Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
32(32%)
4 stars
34(34%)
3 stars
34(34%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
This woman is a truly remarkable writer when it comes to the construction of individual sentences. Her command of language and the art of crafting beautiful and engaging sentences is truly impressive.

However, here's the thing. Even the most outstanding sentences in the world are not enough to salvage a book when its main characters are as flat and uninteresting as cardboard cutouts from a 1940s melodrama.

The lack of depth and authenticity in the characters makes it difficult for the reader to become fully invested in the story. No matter how beautifully the sentences are written, if the characters fail to come alive on the page, the overall impact of the book is severely diminished.

It's a shame because this writer clearly has a great deal of talent when it comes to the sentence level. But without well-developed and believable characters, her work ultimately falls short of its full potential.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The Great Fire is a novel that left me rather disappointed.

It contains so many elliptic sentences and overly complicated descriptions that for significant portions of the book, I simply couldn't maintain my focus. My mind constantly drifted away, making it difficult to fully engage with the story.

Moreover, the plot itself was quite shallow. It was essentially a love story between a grown man and a teenager, with sporadic references to the war but without delving into anything profound or meaningful about it.

The pretty cover and title of the book were definitely misleading. They gave the impression of a deep and engaging read, but unfortunately, that was not the case. Overall, The Great Fire failed to live up to my expectations.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is yet another outstanding book that delves into the devastation of war. Hazard is a talented and perceptive writer, and the story he tells about a rather ordinary young Englishman sent to Japan for reconstruction and a proper English girl whose family is stationed there is truly excellent.

For those of you who have been looking at my books recently, you've likely noticed that there are numerous WWII and refugee themes running through them. I make no apologies for this. I firmly believe that this was a truly profound aspect of our history, and lately, I find myself completely engrossed in that time and those places. If you, dear Reader, are also interested in this subject, take a look at my titles. Many of them are really great books, both in terms of historical accuracy and character development. Some are based on facts, while others are works of fiction, but all, in my opinion, are powerful reads. 'The Great Fire' is definitely one of them.

It offers a unique perspective on the war and its aftermath, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the experiences and emotions of the characters. Hazard's writing style is engaging and descriptive, making it easy to visualize the settings and events. Whether you're a history buff or simply looking for a good story, 'The Great Fire' is well worth reading.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Set in 1947, yet published in 2003, this multi-layered and multi-national story offers a wealth of food for thought.

It transports the reader from Hiroshima to China, then to London, New Zealand, and Germany. Two thirty-year-old World War II veterans, one English and one Australian, are traversing the globe, attempting to come to terms with the horrors of war ("The Great Fire") in which they participated.

The Englishman Aldred studies China (amidst civil war), Japan (where he is a reluctant "victor"), and Germany. The protagonist's unlikely love affair with teenage Helen and her brother serves as the driving force that sustains this novel and kept me engaged until the end.

However, it is not my favorite work by Shirley Hazzard.

Despite its interesting premise and diverse settings, there were aspects of the story that didn't quite resonate with me as strongly as some of her other novels.

Nonetheless, it is still a worthy read that explores themes of war, love, and the search for meaning in a post-war world.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This novel seems to take place all over the globe in the period following World War II. At first, when one comes across the word “fire,” one might think the book is about a single fire. However, this is a false signal. Near the end of Part One, in a flashback to 1942, a plane crash is witnessed:

“There was an explosion after the crash, then a great fire that, despite the rains, smouldered on overnight. The villagers struggled up in the wet, but explosions kept them off” (52).

This is just foreshadowing. The main character, Aldred Leith, recalls visiting a monument to WWI in London as a youth. It is a monument with over 300 steps:

“The monument to the Great Fire” (91).

Leith, in his thirties, falls in love with a seventeen-year-old girl and eventually marries her. But even this relationship of love cannot save him from the author’s great fire, the war through which he has just lived:

“Even to her, he would not say outright that he was thinking of death: of the many who had died in their youth, under his eyes; of those he had killed, of whom he’d known nothing. On the red battlefield, where I’ll never go again; in the inextinguishable conflagration” (278).

Any war is made up of fire, from fireballs to friendly fire. But Hazzard transforms War from an abstraction into one single, eternal event, a conflagration, as she puts it.

It is through these powerful images and the complex emotions of the characters that the true horror and impact of war are brought to life in this novel.

July 15,2025
... Show More
The immediacy of this story is truly captivating.

The level of writing is such that it goes beyond what is essentially a simple love story. Set during World War II and taking place in various locations like Japan, China, England, and New Zealand, it offers a rich tapestry of settings.

Hazzard's descriptions are remarkable. They are detailed and vivid, painting a clear picture in the reader's mind. The tone is somewhat similar to that of Nevil Shute, restrained yet with exhilarating bursts of sparkly recklessness.

This combination makes reading this story an absolute joy. It keeps the reader engaged from start to finish, eager to discover what will happen next in this complex and beautiful love story.

The way the story weaves through different cultures and historical events adds depth and authenticity, making it a truly unforgettable read.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I couldn't get through it.

I have a desire to read all Booker prize winners, but this particular one has defeated me. The language within it was overly dense and too mannered. It was gorgeous at times, even thrilling, but who really talks with an abundance of adverbs? Who, when breaking up with someone, would say "Go to Italy.... Italy will soften the blow." And who would say, (She) "was eighteen, and virgin. She had been handled; but, as yet with care." Or later, that she "was intimidated by horrors, and by the charmlessness of existence."

I just perused some of the other reviews and a couple of things really resonated with me. The writing, which reportedly took her years and years to complete, and for that I am both grateful and empathetic, is so mannered and often oblique that it gives the impression a) that it could not have actually taken place and b) it is extremely difficult to follow. One finds oneself letting one's attention wander, aware that this may potentially give off an air of hazard, perhaps even churlishness, lurking around (omg, I'm writing like her!).

I'm a weakling; I simply can't get through it right now.

Maybe I'll attempt to finish it later, when I'm more mature, or during a period when I have better focus on my part.

July 15,2025
... Show More
All war love stories seem to involve exiles, and this one was no exception.

There was an English soldier, Aldred Leith, who seemingly wandered through China and Japan in search of an Australian girl named Helen. She was described as a "changeling," hiding within books and with her dying brother.

Despite the common theme, this exiled love was surprisingly original and rather charming. Especially in the midst of all the suffering and loss associated with WWII, which Hazzard did not try to sugarcoat. I'm not sure exactly what made their story original. Maybe it was Helen's age, or perhaps it was the combination of all the characters. Or maybe it was Hazzard's elegant narration.

My only complaint was the last page, which seemed clichéd and anticlimactic. But even though I was aware of this as I read it, I had probably hoped for that very ending all along. And I'm uncertain what kind of ending would have been better.

Hazzard has a lovely writing style. It is subtle, deceptively simple yet complicated, and always elegant. I enjoyed her descriptions of locations, such as a busy Hong Kong market scene, a temple presiding silently over marshland, or the coast of North York at daybreak. I reread many lines that seemed to glow from the page like potent little gems. I love words, and I especially love books and authors that remind me of that.
July 15,2025
... Show More
There could be numerous dissertations composed about the manifold "great fire" meanings.

The most evident one is the bombing of Hiroshima, which is where the book commences. Aldred Leitch, a hero of WWII, takes the time to roam around China, documenting the lives of the people before their worlds are turned upside down.

He then travels to occupied Japan due to something related to his military job and ultimately arrives in Kure, a village outside Hiroshima. There, he encounters two young individuals who are living with their extremely peculiarly uninterested and disconnected parents.

Hazzard's characters are extraordinarily real, and she situates them within historical circumstances that offer you an inkling of what it might have truly been like. I highly recommend this book. Although it is rather dense and slow-paced, there are some profoundly moving elements.

She captures the essence of people extremely well. These are not mere characters; they seem genuine, and you come to care about them.

One aspect that left a profound impression on me is that I now feel as if I have a slightly better understanding of the world into which I was born. I was born in 1948, and the world was like this at that time. It appears very real.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This narrative is steeped in the post-apocalyptic atmosphere of the aftermath of World War II.

It is a story that lies at the intersection of a love novel and a historical fresco, presented through a beautiful writing style that could almost be described as classic.

The post-war world is vividly depicted, with its desolation and the glimmers of hope that emerge.

The characters are brought to life in a way that makes the reader truly care about their fates.

The love story that unfolds is both tender and passionate, set against the backdrop of a world in turmoil.

As the story progresses, we are taken on a journey through the challenges and triumphs of the characters, experiencing their joys and sorrows along the way.

This is a story that will stay with you long after you have finished reading, a testament to the power of great literature.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The original article is not provided, so I can't rewrite and expand it specifically. However, I can give you a general example of how to expand an article to 300 words while maintaining an "exquisite" style.

Let's assume the original article is: "The flower is beautiful. It has bright colors and a sweet fragrance."

Expanded version:

The flower is truly exquisite.

It展现出 a captivating beauty that is simply enchanting.

The colors it flaunts are vivid and bright, like a绚丽的画卷 unfolding before our eyes.

Each petal seems to be painted with the most delicate brushstrokes, creating a harmonious and visually stunning composition.

Not only is its appearance a feast for the eyes, but it also emits a sweet fragrance that fills the air.

The gentle aroma lingers, attracting bees and butterflies, and adding a touch of charm to the surrounding environment.

This flower is not just a simple plant; it is a work of art, a symbol of nature's beauty and grace.

It has the power to uplift our spirits and bring a sense of peace and tranquility to our hearts.

We can't help but be amazed and inspired by its exquisite allure.

July 15,2025
... Show More

There are several fires in the book, mainly revolving around love and war. Men who are fond of reading and women who believe in love, while men who don't read put their faith in war. In Shirley Hazzard's world, it's not difficult to identify the good men as they usually have a book in their hand. To a certain extent, I can agree with this. Even if one doesn't find love, at least they can engage in an interesting conversation filled with literary allusions.


The book is set in the post-World War II era. Several characters are grappling with different aspects of it. Some are researching the state of countries after the war, others are administering defeated and occupied countries, prosecuting war criminals, or working for the war graves commission. Still others are simply striving to survive through it. Most of the characters are Australian, with a few Americans and British thrown in. The setting is predominantly the Far East, including occupied Japan and Hong Kong, with mentions of China. However, there are almost no Asian characters or interactions with the people of these countries. The more enlightened characters show an interest in the places, but only one, Peter, shows any inclination towards the people, and he pays a hefty price for it without being able to offer much help.


Aldred, the main character, seems detached from his surroundings and friends both in the East and during his brief return to England, although he does have a few moments of nostalgia. Helen, the girl he falls in love with, is more attached to people, mainly her brother and Aldred, but also others. She tends to express herself and her affections through words rather than actions. I wish the author had made her older. She seems too young for a lifetime of sitting by a fireside with Aldred, reading quotes to each other, which is how I envision their marriage would be if it were to happen.


Although it tells a love story, this book is a work of literary creation rather than a passionate romance. While the characters withdraw into their books, secluded lives, and nostalgia, leaving the new world to the boorish, the bullies, and the warmongers eager to initiate the Cold War, the book fails to engage this reader.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.