This was an extremely painful read.

It was presented to me by a friend as a gift, thus I was resolute in my determination to complete it. Every week, I would peruse one of the short stories. And once I had finished that week's story, I had the sensation of having been liberated.

Among the 40+ stories in this collection, there isn't a single one that I favored. A couple were somewhat tolerable, yet her writing style is simply so arduous. She is extremely vague in the manner in which she depicts scenes and characters... and she skips around from scene to scene without any transition.

Reading her stories felt akin to attempting to watch some individuals playing outside, but having to look through a stained-glass window -- you can obtain impressions of the people, yet it is challenging to make them out clearly and determine precisely what they are doing.

Furthermore, for a book to engage me on a long-term basis, it requires either to have enjoyable characters or a highly interesting storyline. For me personally, the stories were not captivating, and scarcely did she fashion a character that was likable.

It seems that this particular collection of short stories failed to meet my expectations in terms of both engaging content and appealing characters. I'm not sure if it's just a matter of personal taste or if there are indeed areas where the author could improve her writing.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A Curtain of Green might very well be the second finest collection of short stories that I have ever had the pleasure of reading. It trails only Flannery O'Connor's A Good Man is Hard to Find in my estimation. However, when we look beyond the tales within Welty's first book, there isn't an abundance to recommend. The next three collections and the two uncollected stories are, at best, mediocre and frequently lack vitality.

Consequently, I am unable to recommend this book as a whole, especially considering that I started reading it over 16 years ago. That being said, A Curtain of Green is truly outstanding and remains an essential addition to any well-rounded library. It contains stories that are rich in character, atmosphere, and literary merit. Despite the shortcomings of the other works, this collection alone is enough to make Welty's body of work值得 exploring.

Each story in A Curtain of Green offers a unique perspective on life, love, and the human condition. The characters are vividly drawn, and the settings are described with such detail that they come alive in the reader's mind. Whether it's the small-town South or the bustling city, Welty's stories transport us to different worlds and make us feel as if we are a part of them.

In conclusion, while I cannot recommend the entire book without reservation, I wholeheartedly recommend A Curtain of Green. It is a literary gem that should not be missed by anyone who appreciates great short fiction.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Eudora Welty's writing is truly enchanting and magical. At times, it feels as if she is transporting us to an entirely alternate universe.

Surprisingly, most of her stories are set in the same small rural town in the American South. However, within this seemingly ordinary setting, she manages to capture a hidden and secret cadence that lies beneath the everyday rhythms of life.

Among all her wonderful works, my absolute favorite story is "The Bride of the Innisfallen." This particular tale takes us on a captivating journey to Ireland. It weaves a narrative that is both engaging and filled with vivid descriptions, making the reader feel as if they are right there, experiencing the events along with the characters.

Welty's ability to create such a rich and immersive world through her words is truly remarkable and makes her writing a joy to explore.
July 15,2025
... Show More
**"Death of a Traveling Salesman" by Eudora Welty Review**

The story “Death of a Traveling Salesman” by Eudora Welty offers a profound reflection on modern American reality. It does so from the perspective of the loss of true values, specifically highlighting the disintegration of the human personality. The main character finds himself under the intense pressure of bourgeois morality, completely imbued with the psychology of a money-grubbing society. As the story unfolds, it becomes the ultimate confession of a dead man. Through this narrative, Welty delves deep into the human psyche and the impact of a society that places excessive emphasis on material wealth and status. The link provided, http://writing2.richmond.edu/jessid/e..., allows readers to explore the full text of the story and further engage with Welty's thought-provoking themes. Overall, this story serves as a powerful commentary on the state of modern society and the consequences of losing sight of what truly matters.

July 15,2025
... Show More
The style of language and the types of experiences she writes about seem rather foreign to our contemporary era.

Nonetheless, I did have a certain fondness for "The Bride of Innisfallen" and the vivid images she painted of everyone traveling on the train.

Some of the other stories were also quite enjoyable in their own right. However, I found that I could not truly connect with a significant number of them.

Perhaps it is due to the vast differences in the cultural and historical context in which her works were created.

Or maybe it is because our modern sensibilities and ways of life have diverged so greatly from those of the past.

Despite this, there is still something to be gained from reading her stories, if only to gain a glimpse into a different world and a different way of thinking.

It serves as a reminder that literature has the power to transport us to places and times that we may never have otherwise known.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A truly fantastic collection!

Some of these works are extremely grim, painting a rather dark and somber picture.

On the other hand, others are hysterically funny, bringing out laughter and amusement.

Eudora Welty dedicated her entire lifetime to the town of Jackson, Mississippi.

She meticulously and faithfully chronicled the world that she was so familiar with.

Her writing career spanned an impressive five decades.

Throughout these years, she produced a body of work that truly showcases her talent and skill.

She well and truly deserves her esteemed spot as one of the premier American writers of the twentieth century.

Her works have had a profound impact on the literary world and continue to be studied and admired to this day.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I read this for a book club, so I read through it fairly quickly.

However, I had a hard time relating to the writing. I think there are a couple of reasons for this. Firstly, if I had been able to focus on just a handful of stories instead of trying to go through them all, I might have had a better understanding and enjoyment.

Secondly, having the time to research the context for some of the stories would have enhanced my experience.

Despite these challenges, I did like a few of the stories. The last two stories, "Where is the Voice Coming From?" and "The Demonstrators," were my favorites. I also enjoyed "A Still Moment."

The unique perspectives and the way the stories were told in these particular pieces really appealed to me.

Overall, while my initial reading experience had its difficulties, there were still some aspects of the book that I found engaging and worthwhile.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Time has passed Eudora Welty by.

I can clearly see that she is a highly significant writer. There is a distinct literate style at work within her writings.

The importance lies in her representation of People of Color (PoCs) and women during a time when both groups were severely marginalized in the publishing industry.

However, I just did not find myself enjoying the stories.

Welty employs a clear prose style. There are rarely those clever turns of phrase that might catch one's attention. Instead, there is a firm narrative that simply takes in the action and describes the scene in a simple yet effective manner.

Clearly, there are events and references that either shocked or enlivened the audiences of the 1940s and 1950s but do not translate well to the year 2023.

Often, I could sense the setup for a revelation or insight, but rarely did I see the expected payoff.

The closest I came to understanding was by imagining the character dialogue through the accent and mannerisms of my grandmother.

By stretching my point of view to the generation that actually felt these things, I was able to appreciate what was there.

But it just isn't fun to constantly be trying to think about "How Gramma would feel when reading these stories."

In my opinion, these stories are too firmly grounded in the distant past.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Eudora Welty is truly the embodiment of the Southern Female Writer.

Together with Flannery O'Connor, she introduced a remarkable realism to southern literature, a feat that few of their male contemporaries could ever achieve.

Via their writing, readers across the globe were able to catch a vivid glimpse of the diverse range of Southerners - the impoverished, the struggling, the unique, the proud, the diligent, and the genuine Southerner that other writers could only imagine in their minds.

The excessive verbosity of Faulkner was replaced by the harsh and unadorned reality of what it meant to be a "southerner."

In her short story, "The Worn Path," which is a simple account of an elderly Mississippi woman, Welty managed to encapsulate a wealth of powerful imagery and profound symbolism that continues to be a subject of intense debate among students, writers, and philosophers worldwide.

Once, during my youthful days as a university student, I had the great honor of meeting Welty and being presented with a literary prize for my paper on her work, "The Worn Path."

She was and will always remain one of America's most杰出的writers.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.