Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
31(31%)
4 stars
33(33%)
3 stars
35(35%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
July 14,2025
... Show More
Dense, radiant, and all too politically familiar.

This is a great part of the trilogy. It is so complex and detailed that I can only read a few pages at a time.

It takes a while to figure out this book. The author has crafted a world that is both captivating and challenging.

The political undertones add an extra layer of depth to the story, making it relevant and thought-provoking.

I find myself constantly stopping to reflect on the events and characters, trying to understand their motives and actions.

Despite the difficulty, I am determined to persevere and uncover the mysteries that lie within these pages.

This book is not for the faint of heart, but for those who are willing to put in the effort, it promises to be a rewarding read.
July 14,2025
... Show More
I was absolutely overjoyed when I chanced upon two Louis de Bernières novels in pristine mint condition at the oppie. What made it even more wonderful was that their covers matched perfectly with my copy of Captain Corelli’s Mandolin, which happens to be one of my all-time favorite books.
July 14,2025
... Show More
A Perfect Novel


A perfect novel is truly a remarkable creation. It begins with the writing, which is of the highest caliber. The author's words flow seamlessly, painting vivid pictures in the reader's mind and evoking a wide range of emotions. The descriptions are detailed and engaging, making it easy for the reader to immerse themselves in the story.


Equally important are the characters. They are well-developed and multi-dimensional, with unique personalities, backstories, and motivations. The reader can't help but become invested in their lives and root for them throughout the novel. Whether it's the heroic protagonist, the charming love interest, or the complex antagonist, each character adds depth and richness to the story.


In conclusion, a perfect novel is a harmonious combination of excellent writing and unforgettable characters. It has the power to transport the reader to another world and leave a lasting impression long after the final page has been turned.
July 14,2025
... Show More
Another book chosen by a member of my book club was truly a terrible read.

It was so bad that I would not only not recommend it to anyone but would actively tell them to avoid it.

The start of the book is a prime example of its flaws. In a very short span, we are introduced to 6 or 7 different characters, bombarded with information about them, and then expected to care and remember who is who as more characters are added. We are told a lot instead of being shown, which is a classic sign of a poor writer.

The voice of the story is another big issue. With a huge cast and extraneous information, the omniscient narrator takes a haughty view, using phrases like 'Our characters' which is annoying. It makes the reader feel distant and less interested.

The tone is supposed to be funny and clever but fails miserably. The over-exaggerated humor falls flat, leaving us unable to even crack a smile.

The author also lists every possibility when describing things, bogging down the narrative and making it hard for the reader not to skip ahead.

The editing is clearly lacking. The rushed beginning, wordy narrative, and drawn-out story could have been improved with a decent editor. Throwing in Spanish words without clear meaning also doesn't help.

The way the book deals with women is also a problem. Every female character's sexual history is known, and they are often described negatively. Wives are called tiresome and boring, and it's implied that it's their fault when their husbands cheat.

To top it off, the book has a stupid title that's only relevant to one chapter and the author can't seem to choose a genre to stick to, resulting in a hopeless mix of loose ends and unsatisfying stories. The only remotely enjoyable part was the middle of the armed forces story arc, but even that was thrown off track by bad humor and the author's inability to be serious.
July 14,2025
... Show More
This is one of my absolute favourite books, and one which I return to time and time again.

My mum had to buy me a new copy of this after she claimed that the original was in fact hers. At least I'm now the owner of a fresh copy rather than the one which has been dropped in the bath repeatedly over the years.

The first part of a trilogy set in South America, this is a magical read. If you're put off reading this because you didn't enjoy Captain Corelli's Mandolin, then don't be - it's completely different and totally captivating.

The trilogy as a whole is ambitious in trying to create a complete world, filled with peasants and politicians, priests and magicians. The author has done an excellent job of bringing this world to life. The characters are well-developed and the story is engaging.

The overall effect is intense, fascinating, and more than a little bonkers. It's a book that will keep you on the edge of your seat from beginning to end. If you're looking for a unique and exciting read, then this trilogy is definitely worth checking out.
July 14,2025
... Show More
The first half of this book was a real struggle to get through.

The perspective shifts constantly, making it extremely difficult to keep track of all the characters.

However, I'm truly glad that I persevered.

This book is a remarkable blend of hilarity, beauty, and profound sadness.

It showcases magic realism at its absolute finest.

The author's ability to seamlessly weave together the ordinary and the extraordinary is truly masterful.

The vivid descriptions and engaging storylines draw the reader in and keep them hooked from beginning to end.

Despite the initial challenges, the rewards of reading this book are well worth it.

It's a literary gem that will stay with you long after you've turned the final page.
July 14,2025
... Show More

Reading this story felt exactly like delving into one of those strange dreams that we often have. Magical realism has always held a certain allure for me, a genre that I initially thought I could never truly embrace or take seriously. However, it has never failed to disappoint. The only reason I'm awarding it a 3-star rating is that there was an abundance of political party, army, general, soldiers, and such related content, which tended to lose my interest. But whenever I read about Aurelio, his wife, and daughter, I was completely captivated. I also had a tough time keeping track of the characters, which was no fault of the book. I was simply distracted at that time, as I had to study for tests and deal with other commitments. Nevertheless, the book was written brilliantly, and I would most definitely read the other two installments that follow.

July 14,2025
... Show More
I'm in two minds whenever I enter a de Beneieres' novel.

I loved Captain's Corelli's Mandolin. Please don't judge this book by the subpar film, and/or Nicolas Cage's joke of a performance.

Yet I loathed Birds Without Wings. And after three swings at the very twee Partisan's Daughter, I eventually struck out without finishing.

However, this novel works. It has a cast of larger than life characters. It's satirical and darkly comical. It also has liberal doses of South American style magical realism.

The story is set in a fictitious South American nation. A country whose incredibly scenic topography is marred by the typical historical problems that have occurred on the continent. Such as corruption, political power plays, the exploiters, and the impoverished exploited.

I won't discuss the plot here. But de Benieres masters the tightrope. A difficult one between light and darkness, the tragic and the comedic.

Recommended for lovers of satire. Also for lovers of rich writing. And - although not truly historical - lovers of historical fiction.
July 14,2025
... Show More
This was the book that the boys of that ill-fated 11th grade English class truly should have read instead of "100 Years of Solitude".


The class discussion, had they read this book, would likely have been identical. In fact, it might even have been more stimulating, especially considering that 7% minority faction who were literally on the wrong page.


Looking back now, it is evident that this alternative book would have been far less profoundly traumatizing.


With a perilously scabbarded tongue, and a touch of cheekiness, this book offers a critique of post-war colonial (sic) American policy in its southern neighbours.


It is a long, tragic sigh of inevitability, highlighting the terrible things that humans do to one another.


Yet, it also has a cosmic sense of humour in the coincidences that occur, perhaps due to the fact that it is a work of fiction.


Overall, it presents a unique and thought-provoking perspective that could have enhanced the learning experience of those 11th grade students.


July 14,2025
... Show More
Loved this!

My first proper taste of magical realism, this satirical take on a Latin American 'everycountry' is truly captivating. It is often enlightening, revealing the hidden aspects of society, sometimes depressing as it shows the harsh realities, yet always amusing with its clever wit and humor.

It feels especially and sadly relevant as the Venezuelan crisis unfolds in early 2019. It is a true demonstration of history repeating itself, as the events in the story seem to mirror the real-life situation.

South American culture is something I've been underexposed to, but I was still able to identify the clichés and tropes that de Bernieres gently mocks. His writing has opened my eyes to that area of the world more, making me eager to explore more writing about Latin history and politics.

I like that the author presents a balanced portrayal of both positive and negative stereotypes of the Latin American way of life. He doesn't simply caricature the region but shows its complexity and diversity.

Would highly recommend this to anyone with a sense of humour and curiosity about South America! It's a fascinating read that will leave you with a deeper understanding and appreciation of the continent.
July 14,2025
... Show More
3 STARS

This is a story that delves into the complex tapestry of life, love, and politics in South America.

The protagonist, Dona Constanza, is a spoilt and haughty woman who, in her quest for luxury, attempts to divert a river to fill her swimming pool. This act sets off a running battle with the locals, who are understandably outraged at this blatant disregard for their rights and the environment.

In response, the Government dispatches a squadron of soldiers led by the fat, brutal, and stupid Figueras to deal with the situation. The story unfolds as these various forces collide, with unexpected consequences.

Although I wasn't initially interested in the subject matter, I have to admit that the writing is well done. The author has managed to create a vivid and engaging world, populated with complex and believable characters. The pacing is good, and the story keeps you hooked from start to finish.

Overall, this is a solid read that I would recommend to anyone looking for a well-written story set in an exotic location.
July 14,2025
... Show More
After reading De Berniere's sweeping historical novels Corelli's Mandolin and Birds Without Feathers,

I am firmly convinced that I have discovered his niche in the magical realism of South America.

He constructs a captivating ensemble of characters, with each story being a precious gem in its own right.

These characters are seamlessly blended with the rich culture, complex politics, and the intrigues of a banana republic that unfold among the majestic mountains and lush jungles of his fictional country.

The element of magic gradually intensifies until the historical narrative transforms into a truly wonderful fantasy.

I eagerly anticipate the remaining installments of this trilogy, excited to explore further the enchanting world that De Berniere has created.

His unique style of writing and ability to merge different elements make his novels a truly immersive and unforgettable reading experience.

I can't wait to see what other surprises and adventures await in the next books.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.