Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
25(25%)
4 stars
35(35%)
3 stars
40(40%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More
I'm really having a hard time expressing exactly how I feel about this play. So, instead, I'll just jot down some quotes that really stand out to me.

"Where is God in all of this?" This question really makes you stop and think. It forces us to consider the role of God in the midst of all the chaos and suffering in the world.

"Between those who kill in His name and those who die for Him, who, in your judgment, is closer to Him?" This quote is equally thought-provoking. It challenges us to question our own understanding of what it means to be close to God and how we judge the actions of others.

"So great is humanity’s capacity for evil that the God of justice is indeed silenced by humanity’s evil deeds - but the God of sun and moon and stars, of time and space and fifteen billion years that brought humanity into being, the God of life itself, of horses and lions and mountain goats that caught Job’s attention - that God is not silenced. The God of the cosmos is not silenced." This final quote is perhaps the most powerful of all. It reminds us that even in the face of great evil, there is still a God who is greater. A God who is not silenced by our actions, but who continues to be present and active in the world.
July 14,2025
... Show More


"We are permitted to question God, to challenge God, to demand an accounting from God. And this, rather than diminishing God is truly to take God seriously."

This was the religious teaching I was given since I was a child, and I firmly believe it still to this day. It has always been in my mind that we should have the courage to question and challenge the divine.


"When the whole world is out enemy, when God Himself is on the side of the enemy, how can one not be afraid? Admit it: you do fear Him. You neither love not worship him. All He evokes in you is fear."

This is something I wish I could ask to many of the religious people I know, especially the hellfire and brimstone preachers. I wonder if they truly understand the nature of fear and its relationship with faith.


This book hurts the heart in a way it needs to hurt. It is horrific to think of the pogroms, and it is so painful to think that the one person who defended God was . It made sense that . They do evil and then blame women for it.


The book is a very quick read, but it leaves a deep impression on the reader. It makes us think about the nature of good and evil, faith and doubt, and the role of God in our lives. It challenges us to look at ourselves and our beliefs, and to question whether we are truly living up to the ideals we profess.
July 14,2025
... Show More

I vividly remember writing a paper on this remarkable book during my freshman year of college. It was an experience that would have a profound impact on my academic journey. As I delved into the pages of the book, I found myself being deeply challenged. The ideas and concepts presented within its covers forced me to question my own beliefs and assumptions. It made me realize that there was so much more to the world of religion than I had initially thought. This book opened my eyes to the complexity and diversity of religious thought and practice. It was through this encounter that I decided to major in religion. I wanted to explore these ideas further and gain a deeper understanding of the role that religion plays in our lives and in society as a whole.

July 14,2025
... Show More
I'm not sure if I can rate this book because I'm not sure that I fully understand it.

The text seems to be deliberately complex and ambiguous, leaving the reader with more questions than answers.

But then again, I'm not sure if the intent of this text is to present an explicit message that can be understood in the first place.

It felt very much as if Wiesel was as conflicted as the reader ends up being.

Maybe the book is not meant to be easily digestible or neatly categorized.

Perhaps it is a reflection of the complexity and chaos of the human experience, and Wiesel is challenging us to grapple with those difficult emotions and ideas.

In any case, I find myself unable to simply rate this book as good or bad.

It has left a lasting impression on me, and I will continue to think about it long after I have finished reading.

Maybe that is the true measure of a great work of literature.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Questions are like trips. They take us on a journey of discovery, allowing us to explore new ideas and gain a deeper understanding of the world around us. However, just like a trip, we must know when to stop.

Sometimes, we can get so caught up in asking questions that we forget to enjoy the present moment. We may become obsessed with finding the perfect answer or solving a particular problem, and in doing so, we miss out on the beauty and wonder of the journey itself.

Knowing when to stop asking questions is an important skill. It requires us to be self-aware and to recognize when we have reached a point of diminishing returns. It also means being able to trust our instincts and to know when we have learned enough.

So, the next time you find yourself on a quest for knowledge, remember that questions are like trips. Enjoy the journey, but also know when to stop and take in the view.
July 14,2025
... Show More
This is a really hard book to read.

I found myself struggling to understand many of the concepts and ideas presented within its pages.

I am certain that by reading it on my own, I missed out on a great deal.

Perhaps if I had had some guidance or someone to discuss it with, I would have been able to gain a deeper understanding.

Nevertheless, I did manage to pick up some valuable insights and knowledge.

The book was filled with complex theories and detailed examples that required careful consideration.

Despite the challenges, I am glad that I took the time to read it.

It has made me realize the importance of perseverance and the value of pushing myself outside of my comfort zone.

In the future, I will be more open to reading difficult books and seeking out additional resources to enhance my learning.

July 14,2025
... Show More

Excellently written, this work has received diverse opinions. Some critics might argue that the ending is less than satisfactory, contending that it fails to neatly wrap up the story's own ideas. However, I hold a different perspective. I believe there is no definitive way to achieve a perfect conclusion, and Wiesel's intention was rather to simply tell the story.


I am truly impressed by the clever ways Wiesel presents his points. Whether it is through the use of witty humor and engaging banter or by evoking the atmosphere of Purim and its profound meaning, he manages to convey numerous thoughts in a concise manner that I would have deemed impossible. Every single line in the text carries significant weight and vitality.


The experiences of the two women, Hanna and Maria, are meticulously recounted, yet told in their entirety. This aspect was one of my favorite topics within the play. Generally speaking, the characters' backstories were each revealed at the opportune moment, rather than all at once. This approach added depth and complexity to the narrative, keeping the readers engaged and eager to uncover more.

July 14,2025
... Show More
If man is made in God's image (or vice versa), then the act of putting God on trial is essentially an indictment of Man. Wiesel's potent drama serves as a profound invitation for us to reflect upon mankind's inherent inability to live up to the standards set by God, or even to create gods that are truly deserving of our worship and respect.

What is most condemnatory of all is the fact that during the trial, no one is discovered to step forward and advocate for God, except for Satan himself. This absence of a defender for the divine further emphasizes the gravity of the situation and forces us to confront the harsh reality of our own moral and spiritual shortcomings.

Overall, Wiesel's work is both powerful and provocative, challenging us to question our beliefs, our actions, and our relationship with the divine. It serves as a reminder that we must constantly strive to live up to the ideals of goodness and justice, and that we should not be complacent in our search for meaning and purpose in life.
July 14,2025
... Show More
After finishing Jonathan Ames' book \\n  Wake Up Sir\\n, I had a strong desire to read something that was completely distinct from the currently fashionable novel style. So, I was carefully scanning my bookshelf when I suddenly came across this play by Elie Wiesel.

It immediately reminded me of a friend who had once told me that he really liked this play and that it had given him several things to think about. Intrigued, I picked it up and, to my surprise, finished it in just one shift at my coffeeshop. As I set it down, having completed it, a different friend of mine, who had been sitting at the same table with me for the past few hours, noticed it for the first time.

"God, you are fucking morbid, you know that?" he exclaimed.
"What?" I asked, completely baffled. As far as I knew, I hadn't done anything remotely morbid in ages.
"Wiesel? Today?" he continued.
"Why not today?" I countered.
"Today is the start of fucking Hanukkah, asshole."

Looking back, I realize that I might have been a bit insensitive. I offer my sincere apologies to all of my friends who were somehow offended by that. I should have been more aware of the context and the significance of the day.
July 14,2025
... Show More
This amazing play is truly a remarkable piece of work.

It is based on Elie Wiesel's harrowing experience in the Auschwitz death camp, which serves as a powerful backdrop for this stunning theological exploration. Set within the framework of a drama, it boldly accuses God of his absence in the face of unfathomable horror, particularly the atrocities committed against his own people.

The introduction by Robert McAfee Brown and the afterword by Matthew Fox add significant depth and value to the understanding and processing of the story. They offer unique perspectives and insights that enhance the overall impact of the play.

Together, these elements combine to create a thought-provoking and emotionally charged work that forces us to grapple with the profound questions of faith, suffering, and the nature of God in the midst of such extreme evil.
July 14,2025
... Show More
The Trial of God by Elie Wiesel delves into numerous fundamental human inquiries.

Firstly, the entire setting of the play is grounded in a real trial of God that the author witnessed. While the trial might not have had the exact same subjects, aims, or conclusions, it does possess very similar corollaries that form the philosophical foundation in the western world.

Regarding evil in the context of God, there is a rather famous and simplistic form of argumentation. The logic pertains to three characteristics of God. God could have two but not all three of the following attributes: omniscience, omnibenevolence, and omnipotence. If God had all three, there would be no evil. If God were all good and all knowing, He might desire to prevent bad things from occurring but lack the necessary power. If God were all knowing and all powerful, there would be a distinct lack of concern for bad things. If God were all good and all powerful, then everything bad would be unknown to God. These arguments all rely on attempting to understand God through reason. However, this logical form of reasoning fails to consider the possibility that God and nature have no obligation whatsoever to make sense to mankind.

Many other arguments exist that reason in a similar manner. I am more familiar with the divine command theory. This theory posits that either God would not command someone to do evil or that His sense of morality ultimately aims at a higher good. This theory has a similar drawback as the previously mentioned one in that it relates to the capacity of humans to attribute meaning where there may be none. It also has its roots in the Old Testament. When God commands Abraham to sacrifice Isaac, Abraham obeys the order but is stopped before killing his son. This contextually implies that God will test people but not permit undue pain or evil. Although the book of Job seems to be at least somewhat in conflict with this idea. Job was a perfectly obedient follower of God who was chosen to endure great pain by God. This book once again raises the question of why this would happen. Within the text itself, some attribute God’s choice to a bad action on Job’s part. However, like the Trial of God, the evil that plagues certain people is not caused by some bad deed. The book of Job and Wiesel are separated by thousands of years and yet pose similar questions for which there are few answers. Both literary works that attempt to grapple with the human experience allow readers to draw their own conclusions. At the very least, we can hope for fortitude when faced with the ineffability of life’s suffering. It's a good book worth reading, but not worth the 12 dollars for the kindle edition on Amazon.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Elie Wiesel is a favorite of mine. I had not read this particular work of his before, and it truly came as a pleasant surprise.

It was so captivating that I immediately knew I wanted to own it. The words on the pages seemed to come alive, pulling me into Wiesel's world and making me feel every emotion he had experienced.

I was completely engrossed from the very beginning until the end. The way he tells his story is both powerful and poignant, leaving a lasting impression on my heart and mind.

After finishing it, I knew that I would have to reread this book. There were so many details and nuances that I wanted to explore further, and I was eager to experience the story all over again.

I am certain that each time I read it, I will discover something new and gain a deeper understanding of Wiesel's message.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.