Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
30(30%)
4 stars
38(38%)
3 stars
32(32%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More
Several months ago, I had the opportunity to read Catch-22 for the very first time. To my great surprise, I found it to be a truly remarkable book that fully deserved its well-earned reputation. It was an energetic, entertaining, and deeply satirical exploration of war, with a focus on character development that kept me engaged from start to finish.


What really set this book apart, and perhaps the main reason for some people's dislike of it, was Heller's unique writing style. He had a tendency to jump around in the order of events, often going off on random tangents to explore the personalities of his characters. He also liked to revisit the same situations from different character viewpoints, which didn't always add much to the overall narrative. However, I found that this strange sense of humor and non-linear storytelling actually added to the charm of the book.


The characters in Catch-22 were also quite complex and difficult to follow at times, with new characters being introduced constantly and some having more detailed backstories than others. But despite these challenges, I was able to overlook the strange style and appreciate the book for what it was: a thought-provoking and surprisingly humorous commentary on war.


In conclusion, I would highly recommend Catch-22 to anyone who is interested in reading a unique and engaging novel about war. While it may not be for everyone, I found it to be a truly outstanding work of literature that left a lasting impression on me.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Heller's Catch-22 sequel raises interesting questions about what makes a cult book. It's not just about enthusiasts being overly passionate; it's also about attracting those who don't typically read much. Heller's reprise, set in New York City around the Port Authority Bus Terminal, is a more thoughtful work, but it can't recapture the success of the first novel.

The novel follows some of the earlier characters. Yossarian has had a varied life, including going to college and teaching, but has ended up back working for Milo Minderbender's firm. The chaplain has regained his faith and become of interest to the secret service. Yossarian has an affair and impregnates a nurse, and his favorite child, Michael, is still searching for fulfillment.

The most fully imagined figures are Sammy Singer and Lew. Sammy is a Brooklyn Jew who has a successful marriage, while Lew, a tough guy felled by leukemia, inherits a scrapyard and builds a construction business. Their passages about reflecting on their lives are dispassionate and memorable.

The satire in this book is broader but less effective than in the original. It culminates in a grotesque matrimonial scene and the President starting World War Three by accident. The critique of America's military-industrial complex and inequality feels underwhelming in the Age of Trump. Overall, while the book has its moments, it doesn't quite measure up to the original Catch-22.
July 14,2025
... Show More
**Title: The Importance of Reading**

Reading is an essential activity that offers numerous benefits. It allows us to expand our knowledge, improve our vocabulary, and enhance our cognitive abilities.

When we read, we are exposed to different ideas, cultures, and perspectives, which broadens our understanding of the world. It also helps us to develop empathy and understand the emotions and experiences of others.

Moreover, reading is a great way to relax and unwind. It can transport us to different places and times, and let us escape from the stress and pressures of daily life.

In addition, reading can improve our writing skills. By reading well-written books and articles, we can learn about different writing styles, sentence structures, and grammar rules. This, in turn, can help us to become better writers ourselves.

In conclusion, reading is a valuable activity that should be encouraged and cultivated from an early age. It offers a wealth of benefits that can enhance our lives in many ways. So, pick up a book today and start reading!
July 14,2025
... Show More
Catch-22 was a remarkable work that delved into the lives of a group of soldiers.

These soldiers found themselves embroiled in a plethora of wacky and often absurd situations during World War II.

Closing Time, on the other hand, attempts to build upon the success of the original with a sequel set decades after the humorous first installment.

However, in this endeavor, the book unfortunately loses a significant amount of the unique flavor that characterized the young men in the midst of war.

Rather than being thrust into humorous and lighthearted scenarios, the characters in Closing Time are now filled with a sense of wistfulness and nostalgia for their past.

What remains is a novel that feels overly long, lacking in a cohesive structure, and has lost much of the original appeal that made Catch-22 so beloved.

In my opinion, one can simply read Catch-22 and feel a sense of satisfaction with the conclusion of the characters' stories, without the need for a sequel that fails to recapture the magic of the original.

July 14,2025
... Show More
Epic absurdity and dire pathos

mark Heller's work. He is both hysterical and brilliant simultaneously. The book, without a doubt, has its flaws. However, it actually seems superior to the original as it satirizes the end of an entire world. Its ambition reaches much further than that of its predecessor, which was still great. The world as Heller portrays it is a hollow bacchanal on the verge of total annihilation. Much like Kurt Vonnegut (and the references to him in the text are loved), Heller prefers to cry, laugh, cry, and hopefully cry again. It is unsettling, yet brilliant. Depressing, but a great piece of American writing from one of the late greats. Read it and persevere. It is a maddening frenzy that is worth the journey for the sheer awesome force of literature that it embodies.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I had a distinct feeling that delving into this particular piece of writing wouldn't measure up to the sheer enjoyment I derived from the first one. It simply gave the impression that the absurdity characteristic of the Cold War era hadn't truly taken a different turn within the pages of this book. We currently inhabit an era of "alternative facts," with technology and government increasingly encroaching upon our lives. And yet, this work felt more like an "old man fumbling around the world, making extraneous statements about it." What, then, was the purpose of this book?

If the intention had been to demonstrate that the world, much like Yossarian, remained precisely as it was during the 1950s, then that point was most definitely missed. This was a meandering, convoluted piece that never really managed to make a clear point or convey any meaningful message. It seemed to lack a coherent direction and failed to engage the reader on a deeper level.

Overall, it left me with a sense of disappointment and a longing for something more substantial and thought-provoking.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Hi,

I hope all is progressing well.

Closing Time by Joseph Heller is the much-anticipated sequel to the iconic Catch-22. It delves deep into the lives of both old and new characters, exploring their relationships in great detail. The emphasis on romantic relationships throughout the text adds a layer of complexity and emotional depth. I was drawn to this book because I had thoroughly enjoyed Catch-22. Additionally, the title Closing Time reminded me of the song by Semisonic, which, as it turns out, aligns perfectly with a major theme of the book. The style of Closing Time is similar to that of Catch-22, yet it has a distinct metaphysical quality. It takes on the important task of explaining the outcomes of various characters from the previous book, expanding on developments like Milo's enterprises, and bringing the characters closer to a relatable modernity outside of war, yet still in a war state. What I find particularly interesting about Closing Time is its perspective. It seems to be more in tune with the experiences of a civilian who may not have direct war experience but lives in a world where war is an inescapable part of life. The story connects through familiar characters while exploring a wide range of themes, including militarism, war, governmental and private enterprises, medical conditions related to the environment, the progress and recognition of women, the psycho-social effects of war, the impact of trauma on society, changing times and aging, personalities, sexual relationships, mindful living, employment, hope and faith, the afterlife, immortality through creativity, capitalism, advertising, and entertainment. I truly appreciate the text's awareness of the many issues that plague modern societies today. It's not all doom and gloom, however. The introspection throughout the book offers wonderful insights into the depths of the characters, presenting the world as it is, as it might be, and in comparison to what we know and don't know. I find the writing style to be more prose-poignant than poetic, as I recall feeling in Catch-22. Joseph Heller's writing is as sharp as ever, but it feels as though there is no numbing agent, which works extremely well with the concepts and situations presented. Closing Time is more of a now-that-we-have-a-clear-understanding conversational piece that fits perfectly in connection with and after Catch-22. I highly recommend reading Catch-22 before delving into Closing Time to fully appreciate the depth and context of the story.

Onward and Upward,

Kevin Dufresne

www.Piatures.com

IG: @Dufreshest
July 14,2025
... Show More

While it may not reach the lofty heights of Catch-22, this work is still a highly effective follow-up. It delves back into some of the themes of absurd bureaucracy, which was a prominent feature of the earlier masterpiece. However, it also takes on the broader and more profound question of how one can live in a world that appears to be senseless and cruel. In this latter aspect, the book proves to be a worthy sequel. It reflects both Heller's and his characters' advancing age in an unsentimental manner, yet without being unkind. It shows that as time passes, the challenges and dilemmas of life persist, and the characters must grapple with them in a way that is both realistic and poignant. The book manages to capture the essence of the human condition in a world that often seems to be against us, making it a thought-provoking and engaging read.

July 14,2025
... Show More

It really makes no difference in this situation, but out of a sense of responsibility and humanity, I immediately gave him first aid. I carefully checked his vital signs and did my best to provide the necessary assistance. The whole process was紧张而有序.

Although I'm not a professional medical personnel, I believe that every little bit of help counts.

After that, I told the people around me, "Please go on with what you were doing. Don't let this incident disrupt everything."

I hope that he can recover soon and that this experience will also make everyone more aware of the importance of first aid knowledge.

We should always be prepared to help others in times of need and make our society a better place.

July 14,2025
... Show More
Catch-22 is perhaps my all-time favorite book.

Heller's other works, to some extent, also hold the status of being classic and significant.

However, Closing Time isn't really among those remarkable novels. It serves as a sequel to Catch-22, and like many sequels, it might not have been truly necessary.

On one hand, I can understand what Heller aimed to achieve. He drew a parallel between his own aging and that of Yossarian and the protagonists of the original. We now witness them in their later years, some with grandchildren.

Nevertheless, the humor from the original has transformed into something a bit more bitter, and yet it seems less funny, less sharp, and less rebellious.

It's a tough pill to swallow, especially for someone who is still relatively "young".

I'm willing to give it the benefit of the doubt and plan to reread it someday, perhaps, to determine if my current inability to relate is the issue.

Maybe I'm just angry about what happened to these characters, about how the vitality was drained from them.

Maybe I'm just overly attached to the original.

But on an instinctive level, if not a purely critical one, this just feels like a misstep.

NC
July 14,2025
... Show More
"Closing Time" is an extremely captivating sequel to the renowned "Catch 22". Joseph Heller penned "Closing Time" many years after the publication of "Catch 22" in 1961, with "Closing Time" seeing the light of day in 1994.

If you relished reading "Catch 22", then you are certain to thoroughly enjoy "Closing Time" as well.

"Closing Time" features some of the familiar characters from "Catch 22", such as Yossarian, along with several new ones who were not present in the original.

Joseph Heller's writing style was a unique amalgamation of black humor, satire, and social commentary. He was the sole writer capable of gracefully interweaving characters from Nordic and Germanic mythology, allusions to Wagner operas, and events from 20th-century history in a way that makes readers laugh while simultaneously making them seriously ponder the world we inhabit today.

For those planning to read "Closing Time", it's important to note not to take the story's timeline too literally. Joseph Heller deliberately compressed and stretched years and decades in this book. This distortion of time is an integral part of his writing style, employed throughout the narrative. It adds an otherworldly, fantastical quality to the story, a deliberate choice by Heller. The distortion of the timeline is a complex literary technique, and Heller, one of the most skilled writers of the latter half of the 20th century, uses it effectively in this book. The reasons for his choice to play with the timeline only become evident upon finishing the book. I refrain from revealing more about Heller's use of this technique, as I want readers to be surprised.
July 14,2025
... Show More
If you have already read Catch-22, this book will utterly disappoint you.

If you haven't, it will not make the slightest bit of sense to you.

That is the closest Closing Time comes to Catch-22.

Catch-22 is a renowned and highly influential novel that has left a profound mark on literature. It presents a complex and satirical view of war and bureaucracy.

Closing Time, on the other hand, seems to pale in comparison.

It fails to capture the essence and genius of Catch-22.

The characters in Closing Time lack the depth and complexity of those in Catch-22.

The storylines are not as engaging or thought-provoking.

In conclusion, while Catch-22 is a classic that continues to be widely read and studied, Closing Time falls short and is unlikely to have the same impact on readers.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.