“It is an old observation that the best writers sometimes disregard the rules of rhetoric,” says professor Strunk. The old fart was probably referring to his students at Cornell University. The Elements of Style is indeed a dusty textbook (1918), but still widely in use today. It aims at providing a set of rules and tips on how to write properly, if not elegantly. Stephen King, in On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft, strongly recommends this book to any aspiring fiction writer.
In truth, such rules as, for instance, the pre-eminence of the active over the passive voice, or the superiority of the positive over the negative mode in a sentence (which, at the time, were perhaps not as evident), have become the sesame of communication, advocated at school, in business and even in spelling and grammar software. These rules help to make the writing more clear, direct and engaging. They also ensure that the message is conveyed effectively and accurately.
Some of Strunk’s remarks are amusing, sarcastic even, like this one on the use of the word Nature: “Often vaguely used in such expressions as “a lover of nature;” “poems about nature.” Unless more specific statements follow, the reader cannot tell whether the poems have to do with natural scenery, rural life, the sunset, the untracked wilderness, or the habits of squirrels.” This shows that Strunk was not only a stickler for the rules but also had a sense of humor.
While this hodgepodge of rules is at best a bit arbitrary and, at worst, quite outdated, the core of it all is to prompt students to write boldly, confidently, legibly, with crispness and vigour, and avoid fizzling out with sloppy writing — nothing wrong about that. After all, good writing is about expressing oneself clearly and effectively, and these rules can serve as a useful guide to achieving that goal.
I should most definitely list this on my erotica shelf. You see, in the world of literature, there are various elements that can have a profound impact on a reader. And for me, if there is anything that makes me shiver with a strange kind of excitement, it’s grammar. The precise usage of words, the correct placement of punctuation, and the proper construction of sentences can create a sense of order and beauty that is truly captivating. It’s like a hidden art form that adds a layer of sophistication and allure to any piece of writing. Whether it’s a steamy romance novel or a thought-provoking work of erotica, grammar has the power to enhance the reading experience and make it all the more enjoyable.
Readers seeking a style manual, a usage or grammar guide have numerous better options than Strunk and White. When I first started using this book in the late 1980s, it was extremely helpful for my college papers and later for my early work writing. However, now, thirty years later, rereading it is like looking at the computer I used back then. It is obsolete in many aspects and insufficient for today's tasks.
The English language is constantly evolving, influenced by its countless speakers and writers. What was correct thirty years ago may not hold true today. I understand the argument that grammar doesn't change, only people's incorrect usage. But consider Shakespeare's line in As You Like It: "I cannot go no further." It wasn't idiomatic. When grammarians declared double negation wrong, a prominent linguist of the time argued that the English language was weakened as a result. That was a long time ago, but changes are happening all the time. As the Millennial generation leaves its mark on the language, they will surely make some alterations of their own.
As writers and speakers of the language, we require a style and usage manual that ensures we are current. Strunk and White's Elements of Style fails to meet this need. Moreover, as we become more and more sophisticated (think about the powerful computers we now carry in our hands), we need a style and usage manual that is also more advanced. I'm sorry to say, a comprehensive manual on the English language won't fit in your pocket.
If you're in search of a great style and usage manual, check out anything written by Bryan Garner.
No doubt I've made some grammar or style errors in this review. I'm not perfect, but my style and usage manual by Bryan Garner is.
A nice revision of the dos and don'ts of writing has been presented. It is straightforward to the point and highly focused on syntax and grammar. This aspect is indeed very beneficial for those who are looking to improve their writing skills in a more formal and structured way.
However, as other reviewers have accurately pointed out, this book is clearly geared towards essay writing rather than creative writing. While it provides valuable guidelines and principles for constructing well-written essays, it may not be as applicable or useful for those engaged in creative writing endeavors. For example, creative writing often allows for more flexibility and experimentation with language, structure, and style, which may not be emphasized in the same way in this book.
Therefore, it is important to use the content of this book appropriately, depending on one's writing goals and needs. If you are primarily interested in improving your essay writing skills, then this book can be a great resource. However, if you are more inclined towards creative writing, you may need to supplement the information in this book with other resources that specifically address the unique challenges and opportunities of creative writing.