Many profound themes are delved into, such as lost opportunities in love, the consequences of choosing the wrong life partner, the invasive and destructive impact of man on the surrounding landscape, child abuse/abandonment, bullying, divorce, and school shootings. I did enjoy several parts of this novel, yet it didn't always feel completely true to life for me. I struggled to fully believe in a character like the all-powerful Francine Whiting. In my view, Miles Roby was at least partly complicit in his own "lost chances, going nowhere" dilemmas. However, I understand that there must be conflict to drive a story forward, and some characters will inevitably come across as passive, serving as the watcher rather than the actor who creates or drives the central conflict of the story.
As the story unfolds, we are frequently taken back to idyllic snapshots of time. Miles had a deep love for his mother, and when she was terminally ill with cancer, he made the decision to drop out of school to be by her side. Francine Whiting offers him a job as the manager of a diner in town, which his dying mother had pleaded with him not to do. His mother's wish was for him to break free from the small town life and create a different future for himself.
I had the opportunity to watch the HBO mini-series first, and then I became curious about the novel upon which it was based. The adaptation was relatively faithful to the novel, with only some minor alterations. It was "decent," but the story still didn't come across as entirely real. Ed Harris did a remarkable job, and Paul Newman simply stole the show. His performance was the only truly natural one in the entire movie. Even Joanne Woodward seemed a bit stiff. I understand that New Englanders can be somewhat terse, but the dialogue often felt stilted and unnatural, both in the novel and in the movie.
The characters didn't seem very real to me. I'm not entirely sure why this work won the Pulitzer Prize, but I can't deny that I did enjoy watching this "slice of life" movie and reading the equally "this is how it is in these parts" novel. I rate it a 3.75 out of 5, which I've rounded up to a 4.