However, for this reader, there were some drawbacks. I wanted to love this novel, but it didn't quite have the same impact as "Huckleberry Finn," "Sister Carrie," or Faulkner's works. The writing is pyrotechnic, especially in the famous opening paragraph, but at times, the profundities seemed unconnected or even incoherent. The book is long, and some of the characters didn't leave a lasting impression.
Despite these criticisms, "The Adventures of Augie March" has its strengths. Its overarching philosophy and passion for the exceptionalism of America are profound and should be at the core of any "Great American Novel." Augie's belief in the greatness of America is both inspiring and thought-provoking. The novel also captures the black-and-white Chicago of the gangsters and truly American acts like "Abbott and Costello" or "Our Gang." It's a genuine achievement by the author.
In conclusion, while "The Adventures of Augie March" is not without its flaws, it's still a significant work that any reader interested in Bellow should read. It's the novel that made him an "important artist," and it has many memorable moments. However, for this reader, other works like "Henderson the Rain King," "Seize the Day," and "Mr. Sammler's Planet" are more enjoyable and have a stronger impact.