Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
41(41%)
4 stars
30(30%)
3 stars
29(29%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More
Wallace Stegnar masterfully leads us into Bruce's profound reflections as he returns to Salt Lake City out of a sense of obligation.

As we accompany Bruce on this journey, we witness him being torn between multiple identities - that of a son, a friend, a boyfriend, and the person he has evolved into.

I have an immense love for Stegnar's writing style as it presents a nuanced and complex story of a man, encompassing both the beautiful and the not-so-pretty aspects of his character.

Stegnar refuses to neatly package the story with a convenient happy ending, instead, he allows the rawness and reality to shine through.

This book is truly a gem for those of us who grapple with an ugly grief and yet still hold a deep love for a family that may not always be easy to like.

It offers a poignant and relatable exploration of the human condition and the often messy relationships that shape our lives.
July 14,2025
... Show More

This particular work by Stegner may not be my absolute favorite. However, it should be noted that even what might be considered average Stegner is still of great value and well worth the time spent reading. His writing has a certain charm and quality that makes it a delightful experience. The way he crafts his stories, develops his characters, and描绘 the settings is truly remarkable. Even in this work that may not reach the heights of his best, there are still many elements that engage the reader and draw them into the narrative. It serves as a reminder of Stegner's talent and the enjoyment that can be derived from his writing, regardless of whether it is his top masterpiece or not.

July 14,2025
... Show More
This isn't my favorite work by Stegner, yet it still presents an interesting idea.

It explores what it's like to journey back to one's youth by revisiting significant locations and reflecting on and reevaluating life-altering decisions.

Haven't we all engaged in such a process at some point?

The setting to which the lead character returns is Salt Lake City, a place where I myself have resided and am quite familiar with.

He对待这座城市及其居民的态度既温柔又严厉, because a place and its people are never simply one-sidedly good or bad.

There are always multiple layers and nuances to consider.

Perhaps through his experiences in Salt Lake City, we can gain a deeper understanding of the complexity of human nature and the impact of our past decisions on our present lives.

It makes us wonder what we would discover if we were to embark on a similar journey of self-discovery and reflection.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I was initially quite worried when I noticed the lower rating for this book. However, as I delved into it, I ended up enjoying it very much indeed.

It was truly a delight to revisit the world of Big Rock Candy Mountain from the perspective of Bruce Mason. Stegner has an incredible talent for storytelling when he can get behind the eyes of an intelligent character, and Bruce Mason is precisely such a character.

I found it extremely clever how Stegner develops the character of Bruce as an important dignitary and then takes us back in time, unfolding the story through his memories. This approach gives the scenes from the past a certain sense of reassurance, knowing that despite the numerous complications and potential pitfalls, Bruce ultimately makes the right choice.

For instance, he is torn between marrying his serious girlfriend and succumbing to the pressure of starting a business with his best friend. His choices lie between loyalty to friends, the desire to get married and not string his girlfriend along (risking losing her otherwise), and going to law school. But one never gets the impression that going to law school was the only right choice.

Sure, it's what he chose, and it led to him becoming an important person, but is there really a single right way to live? There are just different paths.

When Bruce is reading his old college letters to his girlfriend and is cringing with embarrassment, I couldn't help but laugh aloud! I imagine we can all relate to this scene. When we flip through our old journals or notebooks, we realize just how much we've grown and changed.

A large part of this is coming to terms with our insecurities and reducing our ego, a process we all experience as we develop. Stegner captures so beautifully the driving forces and the small details in these moments.

Moments that we may all bury or question if we're the only ones to be so strange and think in such a way. It's reassuring to see Stegner bring these to the light and dismiss them as just an embarrassing recollection. Ha!
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.