Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
26(26%)
4 stars
46(46%)
3 stars
27(27%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
**Original Article**:
Great

**Expanded Article**:
Great is a word that holds a significant amount of power and meaning. It can describe something that is outstanding, remarkable, or of high quality. When we say something is great, we are expressing our admiration and approval.

For example, a great book can transport us to different worlds, make us laugh, cry, and think deeply. A great movie can captivate our attention from start to finish, leaving us with a lasting impression. A great meal can tantalize our taste buds and make us feel satisfied and happy.

Greatness can also refer to a person's character or achievements. A great leader inspires and motivates others, while a great athlete pushes the boundaries of what is possible. A great artist creates works that touch our hearts and souls.

In conclusion, the word great is a powerful and versatile term that can be used to describe many different things. Whether it's a great experience, a great person, or a great achievement, the concept of greatness is something that we all strive for and admire.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Beautiful novels are a captivating form of literature that have the power to transport readers to different worlds and evoke a wide range of emotions.

They come in various genres, from romance to mystery, science fiction to historical fiction. Each genre offers its own unique charm and吸引力.

In a beautiful novel, the characters are often well-developed and relatable, making readers care about their fates. The plot is engaging and full of twists and turns, keeping readers on the edge of their seats.

The language used in beautiful novels is also an important aspect. It can be descriptive and poetic, painting vivid pictures in the reader's mind. Or it can be simple and straightforward, yet still convey deep emotions.

Whether you're looking for a thrilling adventure, a heartwarming romance, or a thought-provoking story, there's a beautiful novel out there for everyone to enjoy. So pick up a good book and let yourself be swept away by the magic of beautiful novels.
July 15,2025
... Show More

3.5

'Let me tell you about the very rich. They are different from you and me.'


Heartbreak, money, loneliness, boredom, deception, violence, frivolity, sexism, and disappointment - these are the themes that pervade the stories. I initially didn't have a great affinity for the first two tales. They seemed to overly focus on a rich individual, be it a man or a woman, causing harm to others. However, as I delved deeper into the other stories, they gradually grew on me.

'The baby party', 'Absolution', 'Rags Martin-Jones and the Pr-nce of W-les', 'Hot and Cold Blood', \\"The Sensible Thing\\", and 'Gretchen's Forty winks' were truly engaging. They provided entertainment and, at times, even had an alarming quality. Nevertheless, despite their merits, they still fell short of reaching the lofty standard set by 'The Great Gatsby'. Fitzgerald's masterpiece remains in a league of its own, with its complex characters, vivid descriptions, and profound exploration of the American Dream and its discontents.

The stories I read, while interesting in their own right, lacked the depth and brilliance that made 'The Great Gatsby' such a classic. They touched on many of the same themes but perhaps didn't explore them with the same level of nuance and sophistication. Still, they offered an enjoyable read and a glimpse into Fitzgerald's talented pen.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Sadness of love is an emotion that doesn't change with the passage of time. It still feels exactly the same way now as it did before. This shows that Fitzgerald truly grasped the essence of both love and sadness. He was able to capture the complex and often bittersweet nature of love, and the profound sadness that can accompany it. His works are a testament to the power of these emotions and how they can endure throughout a person's life. Whether it's the heartbreak of a lost love or the longing for something more, the sadness of love is a universal experience that Fitzgerald was able to express with great depth and authenticity.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I don't usually have a great deal of interest in short story collections. However, this particular one began in a very strong and engaging manner. It managed to capture my attention right from the start and kept me entertained for a significant portion of the time.

Nonetheless, as I reached the final few stories, I started to notice a rather repetitive theme emerging. It seemed that the author was exploring similar ideas and concepts over and over again, which began to make the reading experience a bit less enjoyable.

Despite this drawback, I still appreciate the initial strength and entertainment value that the collection offered. It had the potential to be truly outstanding, but the repetitiveness in the latter part did somewhat detract from its overall impact.

Perhaps with a bit more variation in the themes and a fresh approach in the final stories, this collection could have been a real gem. As it stands, it is an interesting read with some notable strengths, but also some areas that could have been improved upon.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The first two stories are extremely beautiful. They possess a certain charm and allure that is truly captivating.

However, the remaining stories are not as Gatsby-esque. They lack that specific quality and atmosphere that is characteristic of the works of F. Scott Fitzgerald.

Moreover, they are also less emotionally uplifting. They don't have the power to inspire and move the reader in the same profound way as the first two stories.

Taking all these factors into consideration, I would say that on the whole, the collection of stories deserves a rating of 4 stars. It has its strengths in the first two stories, but the others could have been better in terms of emulating the Gatsby-esque style and providing more emotional uplift.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Winter Dream Solos

Winter is a season that brings with it a unique charm and a sense of wonder. It is a time when the world seems to slow down, and nature展现出its most beautiful and peaceful side. For many people, winter is a time for dreams and solo adventures.

One of the most enchanting aspects of winter is the snow. The soft, white flakes that blanket the ground create a magical and otherworldly scene. It is as if the world has been transformed into a winter wonderland, and everything is covered in a layer of pristine beauty. When walking through the snow, the crunching sound beneath your feet adds to the sense of tranquility and peace.

Winter is also a great time for solo activities. Whether it's going for a long walk in the woods, skiing down a mountain, or simply sitting by the fire and reading a book, there are countless ways to enjoy the solitude and quiet of the season. Solitude allows us to reflect on our lives, to think about our goals and dreams, and to reconnect with ourselves on a deeper level.

In conclusion, winter dream solos offer a wonderful opportunity to escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life and to embrace the beauty and peace of the season. So, the next time you find yourself longing for some alone time, bundle up and head out into the winter wonderland. You never know what magical experiences and dreams await you.
July 15,2025
... Show More
F. Scott Fitzgerald's third story collection, which was published shortly after "The Great Gatsby", is "All the Sad Young Men".

This collection is rather hard to come by these days. Three of the nine stories are now included in "Six Tales of the Jazz Age and Other Stories", and most of the rest can be found in Matthew J. Bruccoli's "The Short Stories of F. Scott Fitzgerald" (1989), which is the current standard with 43 stories and should not be confused with the previous standard collection, Malcolm Cowley's "The Stories of F. Scott Fitzgerald" (1951) with 28 selections. These pieces were written both before and after "Gatsby" and explore some of the same themes and thoughts.

The stories in this collection are diverse. "The Rich Boy" is contrary to Fitzgerald's usual theme as it addresses the failures, disappointments, and emptiness that await even the wealthy. It's excellent but lacks the vibrant emotion typically found in his stories. It includes the often-misquoted line: "Let me tell you about the very rich. They are different from you and me." "Winter Dreams" is a sketch that anticipates "The Great Gatsby". It tells of a middle-class but ambitious boy who falls in love with a rich girl. In some alternate reality, this could be the backstory to Fitzgerald's greatest work and is one of the better stories in this collection. "The Baby Party" is the most interesting and simplest story here. It involves two married couples having a battle following a children's play date, which causes a father to examine his feelings of constraint and pride regarding his child and is better than the other married couple stories.

"Absolution" is an interesting piece where a young boy learns that the world is not as he was told it was in the events leading up to making his confession. Fitzgerald said that this story "was to have been the prologue to that novel [Gatsby] but it interfered with the neatness of the plan." Fortunately, it wasn't made part of that story. "Rags Martin-Jones and the Pr-nce of W-les" is a fantasy of creativity and desire among the very rich as a young man attempts to break through the blase ennui of the most desirable woman in the world.

F. Scott once told his daughter that he was too much a moralist at heart and really wanted to preach at people in some acceptable form rather than just entertain them. This attitude is reflected in three stories with unhappy husbands and insufficiently submissive wives from "All the Sad Young Men". "The Adjuster" is a generally unpleasant story with an even more unpleasant moral as a young wife and mother learns the error of her ways after still wanting to enjoy life after marriage. "Hot and Cold Blood" has a more palatable moral but is still a harsh lesson for the shrewish wife as a husband and soon-to-be father is goaded by his wife into selfishness and then learns the error of his ways. "'The Sensible Thing'" is not one of the married couple stories and is another of Fitzgerald's tales about a young man trying to make good to win the much sought-after girl of his dreams. "Gretchen's Forty Winks" is about a young wife and mother who refuses to delay gratification for six weeks even to achieve their fortune, so her husband masterfully takes matters into his own hands.

"All the Sad Young Men" is a mixed bag, as short story collections, even Fitzgerald's, tend to be. The stories about married couples are weaker on the whole than the others, showing Fitzgerald in transition from chronicler of the Jazz Age to suburban parent. However, as usual, he brilliantly conveys levels of emotion, inhabits the feelings, fears, and hopes of his characters. All are beautifully written with insight and a fine eye for the telling detail. It is well worth reading for the better tales, if one can tolerate the pedantic stories. [4★]
July 15,2025
... Show More
The Cambridge Edition of F. Scott Fitzgerald's third collection of short stories, which was originally published in 1926, is truly a remarkable find. It contains eleven additional short stories, all penned within the same time frame as the original collection. This not only enriches the volume but also provides a more comprehensive look at Fitzgerald's creative output during that period.

Moreover, the editor, James L.W. West III, has done an outstanding job. He presents the original, uncensored versions of stories that were toned down by magazines like The Saturday Evening Post for their mainstream readers. This allows us to experience Fitzgerald's work as he originally intended, without the constraints of censorship.

Although these stories were written during a time of emotional, marital, and financial troubles for Fitzgerald, this collection is by far the most accomplished and adult one he had written up to that point. The book features a broad range of subject matter and scenarios, but there is a connective, thematic throughline of middle-aged, married, adult concerns. The clarity of objectivity that comes from lived experience is evident throughout, something that was impossible in his earliest works. This makes the collection a joy to read from beginning to end.

If you decide to read All the Sad Young Men, I highly recommend this edition. It includes valuable historical, explanatory notes, illustrations of historical events that the stories allude to, and detailed listings of the changes made for magazine publication. These additional features enhance the reading experience and provide a deeper understanding of Fitzgerald's work and the context in which it was written.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Interesting stories with similar themes are always captivating. The beautiful imagery used in such stories adds an extra layer of allure. It's like opening a door to a world filled with vivid colors and enchanting scenes. If you have a penchant for works like The Great Gatsby or are just starting to explore the literary world of FSF, this is a must-read. You'll be drawn into a web of emotions and experiences that will leave you spellbound. The stories will take you on a journey through different lives and perspectives, showing you the beauty and complexity of the human condition. So, don't hesitate. Dive into this collection of interesting stories and let the magic unfold before your eyes.

July 15,2025
... Show More

A pesar de ser buenos cuentos, dejan relativamente poco que comentar en el lector, al menos si ya ha leído la ultra popular obra maestra del autor, cosa bastante probable. Es curiosa esa estética de jazz age que se ha agudizado con el tiempo y que hacen de un estilo que alguna vez fue contemporáneo y seguramente ordinario en el principal atractivo. Pero es un arma de doble filo. Por un lado, tiene una cualidad imaginativa muy poderosa que te transporta a esa ambientación. Te hace sentir como si estuvieras en medio de la vida glamourosa y desordenada de la época. Sin embargo, también relata una parte inofensiva de esa vida; la de los ricos y los nuevos ricos. No muestra la realidad más oscura y compleja que había detrás de todo eso. De ahí que crea que no se terminan de aprovechar todo lo posible las habilidades de Fitzgerald. Constantemente repite sus temas y fijaciones artísticas. Y no es que esté mal. Esta clase de melancolía sosegada y desesperación silenciosa ha reverberado en un montón de escritores después de él. Pero nadie supo hacer suyo ese mood tan particular como lo hizo él. Y en comparación, "El Gran Gatsby" es un libro más rico y gratificante. En fin.

July 15,2025
... Show More

I can't even begin to describe the depth of my adoration for this collection of short stories. They were truly amazing, and that's the only way I can put it. Laced with his later themes and characters, these stories offer a delightful little foray into the world of Fitzgerald without the commitment of reading an entire book.

For anyone who has an interest in delving into Fitzgerald's works, I would highly recommend starting with these short stories. They are simply wonderful and serve as an excellent introduction to his full-length novels. By reading these stories first, readers can get a taste of Fitzgerald's unique writing style, his ability to create complex and engaging characters, and his exploration of themes such as love, loss, and the American Dream.

Overall, this collection of short stories is a must-read for any fan of Fitzgerald or anyone who enjoys beautifully written and thought-provoking literature.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.