...
Show More
So this took me
a painfully long time to read,
Maybe
because I don’t smoke
Weed.
I’d like to continue this rhyming thought
But,
I’m not Tom Robbins.
And I don’t know how to strangle you with alliteration, assonance, simile, hyperbole, irony, and every other literary device in one hard punch of a sentence.
I’m not saying that’s a bad thing.
For whatever reason, this one didn’t work for me stylistically and, well, racially. I struggled with feeling bogged down by the indulgent, overly verbose slow timing of the story. I kept feeling like there was so much more that could happen…but I never found it…over and over again. So many stupid, dud details.
It was also hard for me to imagine a middle-aged white author trying to embody and sexualize how a half-Asian chick feels in a predominantly white culture in Seattle. Teriyaki anyone? Seattle likes teriyaki; they just don’t like Asians. Robbins merely glances this issue (even though the protagonist is half Asian) with his own elitist rant:
“Nowadays, however, it seems few immigrants are inclined to assimilate. They bring their native cultures with them, virtually intact, cling to them, refusing even to learn to speak English and get angry when the social institutions of their adopted land fail to address them in their indigenous tongues. Which keeps them out of the work force, naturally, and in a state of victimization; a selfish, self-pitying, self-perpetuating state insidiously exploited by leftists for their own political ends. Thus, instead of a strong, nutritious broth, pungent with the aromatic spices of labor and success, America has become a plop of separate little lumps of undigested stuff. Kind of like—vomit. Good-bye, melting pot, hello, chamber pot.”
Ahem, why SHOULD immigrants cling to anything other than their own culture, their own comfort, when historically, white Americans have been less than welcoming to any immigrant that isn’t blond and blue eyed? Maybe Robbins needs to read Zinn?
Robbins’ descriptions and perceptions of Seattle have not changed since this was written more than 20 years ago. Which is indicative of a stagnant mindset within this local population. I read the first half of this book thinking…”these descriptions of Seattle could have been written today.” Sad, because I have come across so many people in WA who act like the things he describes in this book are recent phenomenons, recent social ills. “Seattle was always like THIS! Never like THAT!” “It’s because of the minorities that it’s now like THAT!” Robbins descriptions in this book prove otherwise.
Turns out, Seattle and WA have always been like THAT. The “Seattle freeze” is code for racism. And Seattle has always had a drug and homeless issue because it is a white po’ dunk state. It’s just unfortunate that Robbins needs to hide behind the guise of a minority female Asian (Filipino) character to get his points across.
I guess he wasn’t brave enough to take on a character from the Japanese American population who were run out of WA during the Japanese internment. Because, you know, you can’t go after Teriyaki in Seattle.
a painfully long time to read,
Maybe
because I don’t smoke
Weed.
I’d like to continue this rhyming thought
But,
I’m not Tom Robbins.
And I don’t know how to strangle you with alliteration, assonance, simile, hyperbole, irony, and every other literary device in one hard punch of a sentence.
I’m not saying that’s a bad thing.
For whatever reason, this one didn’t work for me stylistically and, well, racially. I struggled with feeling bogged down by the indulgent, overly verbose slow timing of the story. I kept feeling like there was so much more that could happen…but I never found it…over and over again. So many stupid, dud details.
It was also hard for me to imagine a middle-aged white author trying to embody and sexualize how a half-Asian chick feels in a predominantly white culture in Seattle. Teriyaki anyone? Seattle likes teriyaki; they just don’t like Asians. Robbins merely glances this issue (even though the protagonist is half Asian) with his own elitist rant:
“Nowadays, however, it seems few immigrants are inclined to assimilate. They bring their native cultures with them, virtually intact, cling to them, refusing even to learn to speak English and get angry when the social institutions of their adopted land fail to address them in their indigenous tongues. Which keeps them out of the work force, naturally, and in a state of victimization; a selfish, self-pitying, self-perpetuating state insidiously exploited by leftists for their own political ends. Thus, instead of a strong, nutritious broth, pungent with the aromatic spices of labor and success, America has become a plop of separate little lumps of undigested stuff. Kind of like—vomit. Good-bye, melting pot, hello, chamber pot.”
Ahem, why SHOULD immigrants cling to anything other than their own culture, their own comfort, when historically, white Americans have been less than welcoming to any immigrant that isn’t blond and blue eyed? Maybe Robbins needs to read Zinn?
Robbins’ descriptions and perceptions of Seattle have not changed since this was written more than 20 years ago. Which is indicative of a stagnant mindset within this local population. I read the first half of this book thinking…”these descriptions of Seattle could have been written today.” Sad, because I have come across so many people in WA who act like the things he describes in this book are recent phenomenons, recent social ills. “Seattle was always like THIS! Never like THAT!” “It’s because of the minorities that it’s now like THAT!” Robbins descriptions in this book prove otherwise.
Turns out, Seattle and WA have always been like THAT. The “Seattle freeze” is code for racism. And Seattle has always had a drug and homeless issue because it is a white po’ dunk state. It’s just unfortunate that Robbins needs to hide behind the guise of a minority female Asian (Filipino) character to get his points across.
I guess he wasn’t brave enough to take on a character from the Japanese American population who were run out of WA during the Japanese internment. Because, you know, you can’t go after Teriyaki in Seattle.