...
Show More
Ah Mr Roth, how you entertained and confounded me with this book. This book also served as a sort of stupidity graph for me, highlighting where my knowledge of early 20th century American History and Politics has a gaping hole.
Is it a hole in a sock sized hole? An oops, my-car-was-just- swallowed-up-by-this-big-hole sized hole? Or a Guatemala City sink hole sized hole? Well, the hole in my knowledge is probably about the size of the car swallowing hole which is still quite sizeable. I feel ashamed (ashamed face). To counter that shame there is also the caveat that I am easily confused.
Being brought up in the UK and at the mercy of the comprehensive school education system, we had the facts of World War I and World War II hammered into us from the ages of 13 to 16 but generally only focusing on the European perceptions and involvement, as you might expect. America did feature in the lessons and lectures - the depression, seers roebuck, the wall street crash, Warren Harding, Coolidge, Hoover and Roosevelt all got a look-in but probably not in the detailed way that they should have. Between the ages of 16 and 18 it was optional if you wished the hammering of history to continue. I can probably name every treaty and anschluss and every palace that every treaty was signed in. Obviously very helpful factoids which I have used many times over in my adult life....
Therefore, because of the hazy mist that surrounds my knowledge of this period in America I found myself checking on the internet to figure out where fact met fiction in this brilliant book. The Plot Against America depicts growing feelings of anti-Semitism in the USA which began to develop in tandem with the increase in Nazi Power in Europe. Similar anti Semitic feelings and issues are dealt with in a different way in The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay by Michael Chabon. Roth presents us with an America where Franklin Delano Roosevelt has been beaten in the electoral race by Charles Lindbergh, thereby creating a "what if this happened and where would we be now" look at an alternative history. Note: This book will not confuse you at all if you know your actual history/ are American/ live in America/ Are over the age of 65!
I have enjoyed all the Philip Roth books I've read (introduced to him through the joys of the 1001 books to read before you die list)and this one was no exception. To the people who say that American Pastoral is his best book (with all that glove making - really?), I have to disagree!
Is it a hole in a sock sized hole? An oops, my-car-was-just- swallowed-up-by-this-big-hole sized hole? Or a Guatemala City sink hole sized hole? Well, the hole in my knowledge is probably about the size of the car swallowing hole which is still quite sizeable. I feel ashamed (ashamed face). To counter that shame there is also the caveat that I am easily confused.
Being brought up in the UK and at the mercy of the comprehensive school education system, we had the facts of World War I and World War II hammered into us from the ages of 13 to 16 but generally only focusing on the European perceptions and involvement, as you might expect. America did feature in the lessons and lectures - the depression, seers roebuck, the wall street crash, Warren Harding, Coolidge, Hoover and Roosevelt all got a look-in but probably not in the detailed way that they should have. Between the ages of 16 and 18 it was optional if you wished the hammering of history to continue. I can probably name every treaty and anschluss and every palace that every treaty was signed in. Obviously very helpful factoids which I have used many times over in my adult life....
Therefore, because of the hazy mist that surrounds my knowledge of this period in America I found myself checking on the internet to figure out where fact met fiction in this brilliant book. The Plot Against America depicts growing feelings of anti-Semitism in the USA which began to develop in tandem with the increase in Nazi Power in Europe. Similar anti Semitic feelings and issues are dealt with in a different way in The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay by Michael Chabon. Roth presents us with an America where Franklin Delano Roosevelt has been beaten in the electoral race by Charles Lindbergh, thereby creating a "what if this happened and where would we be now" look at an alternative history. Note: This book will not confuse you at all if you know your actual history/ are American/ live in America/ Are over the age of 65!
I have enjoyed all the Philip Roth books I've read (introduced to him through the joys of the 1001 books to read before you die list)and this one was no exception. To the people who say that American Pastoral is his best book (with all that glove making - really?), I have to disagree!