...
Show More
**"My Thoughts on a Picoult Book"**
On 11/10/08, I finally finished this book that I had been dreading carrying around in my purse for another day. I read it for my book club, which usually selects much better books. I had never been interested in reading a Picoult book before, and I doubt I will again.
The story is about Faith White, who starts talking to God and developing stigmata after her parents' separation and divorce. There are also medical issues, a custody battle, and a hot Southern television guy who is supposed to prove Faith is a fraud but ends up falling for her mom.
I had many issues with this book. Firstly, it was extremely formulaic, like Picoult had a system for churning out books for a female market. The characters and details were interchangeable, and I'm sure another Picoult book would be the same with just a few changes.
Secondly, for a beach read, it took itself way too seriously. It pretended to be about religion and protecting children, but it was really just a predictable story with some courtroom drama thrown in.
Thirdly, although the characters kept insisting the story was about Faith, Picoult didn't pay much attention to her until the end. Instead, the focus was on Mariah, the mother.
Fourthly, I didn't find any of the characters to be deep or likable. They were all stereotypes or one-dimensional.
Finally, Picoult wanted to make it seem like the book was more complicated than it was, but she didn't put in the effort to write a truly complex story.
Thankfully, the book club meeting isn't for a while, so I can rant about this book for a few more days. But right now, I'm just wondering how many times Picoult watched "Contact" and if she was trying to cover up the fact that Ian's character was like Matthew McConaughey's in that movie.
On 11/06/08, I sighed, thinking this wasn't the kind of book I would choose for a book club of intelligent young women.
On 11/10/08, I finally finished this book that I had been dreading carrying around in my purse for another day. I read it for my book club, which usually selects much better books. I had never been interested in reading a Picoult book before, and I doubt I will again.
The story is about Faith White, who starts talking to God and developing stigmata after her parents' separation and divorce. There are also medical issues, a custody battle, and a hot Southern television guy who is supposed to prove Faith is a fraud but ends up falling for her mom.
I had many issues with this book. Firstly, it was extremely formulaic, like Picoult had a system for churning out books for a female market. The characters and details were interchangeable, and I'm sure another Picoult book would be the same with just a few changes.
Secondly, for a beach read, it took itself way too seriously. It pretended to be about religion and protecting children, but it was really just a predictable story with some courtroom drama thrown in.
Thirdly, although the characters kept insisting the story was about Faith, Picoult didn't pay much attention to her until the end. Instead, the focus was on Mariah, the mother.
Fourthly, I didn't find any of the characters to be deep or likable. They were all stereotypes or one-dimensional.
Finally, Picoult wanted to make it seem like the book was more complicated than it was, but she didn't put in the effort to write a truly complex story.
Thankfully, the book club meeting isn't for a while, so I can rant about this book for a few more days. But right now, I'm just wondering how many times Picoult watched "Contact" and if she was trying to cover up the fact that Ian's character was like Matthew McConaughey's in that movie.
On 11/06/08, I sighed, thinking this wasn't the kind of book I would choose for a book club of intelligent young women.