I believe my evaluation of the original version wouldn't be so negative. Surely it wouldn't be a 5, but the drastic 1 here is entirely due to the translation. No disrespect to Luísa Silva Maneiras, who did a great job with what she had at her disposal, but the essence of this book, almost all of it based on wordplay between French and English, is completely lost in the Portuguese version, no matter how hard those involved try. I never took so long to read such a small book, but each chapter was more painful than the other. If you are thinking of buying the book, I recommend that you do so in the original language.
It's truly a pity that the charm and cleverness of the original work couldn't be properly conveyed in the translation. The wordplay, which is likely a significant part of the author's intention and the book's appeal, just doesn't come through in Portuguese. This shows how important accurate translation is in bringing a foreign work to a new audience. For readers who want to fully appreciate the nuances and subtleties of the story, it's essential to read it in the language it was originally written in. In this case, the English or French version would likely offer a much more satisfying reading experience.
"A Year in the Merde" is indeed an extremely fitting title for this truly dreadful book.
The narrator seems to delude himself into believing that he is some sort of James Bond-esque character. However, as the story unfolds, it becomes abundantly clear that he does nothing that is even remotely remarkable or impressive. His sense of self-entitlement appears to stem solely from the fact that he is British.
A prime example of this can be seen right at the start of the chapter titled "Liberté, égalité, get out of my way". It begins with the statement: "On April the first, you understand why the French people admire the British sense of humour: we have one." This kind of attitude is not only off-putting but also shows a lack of self-awareness on the part of the narrator.
Overall, this book earns a meager 0.5 stars. It is not a book that I would recommend to anyone. It fails to engage the reader and offers little in the way of entertainment or meaningful content.