"Pride, the inevitable vice of the stupid."
In the imagination of the readers - and also non-readers - of this novel, there is the image of Gulliver lying on the beach of Lilliput, with many little people walking on him, the same image that I see now depicted on the cover. It is a partial and limited image of this masterpiece by Swift. Because, in my opinion, Gulliver's journey to Lilliput, which is the first of the four stories told in the novel, is perhaps the least interesting from the perspective of the literary value of the work. Certainly, it is the most fantastic and entertaining story, together with the immediately following one, in the upside-down kingdom of Brobdingnag, where the inhabitants are as tall as towers and Gulliver is smaller than the court dwarf of the Queen. Their reading, accompanied by the vivid images in front of the eyes of the adventures of poor Gulliver, who, among other things, ends up three-quarters of his body inside the osso buco eagerly devoured by the Queen of Brobdingnag, has entertained me and stimulated my imagination.
In the last two voyages narrated in the book, the tone changes and a sarcastic criticism of the customs and ideas of so-called civilized societies prevails, where intellectual pride and Machiavellian sophistries reign. And so in the kingdom of Lagado - where the only sciences studied are mathematics and music but whose inhabitants only create failures, crooked houses and ridiculous clothes - a fierce criticism of Cartesian rationalism is read, which considers mathematics the only methodological model of all knowledge (there is no room for fantasy and invention). While the Houyhnhnm, animals similar to horses, whose country is the destination of Gulliver's last journey, govern and keep as slaves other beasts, the yahoo, completely similar to humans, and live according to a philosophical conception assimilable to naturalistic Enlightenment, in the perfect binomial Nature-Reason that makes them rational and immune from human vices such as lying, dissimulation and everything that leads to intellectual doubt.
Despite the tone of admiration for this last people, whose life seems perfect, criticisms also emerge of this system of thought, which knows no doubts but only cognitive certainties, "since Reason teaches us to assert or deny only the things of which we are certain; and beyond our knowledge, neither one nor the other thing is possible.." Gulliver (that is, Swift), always a foreigner among his kind, after having led us in allegorical voyages through utopian countries with the aim of putting the customs of the contemporaries to the test, comes to a very bitter conclusion, an appeal-less condemnation, albeit with a smile on his lips, of the human race that abuses Reason to debase it in vices and defects that make it greedy and insensitive: "my reconciliation with the species of yahoo in general would perhaps not be so difficult if they were content with the vices and follies to which Nature has destined them... but when I see a mass of deformities and diseases, both physical and spiritual, swollen with pride, then immediately all the limits of my tolerance collapse". A teaching of universal value, left to us by a great writer who is considered a precursor of the Enlightenment, but also capable of anticipating its negative aspects.