Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
41(41%)
4 stars
30(30%)
3 stars
29(29%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More
A coda to “Big Rock Candy Mountain” that was also a sort of “dear john” letter to Salt Lake City after ghosting the town. The nostalgia here leans more towards pain rather than sentiment. At the end of BRCM, I had mixed feelings about Bruce Mason. However, the conclusion of this book and the parallels drawn with his father made me feel sad that he continued to run away. All the reliving of the past seemed to have no impact on a man who failed to learn from the lessons of his mother's life failure.

The Mormon wedding scene is almost ethnographic and is affectionately accurate. It provides a detailed and vivid picture of the Mormon wedding traditions and customs. It shows how important these traditions are to the Mormon community and how they are passed down from generation to generation. The description of the scene makes the reader feel as if they are actually there, witnessing the wedding ceremony. It is a beautiful and touching moment that adds depth and meaning to the story.
July 14,2025
... Show More
As an ardent admirer of Wallace Stegner, I was truly thrilled to discover that he had penned a sequel to "The Big Rock Candy Mountain". While the earlier book lacked the presence of candy, "Recapitulation" is abundant in recall.

Bruce Mason returns to Salt Lake, the city of his youth, to lay to rest his paternal aunt, a relative he scarcely knows and for whom he harbors no affection. Initially, he is "flooded with delighted recollection", but soon finds himself mired in memories of the past 45 years. The young Bruce, determined to escape his father's irascible anger and the shame of his family's illegal business, has since achieved an enviable social standing. However, the former ambassador remains firmly bound to his past, which has a vice-like grip on him.

This story lacks action; instead, all the drama unfolds within Bruce's recollections over the course of approximately a day. The journey back to Salt Lake resurrects unyielding memories, not only of the trivial and sentimental (including adolescent humiliations) but also of deep-seated pain and shame. Bruce realizes that he has unfinished business and old scores to settle with his father. In this sequel, we witness events from "The Big Rock Candy Mountain" from Bruce's perspective and become acquainted with Nola Gordon, the love of his life, and Joe Mulder, his one true friend.

This novel offers an insightful exploration of the workings of memory. As Bruce visits the parts of the city he frequented in his youth, he is struck by the realization that he is no longer the same person, even as he views a familiar past with the same eyes. "New shapes took over from old ones. Memory had to be - didn't it? - a series of overlays."

Thematically, it reminds me of Julian Barnes's "The Sense of An Ending". What one remembers is perhaps, out of necessity and self-preservation, not always a faithful account of the events that actually occurred. In Bruce's experience, recalling the most challenging years of his struggles compels him to rearrange or reshape memories to make them bearable. With Barnes, one is left in suspense and the truth is elusive; with Stegner, the truth defies attempts at reconstruction.

Typical of Stegner's style, there are memorable lines. Regarding his childhood, Bruce remarks: "His childhood had been a disease that had produced no antibodies. Forget for a minute to be humorous or ironic about it, and it could flare up like a chronic sinus." Concerning his destiny and ours, Bruce astutely observes: "...that it is easy enough to recover from a girl, who represents to some extent a choice. It is not so easy to recover from parents, who are fate." Reflecting on lost friendship and love, he states: “What they had once shared was indelible as if carved on a headstone, and was not, after so long a gap, to be changed or renewed.”

Stegner remains true to form in the strength of his prose style. It is always a pleasure to read his superb way with words. As a story, this is less compelling than "The Big Rock Candy Mountain" largely because it is all introspective. Stegner writes of Bruce, "The feelings of that miserable time came out of the gray past and overwhelmed him." It overwhelmed me too.

The ending is not as I had hoped. The last item on Bruce’s checklist, the one I most wanted him to cross off as completed, does not happen. But there is a good reason for this. Because the last thing he chooses and needs to cross off is the Bruce Mason of his youth who “has usurped space in his mind and been a pretender to his feelings". I hope that as he drives out of Salt Lake for the last time, Bruce is preparing to embrace new beginnings.

A Stegner fan can read “Recapitulation” with a renewed appreciation of how well he understands human nature and how he holds up aspects of life that we cannot fail to recognize as reflections of ourselves.
July 14,2025
... Show More
So beautifully written but so depressing and hopeless.

This piece of writing is truly a masterpiece in terms of its literary style. The words are carefully chosen and arranged, creating a vivid and engaging narrative.

However, the content is extremely disheartening. It seems to paint a picture of a world without any hope or light. The characters are trapped in a cycle of despair, and there seems to be no way out.

The author's use of language to convey this sense of hopelessness is both powerful and effective. It makes the reader feel as if they are experiencing the same emotions as the characters in the story.

Despite its beauty, this article leaves a heavy weight on the reader's heart. It makes one wonder if there is really any hope in this world, or if we are all just doomed to a life of depression and hopelessness.

Overall, it is a thought-provoking and moving piece of writing that will stay with the reader long after they have finished reading it.
July 14,2025
... Show More
After reading BIG ROCK CANDY MOUNTAIN, I delved into RECAPITULATION, which chronicles Bruce Mason's return to Salt Lake City after many years. BIG ROCK is filled with so much of Mason's history that it's hard to say how RECAPITULATION would fare on its own. However, having had the privilege of reading BIG ROCK first, RECAPITULATION becomes incredibly compelling. It's as if an unseen wind gently turns the pages for me.

Stegner reminds us that neither our lives nor those of others can be judged in a single encounter. Instead, it takes the understanding of generations to begin to fathom where a person is coming from.

Our lives are astonishingly complex, and Stegner makes us aware that we are not alone in all our thoughts, actions, decisions, and compromises. Even the most self-assured among us likely harbors deep conflicts as we navigate through life. Here, we witness an outwardly extremely successful man who, in the later years of his life, is still fleeing from the shame of his family. This keeps him isolated, like an island, separating him from humanity. It is truly very sad not to feel a part of the whole.

Wallace Stegner is undeniably a master.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I've read a substantial number of books penned by Wallace Stegner, and I have held a great affection for them. However, this particular one failed to capture my heart in the same way.

The plot seemed to lack the kind of depth and excitement that I have come to expect from his works. It meandered along without a clear sense of direction, leaving me feeling rather disengaged.

Similarly, the characters did not possess the vividness and complexity that would have made them truly memorable. They felt somewhat one-dimensional, lacking the nuanced personalities that could have drawn me into their stories.

While I still have a great deal of respect for Wallace Stegner as an author, this particular book was not my favorite. It serves as a reminder that even the most talented writers can have off days, and that not every work will be a masterpiece.
July 14,2025
... Show More

3.75 is an interesting number. It lies between 3 and 4, and can be thought of as a fraction or a decimal. In some contexts, it might represent a measurement, a score, or a quantity. The decimal part, 0.75, can also be written as 3/4. This fraction has various applications in mathematics, such as in fractions and ratios.


Looking at the number 3.75 in a more symbolic way, we can think of it as having different aspects or qualities. The whole number part, 3, represents a certain foundation or base. It could symbolize stability or a starting point. The decimal part, 0.75, adds a degree of flexibility or variation. It might suggest growth or the potential for change.


3.75
July 14,2025
... Show More
I was initially introduced to this remarkable author through his classic, Big Rock Candy Mountain. In this work, the same characters of a boy and his parents persist. Now, the grown-up Bruce Mason returns home to Salt Lake City after the death of an aunt - the last of his living family.

Stegner is truly a master of prose. His lyrical writing style delicately transports you into the world of Mason's past, revolving around the year 1929. Astonishingly, despite the era, Stegner's exploration of his character's thoughts and emotions has the power to resonate with modern readers. The subject matter is truly timeless. Mason faces a past and people that, although painful, signify a crucial period in his life. It is a time when he realizes that he is not fated to repeat the mistakes of his father, but that his life could hold so much more. Recapitulation is a remembrance of the unique events in Bruce Mason's past, yet only Mason himself grasps their significance.

This is a beautiful work, and one that I wholeheartedly recommend.
July 14,2025
... Show More

Stegner has always been one of my favorites. His works are filled with profound reflections that touch the deepest chords of our hearts. The way he crafts his words is nothing short of beautiful. Each sentence seems to be carefully constructed, like a precious piece of art. His stories and ideas have the power to transport us to different worlds and make us see things from a new perspective. Whether it's about nature, human relationships, or the meaning of life, Stegner's insights are always thought-provoking and inspiring. I find myself constantly coming back to his books, eager to discover new layers of meaning and to be moved by his words all over again.

July 14,2025
... Show More
Two years ago, I had an experience that closely resembled the plot of Wallace Stegner’s Recapitulation. After being away for a long time, I made a trip back to my childhood neighborhood for a memorial service. It was very much like the journey of Bruce Mason, the central character of the novel, who returned to Salt Lake City for his aunt’s funeral. Just like Mason’s visit, my trip brought back a flood of childhood memories, some of which were painful. So, when I read Recapitulation, it created a new kind of memory for me (a rather strange memory of memories), which meant the story had a powerful and even visceral impact on me. Reading the novel was indeed a deeply thought-provoking experience.

For example, here is a passage about Bruce Mason that really spoke to me. It sums up the conflicting thoughts that a person has when visiting “home” after being away for decades. “All his impressions suffered from distortion and ambiguity. Looking at buildings, he couldn’t say whether he remembered them or whether his memory was filling the street with things it wanted to be familiar. Though he had been vaguely prepared for changes, he had not foreseen how strangeness and familiarity might fuse. He knew the street but was made uneasy by it. Was that because the person who saw and the person who remembered were not the same, though they used the same eyes?”

This passage is just one of many that had a special meaning for me. However, overall, I found Recapitulation to be somewhat lacking. Although I am a fan of Wallace Stegner, I thought his work here was slow, even tedious and overly wrought. In many cases, reading it was a bit of a struggle for me, despite the presence of many insightful passages. To be fair, the storytelling is realistic. As Stegner says, Mason “feels how the whole disorderly unchronological past hovers just beyond the curtain of the present, attaching itself to any scent, sound, touch, or random word that will let it get back in.” The book is realistic, but “disorderly” (not to mention, painful) is not always enjoyable.

So, was the novel thought-provoking? Absolutely, especially because of my recent parallel journey “home.” Enjoyable? Absolutely not.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I feel an intense connection to this book, as if it was penned specifically for me.

This sense of affinity is only partly because it chronicles the return of a man to his childhood home of Salt Lake City after a prolonged absence, and I happened to start reading it during my first visit to Salt Lake in almost four years.

The book is replete with references to the city, its environs, and its unique culture. I truly can't fathom how someone who didn't grow up along the Wassatch Front could even begin to understand it.

When Stegner describes an approaching thunderstorm as witnessed from the Salt Lake City Cemetery, writing, "The southern end of the Oquirrhs was gone, and a wall of black rain was advancing through Murray," I not only envision the scene with perfect clarity, but I also know precisely how the air feels, what shade the lake呈现, and what the slope of the mountain feels like underfoot.

Moreover, I adore Stegner's description of the Salt Lake Temple as "Spiney as a horned toad."

I'm certain that non-native readers can appreciate "Recapitulation" in the same way I loved "Middlesex" without ever having stepped foot in Detroit, or "Love in the Time of Cholera" without even knowing what Cartagena looks like.

However, Stegner's prose, combined with my own profound nostalgia, has made this book as vivid and real as any I've ever had the pleasure of reading.

July 14,2025
... Show More
The narrator is an elderly gentleman who is on the verge of retirement. He finds himself looking back at his early life, the details of which are familiar to those who have read the author's earlier book, Big Rock Candy Mountain. However, Recapitulation stands alone in a beautifully elegiac manner. Mason delves deep into his memories of a crucial period in his life and the trajectory of his family when he returns to his hometown to bury his aunt, the last surviving member of his entire family.

Not much occurs in terms of outward events. He meets with the funeral home clerk, has dinner, drives slowly down the streets, and refrains from calling on a friend (or perhaps his spouse) who has reached out to him. But as he does so, the years and the memories, the growth, wonder, surprises, and pain of long ago all resurface, coming together to form a moving story that is exquisitely told.

Stegner was indeed a master. His ability to capture the essence of a life and the emotions that come with looking back is truly remarkable. Through Mason's memories, we are able to experience a slice of life that is both universal and deeply personal.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I should have liked this book more.

I had high anticipation for the sequel to “The Big Rock Candy Mountain” as I was extremely eager to know what had happened to Bruce.

The setting in Salt Lake City was very relatable to me as I could vividly picture most of the landmarks, streets, and buildings he described.

I was also intrigued by his frequent references to the “Mormon” church and culture.

The theme of returning to the place where one experienced losing their first love was something I could definitely relate to. I had a similar experience when I went back to the college town where I lost my first love many years later.

I was completely overwhelmed by the flood of emotions I felt just by being in that setting. It brought back all those memories and experiences that I hadn't thought about in years.

Stegner did an excellent job of capturing those emotions and feelings. Returning offers a kind of closure that you might not even be aware you needed.

However, this book was a bit slow and cumbersome for me. I think this is because it was mostly composed of flashbacks, so the present story progressed slowly and it was easy to lose the thread of the story as it wasn't told in chronological order. But then again, that's how memories often come back - not necessarily in a linear fashion.

Interestingly, as I contemplate and review the book, I'm starting to like it better. I think the real problem might be that I'm not intelligent enough to fully appreciate this genius of a writer. He would sometimes lose me, for pages at a time.

I'm sure that if I hadn't had to rush through to return the book to the library and had taken the time to really think through those difficult passages, I would have discovered great depth and spine-tingling truths within. I feel certain of this because that has been the case with every other Stegner book I have read.

Overall, at least for this initial reading, I would rate it 3.5.
 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.