Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
33(33%)
4 stars
41(41%)
3 stars
26(26%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More

Picoult's books are renowned for their ability to make readers think deeply and reveal the multifaceted nature of a single issue. Salem Falls, on the surface, presents as a modern-day witchhunt in the guise of a rape trial. However, it is truly the intricate backstories of the characters that breathe life into the book. Her writing style is unassuming yet powerfully conveys a profound message.


From the outset, the outcome of the rape trial seems rather evident. Nevertheless, it is the entire course of the trial and the actions of each character that draw the reader deeply into the story. Your perspectives on the characters will undergo significant transformations as you progress through the book.


There is a truly shocking revelation in the book that occurs right at the very end. It has been subtly hinted at throughout the text - certain passages might give you a slightly "off" feeling, but you tend to dismiss it. However, once you have completed reading the book, you will be compelled to go back and re-read these same passages in light of the new information. This revelation completely alters the tone of these passages and the motivations of certain characters.

July 14,2025
... Show More

\\"Salem Falls\\" is a captivating story about a charming man named Jack St. Bride. He was unjustly convicted of statutory rape and, after serving his time in jail, he relocates to the town of Salem Falls. However, his arrival disrupts the usually peaceful town, as a large movement emerges to drive him out. In Salem Falls, Jack meets Addie Peabody, a woman with a tragic past and a heart that heals, much like his new home. Just as they begin to fall in love, Jack is wrongly accused of rape once again, this time by Gillian Duncan, a wealthy girl whose father owns a large drug manufacturing company. Now, he must endure the harrowing legal process yet again, where either love might set him free or lies could condemn him to a life in jail.


This novel, written by the talented Jodi Picoult, is truly outstanding. I developed a deep affection for the characters, including Jack, Addie, Catherine, Jordan, Thomas, and even Gillian, once I discovered her significant role at the conclusion of the book. Jodi masterfully maintained the pacing of the story, ensuring there were no dull moments and no confusion. It was a delight to see Jordan and Selena again, as I had encountered them in \\"Nineteen Minutes\\" and \\"The Pact\\". This book held my attention from start to finish, and I completed it in approximately a day and a quarter. I eagerly anticipate Jodi's future works.

July 14,2025
... Show More
I have now read nearly all of Jodi Picoult's books. (I couldn't get through Second Glance.) This particular one was actually among her better works, despite being extremely ridiculous at times. It's a somewhat convoluted story that essentially boils down to this: Jack St. Bride, a teacher and soccer coach, is accused of sexual assault by a student, takes a plea, and serves time in jail. After getting out of jail, he desires to start a new life and ends up in Salem Falls at a diner with Addie, a woman who hires him on the spot. There is another allegation made by an underage girl, and about half of the book covers the investigation and trial. Of course, in Salem Falls, nothing is as it seems. (Hint: witches are from Salem.)


This time, Ms. Picoult managed to incorporate a few twists into her story, saving the final "Law and Order" twist until the very last page. I must admit, it took me a while to figure it out. My biggest gripe with her books is that they are fairly well constructed (even if they read like a stereotypical Lifetime movie), but then the ending just sort of happens.


It was a quick read and a decent story, with her "issue" being Megan's Law and whether laws mandating the registration and public announcement of individuals with prior sexual convictions are the best approach.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I absolutely loved it. Jodie Picoult is truly at her best in this book.

The tension in the first half is so palpable that it's almost suffocating. You find yourself completely engrossed in the story, on the edge of your seat.

Then, there comes a point where you start to question whether Jack is guilty or not. From the very beginning, I had rooted for him, believing in his innocence.

However, as the story progresses, the writing is so incredibly subtle that before you know it, you're not at all sure whether he's pulled the wool over your eyes.

I can't quite put my finger on the exact point where my opinion began to shift.

But I won't give any spoilers here. So, whether or not he's innocent, you'll have to read the book to find out for yourself.

If you're a fan of Ms Picoult's other novels, I would highly recommend this one. It's definitely one of my favorites that she's written.

You won't be disappointed.
July 14,2025
... Show More

Covering a controversial issue, this book takes a gentle and tactful approach. It presents both sides of the argument, which is a refreshing departure from the typical one-sided discussions. By doing so, it allows readers to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the problem at hand. The author skillfully navigates through the complex issues, presenting the facts in a clear and concise manner. This makes it easier for readers to form their own opinions and make informed decisions. Whether you are already familiar with the issue or are just learning about it, this book is a valuable resource that offers a unique perspective. It encourages open-mindedness and critical thinking, and is sure to spark interesting discussions among readers.

July 14,2025
... Show More
This is an amazing book.

The story is full of twists and turns that keep you on the edge of your seat from beginning to end.

The characters are well-developed and you really care about what happens to them.

But the best part of all is the ending. It's completely unexpected and yet it makes perfect sense.

It ties up all the loose ends and leaves you with a feeling of satisfaction.

I absolutely loved this book and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a great read.

It's one of those books that you'll be thinking about long after you've finished it.
July 14,2025
... Show More

I must confess that the first half of the book was slow and demotivating. There were so many characters that I just couldn't get into the story. It felt like I was constantly struggling to keep up and understand who was who and what was going on.


However, the second half of the book was spectacular. It was simple, fluid, and extremely captivating. The story finally started to come together, and I found myself completely engrossed. The pacing was perfect, and I couldn't put the book down.


Overall, while it's not one of my all-time favorites, I still liked it quite a bit. The second half really redeemed the first, and I'm glad I stuck with it. It's a book that shows the importance of perseverance and not giving up too easily.

July 14,2025
... Show More
Jodi Picoult is coming to speak in my town.

Excited about the event, I thought I’d read at least one of her books before going to her talk.

I chose Salem Falls as the subject matter resonated with me. One of my ancestors was hanged during the Salem Witch Trials in the late seventeenth century, and this book promised to explore a similar theme.

Picoult writes with fluency, and at times, her writing is quite good. However, as the book progresses, a certain covenant is established between the writer and the reader. Unfortunately, almost immediately, Picoult lost my trust.

On page 2, when Jack St. Bride walks out of prison after an eight-month stay, someone offers him a ride in his car. Jack hesitates. Despite the invitation, he doesn't reach out and open the door. He has come to think that a car door is like a prison door, which only opens when an officer buzzes him through. In just eight months, he has seemingly forgotten how cars work.

This was a clever idea, but I couldn't bring myself to believe it. And after that, I became suspicious, constantly looking for other scenes that felt false. There were plenty of them.

In a flashback on page 40, Jack talks his way out of a rape in prison, using a single disparaging comment to intimidate the rapist. Jack is portrayed as extremely smart (he knows all the answers on Jeopardy!), and with just a few words, he deflates the prison's most threatening inmate.

Once I started doubting, nothing in the book seemed real. Page after page, scene after unlikely scene, I found myself unable to believe any of it. I struggled to page 100, but eventually, I gave up.

Perhaps I was too critical, but for me, the book failed to maintain the suspension of disbelief necessary for an engaging read.
July 14,2025
... Show More

I'm always truly amazed at the remarkable creativity and diverse subject matter that Picoult presents in her works. The fact that she has the ability to write about such extremely difficult topics with such finesse and yet manage to keep the reader completely engaged throughout is a testament to just how talented she truly is. This particular book might not have been my absolute favorite among all of hers, but nevertheless, I am still highly impressed by the challenging subject matter that she fearlessly tackles. Her writing has a way of making you think deeply and feel a wide range of emotions. It's as if she takes you on a journey through the most complex and often overlooked aspects of human nature and society. Picoult's work continues to leave a lasting impression on me, and I look forward to seeing what she comes up with next.

July 14,2025
... Show More
In this novel, Jodi Picoult tells the story of Jack St. Bride, who is accused of sexual assault. Recently, he has been released from prison and moves to a new town, trying to start a new life. However, his past soon catches up with him. The residents of the town are hostilely disposed towards him when a group of teenagers accuse him of committing a crime.

"Salem Falls" by Jodi Picoult is not a typical family drama. It is a fascinating exploration of the unrelenting grip of the past, the power of forgiveness, and the search for self-discovery. Picoult masterfully creates novels that transcend generations, forcing us to confront the complexities of family relationships and the scars left by long-hidden secrets.

If you like this kind of theme: accusation of a crime, injustice, and spookiness. Then this book will definitely suit you 100%.
July 14,2025
... Show More
What a remarkable story it is!

I immediately felt a profound sense of sympathy for the main character, Jack St Bride. He had to endure such a harrowing experience, not just once but twice!

For those who haven't read it, I won't give away the details and spoil the plot. However, it's certain that there should be more stories like this one, which carry a glimmer of truth within the fictional narrative.

The justice system we have in place may seem to be without flaws on the surface, but I wouldn't be at all surprised if there are hidden imperfections that are carefully concealed.

Just think about it, how many people out there have been unjustly convicted and are still languishing in prison, serving a sentence that they don't deserve?

If you have a penchant for stories that compel you to take a close and critical look at the issues that surround us in our daily lives, then this book is definitely a must-read for you.

It has the power to make you question and reflect on the world we live in and the systems that govern it.
July 14,2025
... Show More
As a Jodi Picoult stan, this is by far the worst book I have ever read. I understand that I need to give some leeway considering the culture today is vastly different from when this was written. However, I find it rather challenging to empathize with Jack at times. It was really tough to power through this novel.

Nevertheless, I have always adored a Jordan McAfee appearance. And getting a bit more of his origin story was truly interesting. It added an extra layer of depth to his character.

Despite the flaws in the main storyline and my struggle to connect with Jack, the inclusion of Jordan's backstory was a redeeming factor. It made me eager to see what else Jodi Picoult has in store for us in the future. Maybe her next book will be more to my liking and will once again remind me why I fell in love with her writing in the first place.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.