‘Moderato Cantabile’ presents a seemingly innocuous tale of two strangers, Anne Desbaresdes and Chauvin. Their encounter occurs daily for a week at a seedy café, following a tragic murder of a young woman by her lover outside that very café. The language is sparse, yet it combines with the repetition of various symbols like the sunset, a magnolia flower, and tugboats, enhancing the ambiguity that underlies the characters' motivations and actions. Consider the descriptions of the sky-scapes and sunsets throughout the week the novel is set. For instance, when Anne's recalcitrant son is sullenly having his music lesson, the sunset is described as "The colour of the sunset suddenly became so magnificent it changed the gold of the child’s hair…the pink sky exploded in a final burst of colour." But this beautiful image is soon disrupted by the onset of dusk as the murder takes place.
Anne is intrigued by the murder and visits the café, where she meets the sullen and sinister, yet oddly seductive, Chauvin. He regales her with fictional accounts of why the man murdered his lover. Anne is drawn in by his stories, and the sexual attraction and potential relationship between them are symbolized by the repeated scenes of the sunset and sunlight. At the culmination of their relationship, as they share a cold kiss, the descriptions of the sunset add to the atmosphere. However, the passion reaches its peak the night before when Anne hosts a dinner party and Chauvin stalks outside, attracted by the scent of the magnolia on her breast. The scene is filled with sexual ambiguity, leaving the reader wondering if he actually visited her that night or if his descriptions of watching her are fictional.
‘Moderato Cantabile’ is a novel of ambiguities, with half-spoken emotions. The reader is constantly left in doubt about what truly happened and how much of the action occurs in the imagination of the two lead characters. It is a novel where only two characters truly exist, and all others serve as symbols of their emotions. The endless repetition of certain scenes and motifs only adds to the uncertainty that pervades the story. While superficial comparisons can be made to nouveau roman writers like Robbe-Grillet, these would undermine the startling originality of Dumas's style.