Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
34(34%)
4 stars
38(38%)
3 stars
27(27%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More
This one truly made me engage in deep thought.

The characters had such an alluring charm that they pulled me in right from the very beginning.

It was a great book with a plot that kept me on the edge of my seat throughout.

The development of the characters was so well done, making them feel real and relatable.

And then, there was the ending. Oh, what a brilliant ending it was!

It tied up all the loose ends in the most satisfying way, leaving me with a sense of fulfillment and wonder.

I found myself reflecting on the story long after I had turned the last page, pondering over the themes and messages it conveyed.

This book is definitely one that I would highly recommend to others, as it has the power to captivate and inspire.
July 14,2025
... Show More
My introduction to Picoult was an interesting experience. I wasn't disappointed in the sense that the validation of traditional values, like having a mid-afternoon cup of tea after picking up the kids from school, worked for me. However, I was also quite bored at times.

The beginning of the book was slow and annoyingly drawn out. I found myself wanting to slap all the characters, especially Allie for being such a goody-two-shoes and non-adventurous little housewife. The middle of the book didn't offer much more excitement, but the Cam-Mia affair was actually quite hot and sweet. The most interesting part, though, was the grind of the court-case. It made me think that perhaps I should go back to reading John Grisham.

The characters were strangely plausible. Most people I know operate in shades of gray, and that's what Picoult captured well. However, what I didn't enjoy was the over-analysis of every potential significance. Flowers, bonsai, every glance, every moment - it was just too much. No one really lives like that, not even a melodramatic psychoanalytical person like me.

Oddly enough, despite all these criticisms, I was still hooked. I wanted to know the outcome of the story. My favorite line was something like 'Love is a bigger stickier version of trust', because it really struck a chord within my own complicated love life.

My favorite character was Kafka, who added an element of mystery and depth to the story. Overall, my experience with Picoult's book was a mixed bag, but it did manage to keep me engaged until the end.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I don't think I've ever come across a book that managed to infuriate me to such an extent. I have always been a huge fan of Jodi Picoult's stories, as her writing has the power to draw me in and make me feel deeply for the characters. However, this particular book took things a step too far.

It had me seething with anger at the actions and decisions of the characters. I found myself constantly questioning their sanity and wondering what on earth they were thinking. How could they make such choices? It was truly baffling.

But perhaps I'm being too harsh. Maybe you'll have a completely different perspective. So don't just take my word for it. Judge for yourself. Pick up the book and see if it has the same effect on you. Who knows, you might love it just as much as I usually love Jodi Picoult's work.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Well, there's 481 pages of my life that I'm never getting back.

These 481 pages hold a world of memories, experiences, and emotions. Each page is like a snapshot of a moment in time, frozen forever.

Some of those pages are filled with joy and laughter, while others are marked with tears and heartache. There are pages that tell the story of my achievements and successes, and there are also pages that document my failures and mistakes.

But despite all the ups and downs, those 481 pages are a part of me. They have shaped who I am today and have taught me valuable lessons along the way.

Even though I can never get those pages back, I can cherish the memories they hold and use them to move forward in life. I can look back on those pages with a sense of pride and gratitude, knowing that they have made me the person I am today.

So, while I may never be able to rewrite those 481 pages, I can continue to write the next chapter of my life with purpose and intention.
July 14,2025
... Show More
There might be a million ways to die, but when it comes to attempting suicide, the options are somewhat limited.

Some individuals opt for violent methods such as hanging or putting a gun to their mouth. Others choose non-violent means like taking pills, drowning, or jumping from a high place. And then there are those who involve others in their decision to die, like suicide by cop or through euthanasia.

Cameron McDonald is the police chief of a small town in Massachusetts. He essentially inherited this title when his beloved father passed away prematurely from a heart attack. At heart, Cameron is a wanderer and is dissatisfied with his provincial marriage to Allie, the quintessential small town girl.

One morning, his cousin Jamie arrives in town with his dead wife by his side. Jamie claims that he killed her out of mercy, as she had asked him to in response to an extremely aggressive form of cancer. On the very same day, Mia Townsend walks into Allie’s flower shop and begins quietly taking over, demonstrating an instinctive knowledge of the language of flowers.

What follows is a reckoning from which no one escapes unscathed. Sides are taken, and these divisions will be etched forever in history.

I truly relished this book. I adored the way it compared and contrasted Maggie and Jamie’s marriage with Allie and Cam’s marriage. I also loved that it broached the topic of euthanasia as a form of mercy killing. I firmly believe that everyone should have the right to choose how they die, but I don't think one should enlist the help of others to do so.

July 14,2025
... Show More
This is yet another entirely realistic and thought-provoking read penned by Picoult.

The issues of euthanasia and infidelity are curiously intertwined within the narrative.

Cam, who serves as the Chief of Police, and Allie, his affectionate wife, reside in a small town. However, this is no idyllic "Mayberry."

There is intense courtroom drama as a cousin stands trial, engaged in a battle with lawyers.

Moreover, a highly convoluted love affair adds an extra layer of complexity.

You simply cannot resist the allure of this book.

It draws you in with its realistic portrayal of human relationships and the moral dilemmas that arise.

The story unfolds in a way that keeps you on the edge of your seat, eager to discover what will happen next.

Picoult's writing is masterful, as she weaves together a tale that is both engaging and deeply moving.

Once you start reading, you'll find it impossible to put this book down.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I really struggled with this book.

To be honest, I didn't like one of the main characters, Cameron, at all. And to make matters worse, I didn't like Mia either.

The entire affair that started after they had only seen each other three times was just ridiculous. It felt so rushed and unrealistic.

Moreover, there were way too many sex scenes in the book. It seemed like the author was relying on them to drive the story forward rather than developing the characters and the plot in a more meaningful way.

Overall, I was extremely disappointed with this book. It didn't meet my expectations at all, and I would not recommend it to others.
July 14,2025
... Show More
This was truly a challenging one to rate.

I have a deep affection for a good Jodi book. Her chosen topics are invariably thought-provoking, having the power to stimulate the reader's mind and make them anticipate what lies ahead. However, in this particular instance, I found certain parts of it rather boring.

What I really desired was to have more in-depth exploration about euthanasia or death with dignity. Instead, it seemed to veer towards a story about a cheating spouse.

Nonetheless, considering the overall picture, it was still a good story. So, I have decided to round up the rating to 3 - 4 stars.

Despite its flaws, there were still elements that held my interest and made it a worthwhile read.

I hope that in her future works, Jodi will focus more on the aspects that truly engage and challenge her readers.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Meh.

This novel of hers fails to truly capture my interest.

It lacks the charm and depth that I have come to expect from her works.

The story seems rather平淡 and uneventful, lacking the excitement and twists that would make it a page-turner.

The characters also feel a bit one-dimensional, not fully developed or engaging enough.

While I appreciate her writing style to some extent, this particular novel just doesn't do it for me.

It's not that it's a bad book, but it's definitely not my favorite of her novels.

I was hoping for something more, something that would leave a lasting impression.

Unfortunately, this one falls short of my expectations.

Maybe her next novel will be more to my liking.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I may have rated this book lower had the author been anyone else. I’ll admit my bias here.

It’s clear that this is an earlier work in her repertoire.

First, I didn’t find any of the characters admirable or redeemable. None were characters that I felt like championing. And their development felt underdone for such a complex plot.

As well, there seem to be so many components to this novel that don’t all clear themselves up at the end. What was the significance of the virtual reality? Of Angus and his flashbacks? Why did Mia and Cam click so quickly with no history and why was he willing to throw his marriage away for someone so seemingly insignificant? Or, in the reverse, if he really wanted a different life, why didn’t he take it? Why so much background on Graham to then not develop him further than the trial? How did the jury come to their decision? So many unanswered questions and ends that don’t tie up.

Overall it wasn’t my favorite of her works. The story had potential, but it just didn't quite come together for me. The characters lacked depth and the plot had too many loose ends. I was left feeling unsatisfied and disappointed. Maybe with more experience, the author will be able to create a more engaging and fulfilling novel.
July 14,2025
... Show More
The novel Mercy is set in the seemingly idyllic Massachusetts town of Wheelock. Its unique Scottish history, which is explored in great detail, almost to the point of being tiresome, shapes the lives of Cameron MacDonald, the police chief and clan chief, and his wife Allie, a florist who has been in love with her husband for as long as she can remember. Then, Cameron's estranged cousin, Jamie, arrives in town with a dead wife, and Allie gets a new assistant in the form of an enigmatic, worldly wanderer.

One of the first things that strikes you when reading this novel is its complete lack of originality. Jodi Picoult seems to have plagiarized herself, and this would be forgivable if the novel was in any way compelling or interesting. Unfortunately, it is not. In fact, it is quite the opposite.

None of the characters in the novel are particularly sympathetic. Some do manage to elicit a bit of sympathy at times, such as Mia at the beginning of the novel when the reader first learns about her as a "lonely girl." However, this sympathy quickly fades as the lack of character stability becomes evident. There is no real character growth; instead, there are sudden 180-degree turns with little to no evidence to support the change. An example of this is Allie, who is initially shown as timid, loyal, and a bit of a wimp. But at the end of the novel, after finding out that her husband has cheated on her, she suddenly becomes a badass, with no explanation as to where this newfound courage comes from.

Then there's Jamie, who is a walking cliché of a character, constantly spouting lines that are supposed to be profound but come across as forced and irritating.

The book also lacks subtlety. Picoult doesn't allow the reader to figure out the metaphors on their own; instead, she spells them out flat-out, usually with flower imagery. The foreshadowing is sparse, cliched, and predictable. For example, near the end of the novel, Jamie has a conversation with Cam's mother, Ellen, about what he plans to do after he gets off, even though he doesn't know if he will be acquitted.

The handling of the morality of Jamie's actions is another area where the novel fails. It is rather heavy-handed, and the comparison drawn between Jamie killing his wife out of love and Cam cheating on Allie because he is in love with another woman is a bit offensive. Jamie had a reason for his actions, and whether that reason is sufficient to justify what he did is something that the reader should be able to decide for themselves. Cam, on the other hand, had no real reason to cheat on his wife other than being a jerk who is dissatisfied with his life.

There are other issues with the novel as well, such as missed opportunities to explore the characters more deeply and expand on their emotional and psychological states during Jamie's trial. The notes between the chapters seem unnecessary, and overall, there is a lot wrong with this book. However, perhaps we shouldn't hold Picoult too accountable for this mess, considering she has to churn out a book every year, regardless of its quality.
July 14,2025
... Show More

2.5 was rounded up because the book club discussion was truly amazing. It was so lively and engaging that it felt like it deserved a higher rating. The members were sharing their thoughts and ideas passionately, and there was a great deal of energy in the room. The topics covered were diverse and thought-provoking, and everyone had something valuable to contribute. It was one of those discussions that made you realize the power of books to bring people together and spark meaningful conversations. Overall, it was a great experience, and I'm looking forward to the next book club meeting to see what other精彩的 discussionsawait.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.