...
Show More
This book fails to provide any engaging explanations or compelling arguments regarding the validity of Christianity. I decided to read it because my younger brother, who vacillates between paganism, a rather weak form of Christianity, and whatever else offers him comfort, believed that I might find it interesting and that I could gain a better understanding of Christianity. He seems to have mistakenly equated my disagreement with a lack of understanding. The arguments presented by Lewis in this book would have been quite interesting if it were intended as a satire of narrow-minded Christian apologetics. However, it is meant to be taken seriously. The fact that this book has any significance at all makes me feel rather disheartened. His arguments for the authenticity of Jesus as the son of God are so easily refuted that it is astonishing. It's as if he is using logic similar to that of a third grader trying to figure out how the world's supply of cows produced the milk that was used to make the cheese that the moon is supposedly made of. To spare you, dear readers, some time, a fair amount of torn hair, and several millimeters of gnashed teeth, I will summarize as follows: Christianity is considered true because the author of a series of books where children enter a wardrobe and are transported to a magical land with faster time, talking lions, and wars against mystical beings believes that the stories of Christianity are too detailed and fantastical to be fabricated. Jesus was truly God because the other alternatives are that he was the devil, which is clearly not the case, or a madman. And according to the author, nobody could be so insane as to think of themselves as God, despite the fact that most people who will eventually read this are likely to be within the vicinity of someone who believes themselves to be God, Napoleon, or Jesus. The possibility that Jesus could have been a liar is not really considered. Some day, I hope to come across Christian apologetics that don't leave me amazed that the author managed to avoid, on a daily basis, walking into traffic and getting hit by a truck because he forgot to open his eyes when getting out of bed.