...
Show More
If there had been half-stars, this book would have rated 2.5. It was better than okay, but I didn't really like it. I had read four or five Jodi Picoult novels and found, from the first high of My Sister's Keeper, it to be a slow, downhill road and this book doesn't break that path. The first half, which took me three days to read, established the characters, none of whom I liked. There is the adulterous husband who feels guilty about never passing up an opportunity to cheat on his wife with her strange employee who wanders from town to town looking for love. There is his wife, Allie, the submissive woman par excellence who held on to her virginity until she met her husband at 25 and whose every action is designed to please him. Her small show of self-assertiveness is quickly cast aside in favour of forgiveness and love. Then there is the murderer who really isn't, his wife who is absolutely perfect in every single way and was dying of cancer anyway, and sundry other characters, all of them caricatures of their occupations. The plot was ordinary, the central theme, All For Love, who loves enough... might have worked if I had liked the characters more, and the language was often overly flowery and reminiscent of a romance novel. So why did I like it at all? Two reasons. Firstly, Jodi Picoult has the amazing ability to keep you engaged, turning the pages unable to put the book down until you find out what happens. It took me less than a couple of hours to read the second half of the book. Secondly, I was trying to second-guess what the twist at the end would be. I guessed several possible ones and I was wrong, wrong, wrong. It's very nice to have the author pull a surprise on you. I do like Picoult for that and so, I'm not going to give up on her just yet - the Tenth Circle is sitting on my coffee table already. Overall, this book had its flaws but also some redeeming qualities. While the characters and plot weren't my favourites, Picoult's writing style and ability to keep me hooked were enough to make me finish the book and look forward to reading more of her work. I'm curious to see if the Tenth Circle will be able to break the pattern and return to the heights of My Sister's Keeper. Only time will tell.